Milwaukee's Best Corned Beef Sandwich [Updated 2025]

Along the way, I've devoured countless sandwiches, each bite bringing me closer to the ultimate corned beef experience. After meticulously reviewing 12 of the top spots in the city, I can confidently say that Milwaukee has some serious contenders when it comes to this classic deli delight.

You might wonder why you should take my word for it; well, let’s just say I’ve tasted enough corned beef to know when it’s a cut above the rest! Whether you’re a lifelong lover of this savory treat or a curious newcomer, I promise you’ll find a perfect pairing for your palate in this vibrant city. Ready to sink your teeth into some mouthwatering goodness? Let’s dive in!

Benji's Deli & Restaurant

Highlights
Classic diner atmosphere
Friendly and attentive service
Fast food preparation
Delicious, lean corned beef
All-day breakfast options

Review of Benji's Deli & Restaurant

As I strolled into Benji's Deli & Restaurant, I was instantly enveloped by a classic diner atmosphere that felt like a warm embrace. The lively chatter and friendly staff created a delightful backdrop for my corned beef journey. I’ve visited my fair share of delis, but this gem truly stood out.

The service was not just friendly; it was attentive, making me feel right at home as I nestled into a cozy booth. When my corned beef sandwich arrived, I couldn’t help but admire its striking presentation. The lean corned beef was generously piled high, promising an adventure of flavors.

As I took my first bite, the tender meat practically melted in my mouth, with just the right balance of spices. Its savory richness was simply unparalleled, making every nibble an absolute treat. And for the breakfast enthusiasts out there, the all-day breakfast options are a cherry on top of an already enticing menu.

In my quest for Milwaukee's best corned beef sandwich, Benji's has certainly carved its place in my heart. With a measure of love in every bite, it’s a must-visit for any deli aficionado!

You might also want to check out the best reuben sandwich in Milwaukee.

Mae Velma's Corned Beef

Highlights
Tender, flavorful corned beef
Reuben sandwich is a must-try
Local gem in Milwaukee
Potential food truck plans
New lunch spot for many

Mae Velma's Corned Beef is a delightful local gem that took my taste buds on a flavorful journey. From the moment I walked in, the aroma of slow-cooked corned beef filled the air, instantly raising my expectations. I opted for the Reuben sandwich, which is a must-try for anyone who considers themselves a fan of this iconic dish.

The corned beef was remarkably tender, melting in my mouth with each bite. It was paired perfectly with fresh, tangy sauerkraut and a generous layer of creamy, house-made dressing, all snuggled between two slices of perfectly toasted rye bread. Every aspect was thoughtfully crafted, making it evident that Mae Velma’s takes pride in their offerings.

What’s exciting is that this spot could soon have a food truck, expanding its reach beyond the cozy eatery. This means more people will have the chance to savor their incredible sandwiches. If you're looking for a new lunch spot, Mae Velma's Corned Beef should top your list for a satisfying meal that celebrates the rich tradition of corned beef like no other. Don't miss out on this delicious adventure!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Benji's Deli

Highlights
Fantastic corned beef
Warm and inviting atmosphere
Great value for your money
Delicious potato salad
Authentic Israeli deli experience

Benji's Deli is a hidden gem in Milwaukee, and let me tell you, their corned beef sandwich is nothing short of spectacular! The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere that instantly made me feel at home. The aroma of freshly cooked meats filled the air, and I knew I was in for a treat.

Now, let’s talk about that corned beef. It arrived piled high on perfectly toasted rye bread, its rich, savory flavor bursting with each bite. The meat was tender and seasoned just right, making for a delightful experience that’s hard to beat. What truly blew my mind was the great value—you get so much deliciousness for your dollar.

To accompany my sandwich, I opted for their potato salad, which was the ideal sidekick; creamy and flavorful without overshadowing the star of the show. Each bite felt like a visit to an authentic Israeli deli, a testament to the skill and care that goes into their food.

If you're in search of the best corned beef sandwich in Milwaukee, look no further than Benji's Deli. You’ll leave with a satisfied palate and a smile on your face, guaranteed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Mae Velma's Corned Beef (Teutonia/Capitol)

Highlights
Disappointing meat portion
Loaded with fat
Good wings
Well-seasoned fries

Mae Velma's Corned Beef truly has a vibrant atmosphere that invites you in with its neighborhood charm. When I heard about their corned beef sandwich, I arrived with excitement that quickly turned into disappointment. The corned beef was, unfortunately, lacking in quantity, doubting whether I had truly ordered a “sandwich” at all!

The meat was generously marbled with a touch too much fat, which some may enjoy, but I prefer my corned beef leaner and more succulent. Each bite didn’t quite have the satisfying texture I sought, leaving me yearning for that perfect balance.

However, it wasn't all a culinary letdown; their wings were surprisingly good! Crispy and flavorful, these wings were a delightful diversion from the main event. The well-seasoned fries that accompanied my meal also offered a satisfying crunch, making me question if perhaps I had come for the wrong dish altogether.

