Milwaukee's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

After devouring slices from twelve of the top pizzerias in town, I’m ready to dish out my favorites that will make your taste buds dance. Each bite tells a story—from the crispy crust that crackles beneath a blanket of gooey cheese to the vibrant toppings that add a burst of flavor.

You can trust me on this; I’ve sampled everything from classic pepperoni to unique gourmet creations, all in the name of pizza perfection. Whether you’re a lifelong Milwaukeean or just passing through, I’ve got the inside scoop on where to find the best pies that’ll have you coming back for more. Let’s dive into the mouthwatering world of Milwaukee pizza!

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

Highlights
Incredible Neapolitan style pizza
Friendly and attentive service
Wood-fired cooking excellence
Light and airy dough
Fun seating around pizza oven

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana is a delightful gem that truly captures the essence of Neapolitan-style pizza. As I stepped inside, the aroma of wood-fired cooking enveloped me, instantly igniting my excitement. The atmosphere is vibrant, with playful seating around the open pizza oven, adding to the whole experience.

I opted for their classic Margherita, and let me tell you, the dough was a revelation. Light and airy, it had that perfect char that only a wood-fired oven can achieve. Each bite was a harmonious blend of fresh mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and fragrant basil, transporting me straight to Naples—if only for a moment.

The service was as delightful as the pizza itself. The staff was not just attentive but genuinely enthusiastic about the menu, ready to guide me through my choices. Their passion for pizza is infectious!

Overall, San Giorgio stands out in Milwaukee’s bustling pizza scene. With exceptional attention to detail in both preparation and customer experience, it's a must-visit for anyone seeking a slice of pizza perfection. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, do yourself a favor and indulge in the magic of San Giorgio. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Transfer Pizzeria Café

Highlights
Cool historic pharmacy setting
Tasty cracker crust pizza
Excellent and personable service
Accommodating staff
Mixed reviews on pizza quality

Transfer Pizzeria Café is a delightful gem nestled in a historic setting, once an old pharmacy, that instantly draws you in with its charm. As I walked in, the ambiance welcomed me warmly, making it a perfect spot for a pizza pilgrimage. What truly sets Transfer apart is their unique cracker crust, which offers a satisfying crunch with each bite—it's a distinctive touch that makes their pizzas stand out in the sea of Milwaukee's pizza offerings.

The service here is just as remarkable; the staff were not only personable, but also incredibly accommodating, ensuring my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional. However, it's worth mentioning that the reviews on pizza quality seem to be a mixed bag. My personal pie was delightful with a fresh assortment of toppings that complemented the crispy crust beautifully, though I sensed some inconsistency on other plates nearby.

All in all, if you're searching for a slice of what's good in Milwaukee, Transfer Pizzeria Café deserves a spot on your list. Its idiosyncratic vibe combined with a one-of-a-kind crust might just make you a repeat visitor. Each visit feels like an adventure, and I can't wait to return for another round!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Balistreri's Bluemound Inn

Highlights
Fantastic tomato relish
Top-notch calamari
Delicious pizza options
Mixed service experiences
Cozy atmosphere

Balistreri's Bluemound Inn is not just another pizza joint; it’s a culinary gem tucked away in Milwaukee that has a rich heritage and a knack for whipping up some truly magnificent pies. As I settled into the cozy atmosphere, it was hard to ignore the enticing aroma wafting through the air, which set the perfect stage for a memorable dining experience.

What immediately caught my attention was their fantastic tomato relish—it’s a whimsical twist that added a delightful zing to every bite. I paired my pizza with their top-notch calamari, which was beautifully seasoned and tender, making it hard to resist ordering a second round.

The pizza options here are nothing short of delicious. Each slice brought a perfect balance of toppings and a lovingly crafted crust that boasted just the right amount of chew. My only quibble was the mixed service experiences; while some staff members were friendly and attentive, a couple of interactions felt a bit off-key. Nevertheless, these minor hiccups didn’t overshadow the culinary delights that Balistreri’s served.