In a city famed for its deli scene, Mae Velma's delivered merely a mediocre corned beef sandwich. With its inviting atmosphere, it still might be worth a visit, but I'd recommend focusing your order on those wings instead!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

Megawich - The Ultimate Sandwich

Highlights
Fast and friendly service
Fresh and hot sandwiches
Chewy, crispy bread
Tasty fries
Needs better cheese sauce

At Megawich - The Ultimate Sandwich, I felt like a kid in a candy store for sandwich lovers. The friendly staff greeted me with smiles and quick service, making it clear that they love what they do. As the aroma of fresh bread filled the air, I could hardly contain my excitement. I went straight for the corned beef sandwich, and when it arrived, it was hot and fresh, showcasing their commitment to quality.

The bread was nothing short of spectacular, boasting a perfect balance between chewy and crispy. Each bite felt like a delightful embrace, with the corned beef expertly piled high — flavorful and tender, it practically melted in my mouth. The sandwich was served alongside some delicious fries, crispy and seasoned to perfection.

However, while the sandwich was superb, I felt the cheese sauce could use a little extra love to elevate the overall experience. Nevertheless, the combination of flavors at Megawich could make anyone consider it among the best in town. I left feeling satisfied, and I can't wait to return for another bite of that stellar corned beef creation!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Riley's Sandwich Co.

Highlights
Friendly and helpful staff
Unique indoor dining experience
Dog-friendly with pet menu
Flavorsome food options
Variety of sandwich choices

Riley's Sandwich Co. in Milwaukee, oh my goodness! Walking through the doors, I was embraced by a welcoming atmosphere that instantly made me feel at home. The staff—super friendly and attentive—ensured that I was well taken care of as I reviewed their extensive menu. I had my heart set on the corned beef sandwich, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint!

Served on fresh, crusty rye, the corned beef was perfectly seasoned and piled high. Each bite was a delightful medley bursting with flavor, perfectly complemented by a splash of tangy mustard. While indulging in this savory delight, I admired the unique indoor dining experience—a mix of modern decor and rustic charm that kept the ambiance lively.

What also caught my eye was the opportunity for a dog-friendly experience. They even have a special pet menu! It’s not just about the food; it’s about the vibe at Riley’s! With a variety of other sandwich choices on offer, I might just have to come back for a second round. If you’re hunting for an exceptional corned beef sandwich in Milwaukee, look no further than Riley's!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

House of Corned Beef

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, House of Corned Beef serves up a sandwich that’s nothing short of a celebration. The moment I took a bite, the tender, flavorful brisket practically melted in my mouth. Coupled with their house-made mustard and crisp pickles, each bite was a delightful explosion of flavor. The marbled rye is freshly baked, adding the perfect texture balance. The generous portion size guarantees that no one leaves hungry. If you’re hunting for corned beef bliss, this spot is a must-visit. Deliciously satisfying—a true standout in the Milwaukee sandwich scene!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

Top Corned Beef

At Top Corned Beef, the moment I sank my teeth into their sandwich, I was transported to corned beef heaven! The generous layers of tender, flavorful meat were perfectly complemented by their house-made mustard and fresh rye bread. Each bite was a harmonious blend of textures and tastes. The ambiance was casual and welcoming, making it a perfect spot for a satisfying lunch. If you're searching for the ultimate corned beef experience in Milwaukee, this gem is not to be missed. Trust me, you’ll be craving more long after the last bite!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

Deli 1614 | “That Corned Beef Place”

My taste buds danced with delight as I sunk my teeth into the corned beef sandwich at Deli 1614. The beef was perfectly tender, seasoned with a magic blend of spices that transported me straight to flavor heaven. Nestled between two slices of freshly baked rye, this sandwich was a delightful harmony of textures and tastes. The classic deli mustard added just the right zing, elevating each bite. With generous portions and a vibrant atmosphere, it’s no wonder this place is dubbed “That Corned Beef Place.” If you’re a corned beef aficionado, this spot deserves a place on your culinary map!

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

Jake's Deli

Jake's Deli in Milwaukee delivers a corned beef sandwich that’s nothing short of a flavor revelation. The moment I unwrapped my hefty delight, the aroma of perfectly seasoned meat filled the air, promising a taste explosion. Each bite revealed tender, juicy layers of corned beef, complemented by just the right amount of zesty mustard and crisp pickles. The rye bread held it all together, providing a delightful, toasted crunch. With generous portions and a welcoming atmosphere, Jake’s is a must-visit for any sandwich lover. Trust me, this is where Corned Beef Dreams come true!

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

Mae Velma's Corned Beef (Teutonia ave)

Mae Velma's Corned Beef on Teutonia Avenue is a delightful gem that had me grinning from ear to ear. The corned beef sandwich is a heavenly medley of tender, marbled meat piled high on fresh rye bread. Each bite delivers a luscious blend of spices, perfectly complemented by tangy mustard and a crisp pickle on the side. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff add to the experience, making it feel like coming home. If you’re on the hunt for the best corned beef sandwich in Milwaukee, Mae Velma's is an absolute must-try! Don’t miss out on this flavor-packed delight!

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

McBob's Pub & Grill

At McBob's Pub & Grill, the corned beef sandwich is an absolute delight! Nestled between perfectly toasted rye, the generous portions of tender, juicy beef practically melt in your mouth. The house-made mustard adds a tangy kick that perfectly complements the savory flavors. I appreciated the sandwich's balance—not too greasy, yet satisfyingly hearty. Plus, the cozy pub atmosphere makes it the ideal spot to savor this classic dish. If you’re on the hunt for corned beef bliss, McBob’s deserves a spot on your list. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you for this delicious detour!

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.