In a city brimming with pizza options, Balistreri's Bluemound Inn stands out—not only for its incredible flavors but also for its charming ambiance. If you’re looking for an exquisite pizza experience, this is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

Santino's Little Italy

Highlights
Homemade pasta and sauces
Exceptional wine selection
Great for family outings
Charming and relaxing ambiance
Reservation recommended

Santino's Little Italy has become a delightful favorite of mine during my quest for the best pizza in Milwaukee. Walking into this charming eatery immediately transports you to the heart of Italy, complete with a relaxing ambiance that beckons you to unwind. The delicious smell of homemade pasta and sauces fills the air, creating an irresistible welcome that sets the stage for the culinary adventure ahead.

Their pizza, a delightful masterpiece, boasts a perfectly thin crust, expertly baked to a golden crisp while still maintaining a soft, chewy interior. Topped with a blend of fresh ingredients, each slice tantalizes the palate with flavors that dance together in harmony. You simply cannot resist a second slice, or perhaps even a third!

Moreover, their exceptional wine selection pairs beautifully with the pizza, enhancing the overall dining experience. Santino’s is also an excellent choice for family outings, offering a relaxed vibe that keeps everyone happy. Just a note—reservations are recommended, as this gem tends to fill up quickly!

In short, if you're seeking a memorable pizza experience in Milwaukee, Santino's Little Italy is a destination that promises both flavor and ambiance in every bite. Treat yourself—you won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Alphonso's | The Original Pizzeria

Highlights
Giant mozzarella sticks
Nostalgic and happy atmosphere
Delicious and fresh pizza
Friendly and engaging staff
Unique memorabilia and decor

Upon entering Alphonso's | The Original Pizzeria, I was immediately enveloped in a nostalgic atmosphere that felt both inviting and delightfully familiar. With walls adorned in unique memorabilia, this place has a charm that transports you back to simpler times—perfect for a good pizza night!

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the pizza! Each slice is a testament to freshness, topped generously with gooey mozzarella that stretches to joyous lengths. The crust strikes an impeccable balance: crispy on the outside yet soft and pillowy within. You can taste the love in every bite!

And before pizza, I simply couldn't resist the giant mozzarella sticks—they're virtually a meal in themselves! Served hot with a side of marinara, they're the perfect way to set the stage for what’s about to come.

Moreover, the friendly staff truly enhance the experience, offering engaging service that makes you feel valued. Whether you're here for a casual meal or a family gathering, Alphonso's brings people together with great food and a welcoming vibe. For anyone searching for Milwaukee's best pizza, this place deserves your time and taste buds!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

Zaffiro's Pizza The Original

Highlights
Thin crispy crust
Solid sausage flavor
Sweet sauce blend
Good lunch specials
Friendly service

Zaffiro's Pizza The Original has a special place in my heart—and my stomach. As soon as I stepped inside, the friendly service made me feel right at home. But let’s get to the star of the show: the pizza! The thin crispy crust was an absolute revelation, perfectly baked to achieve that delightful crunch that pairs beautifully with every topping.

As I savored my slice, the solid sausage flavor stood out, delivering just the right amount of savory goodness without overpowering the other flavors. Speaking of which, the sauce was a delightfully sweet blend that danced on my taste buds, giving each bite a little something extra.

Don’t miss out on their good lunch specials—they’re both wallet-friendly and delicious, making it hard to resist going back for more. Overall, Zaffiro's hits the mark on flavor and experience. If you’re in Milwaukee and craving a slice of heaven, this is one place you won’t want to bypass. Trust me, you’ll leave with a smile and a satisfied appetite, and that’s what pizza is all about!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

State Street Pizza Pub

Highlights
Warm and friendly atmosphere
Delicious fresh ingredients
Great for casual meals
Lots of beer options
Unique robot food service

State Street Pizza Pub never fails to impress with its warm and welcoming atmosphere—a superb spot where you instantly feel at home. Upon stepping inside, I was greeted by the enticing aroma of freshly baked dough, setting the stage for a delightful pizza experience. One bite of their signature pizza, adorned with mouthwatering fresh ingredients, and I was instantly hooked. The harmonious blend of flavors dances on your palate, a reminder of why pizza can be so sublime!

What truly sets State Street apart is their unique robot food service. Watching a little mechanical marvel navigate the room with your food is a playful twist that adds to the overall experience. Plus, the pub features an impressive array of craft beer options, making it the perfect accompaniment to a slice (or three) of your favorite pie.

For those seeking a casual dining experience that caters to pizza aficionados and novices alike, this spot is a gem. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or planning a meetup with friends, State Street Pizza Pub is undeniably one of Milwaukee’s best pizza places. Come for the pizza, stay for the fun! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

Calderone Club - Downtown Milwaukee

Highlights
Phenomenal Italian Cuisine
Attentive and Friendly Service
Great Pre-Concert Dinner
Authentic Old-Style Dishes
Reasonably Priced Wine

After indulging in the delightful offerings at Calderone Club - Downtown Milwaukee, I confidently declare it a hidden gem among the city's pizza landscape. Nestled conveniently for concert-goers, this spot serves up phenomenal Italian cuisine that truly tantalizes the taste buds. From the moment I walked in, the attentive and friendly service made me feel right at home, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience.

Now, onto the star of the show: the pizza! Their selection showcases authentic old-style dishes that transport you straight to Italy with each bite. The crust is that perfect balance of crispy and chewy, holding up beautifully under the weight of rich, zesty toppings. Pair your pizza with one of their reasonably priced wines, and you've got a match made in culinary heaven.

In the spirit of full disclosure, I highly recommend making it a pre-concert dinner destination, as the ambiance is lively and inviting, ensuring you’re pumped for the evening ahead. So, if you find yourself craving some top-notch pizza, look no further than Calderone Club—it is a slice of paradise right in the heart of Milwaukee! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

Brick 3 Pizza

Highlights
Great quality at decent prices
Comfortable seating options
Peaceful dining environment
Quick, hot, and fresh delivery
Many delicious options available

When I stepped into Brick 3 Pizza, I was immediately struck by the inviting atmosphere. The combination of comfortable seating and a peaceful dining environment made me feel right at home, setting the perfect stage for a delightful pizza experience. What caught my attention was not just the ambiance, but also the quality of the food that matched its reasonable prices.

I decided to try their signature pizza, and when it arrived, I was wowed; it was hot, fresh, and bursting with flavor. Each bite was a delightful treat, showcasing a perfect harmony of toppings that didn't overpower the crust. Speaking of the crust, it was just the right balance of crispy and chewy, reflecting their dedication to quality standards.

Plus, if you're in a hurry, Brick 3 offers quick delivery that ensures your pizza arrives just as hot as if you were dining in. With a variety of delicious options available, I'm impressed by how they cater to different tastes while maintaining such high standards.

For anyone seeking a great slice in Milwaukee, I highly recommend stopping by this gem. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

Fixture Pizza Pub

During my visit to Fixture Pizza Pub, I found a delightful blend of flavors that truly captured my palate’s attention. The crust was perfectly crisp, with just the right amount of chew, providing an excellent base for their unique toppings. I indulged in the house special, which boasted a sweet and tangy sauce, complemented by vibrant vegetables and quality cheese that melted beautifully. The inviting atmosphere and friendly service added to the overall experience. If you’re looking for fun and flavorful pizza, Fixture is a must-visit spot that beautifully illustrates Milwaukee’s thriving pizza scene! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.

Maggio's Wood Fired Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Maggio's Wood Fired Pizza dazzles with its artisan pies cooked to perfection in a roaring oven. The thin, crispy crust is a testament to their wood-fired technique, providing an irresistible char that complements the fresh, quality toppings. I indulged in the Margherita, and each bite was a harmonious blend of zesty tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and fragrant basil. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a casual night out. For pizza aficionados, Maggio’s is a delightful gem that proves wood-fired magic is alive and well in Milwaukee!

You might also want to check out the best prime rib in Milwaukee.

Classic Slice

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Classic Slice serves up a delightful array of New York-style pizza that feels both nostalgic and innovative. The crust strikes that perfect balance between crisp and chewy, inviting you to savor each bite. I opted for their signature "Classic Cheese", which boasted a rich tomato sauce and a heavenly blend of cheeses that melted together like a cozy blanket. The ambiance is casual yet charming, making it a perfect spot for a laid-back meal. If you’re in search of a slice that hits the spot, Classic Slice should top your list—it's an absolute gem!

You might also want to check out the best gluten free restaurants in Milwaukee.