Waukesha's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

Trust me when I say, this quest for the best pizza in Waukesha has been a delicious adventure! I’ve explored 12 of the top spots, savoring every slice and crust variation along the way. Whether it’s a classic pepperoni, a gourmet twist, or that perfect chewy crust, I’ve tasted it all to uncover the true gems.

As a local who’s spent countless evenings indulging in pizza, I know what makes a pie stand out. It’s about more than just toppings; it’s the atmosphere, the passion, and that unforgettable first bite. So, if you’re ready to discover where to grab your next slice, you’re in the right place!

Mia's

Highlights
Friendly and attentive staff
Laid-back atmosphere
Charred crust pizza option
Mixed reviews on food quality
Clean seating with good spacing

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Mia's in Waukesha, where the atmosphere exudes a charming laissez-faire vibe that immediately put me at ease. The friendly and attentive staff welcomed me like an old friend—a perfect start to any dining experience.

As I browsed their menu, I couldn’t resist the allure of their charred crust pizzas. When my pie arrived, it was a sight to behold: a beautifully golden crust with that tantalizing charred perfection that sings to pizza lovers everywhere. The flavor was rich and satisfying, although I must admit that I’ve heard mixed reviews about the overall food quality, which gave me pause. Still, my first slice was enough to make me a fan.

The seating is neat and spacious, allowing for a relaxed meal either solo or with friends. While my pizza was delightful, I appreciated that the atmosphere was equally friendly and far from rushed.

If you find yourself in Waukesha, don’t miss out on Mia's. It embodies a playful spirit that complements its delicious pizza. You're bound to leave with a full belly and a smile!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Tally's Tap & Eatery

Highlights
Great pizza and Italian beef
Vibrant and festive atmosphere
Unique Garlic Parm fries
Generous fish fry options
Great staff and beer lineup

Tally's Tap & Eatery is a delightful gem that transcends the ordinary pizza experience in Waukesha. Upon entering, I was immediately struck by the vibrant and festive atmosphere—perfect for gathering with friends or enjoying a casual night out.

Now, let's talk pizza. Tally's serves up some truly exceptional pies, cleverly paired with an Italian beef that makes for a savory journey. Each slice boasts a crisp crust, lovingly topped with fresh ingredients that sing of quality. The creativity doesn’t stop there; their unique Garlic Parm fries are a must-try, complementing the pizza perfectly—I found myself reaching for more after the first bite!

But Tally’s isn’t just about the pizza; they offer a generous selection of fish fry options and a robust beer lineup that pairs beautifully with their food. The friendly and attentive staff round out the experience, ensuring that your visit is nothing short of delightful.

If you’re searching for pizza that brings both flavor and fun to the table, look no further than Tally’s Tap & Eatery. It’s a spot that I’ll surely return to, craving more of that pizza magic! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Waukesha

Highlights
Delicious toasted ravioli
Family-friendly dining experience
Tasty portobello lugiosi pizza
Cozy atmosphere for dining
Variety of menu options

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Waukesha offers a delightful experience that goes beyond just cheesy goodness. The moment I stepped in, I was welcomed by a cozy atmosphere that immediately put me at ease. With the laughter of families and the warm glow of lights, it’s clear that this is a spot that caters to both pizza lovers and family gatherings alike.

I kicked off my meal with a plate of delicious toasted ravioli—an appetizer that set the bar impressively high. But the real star was undoubtedly their luscious portobello lugiosi pizza. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and blissfully soft within, and the flavors melded beautifully, proving that they know how to balance rich ingredients with finesse.

The menu boasts a variety of options, ensuring there's something for everyone, whether you're a meat lover or a veggie enthusiast. Dining here is not just about filling your belly; it resonates with a sense of community and joy. For anyone searching for a top-tier pizza experience, I wholeheartedly recommend making a stop at Glass Nickel Pizza Co.—you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

People’s Park

Highlights
Fun, vibrant atmosphere
Rooftop seating available
Friendly owner and staff
Unique gluten-free options
Festive holiday decorations

People's Park in Waukesha offers a delightful twist on your traditional pizza outing, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors alike. As soon as I stepped into this vibrant establishment, I was enveloped by a fun atmosphere that blended playful energy with a welcoming charm. The rooftop seating was particularly enchanting, turning each bite into a mini celebration as I soaked in the warm sun and the buzz of laughter around me.

The owner and staff exuded genuine friendliness, making my pizza experience feel personal and special. They took the time to recommend their unique gluten-free options, which I greatly appreciated, as they cater to a variety of tastes and dietary preferences. I indulged in a slice topped with fresh ingredients that sang with flavor, truly elevating the pizza experience in Waukesha.

The festive holiday decorations added an extra layer of joy, making the space feel cozy yet lively. As I savored each bite, I knew I had discovered a special gem in the pizza landscape, one that I can't wait to return to. If you're hunting for great pizza in Waukesha, don't miss the vibrant slice of life that is People's Park!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Highlights
Impressive decor
High quality toppings
Thin, unique pizza crust
Busy yet accommodating
Worth checking out

Grimaldi's Pizzeria in Waukesha is a delightful spot that truly embodies the spirit of a classic pizzeria while maintaining an air of sophistication. As soon as I walked in, I was captivated by the impressive decor, which strikes a fine balance between casual comfort and upscale charm. The ambiance is so inviting that you can’t help but feel at home.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the pizza! Grimaldi's offers a thin, unique crust that is simply marvelous. It achieves the perfect texture—crispy on the outside while remaining tender on the inside. The high-quality toppings are a testament to their commitment to excellence. Each bite bursts with flavor, making it clear why this place has garnered such a loyal following.

Despite being a busy eatery, the staff at Grimaldi's is incredibly accommodating, ensuring every customer has a delightful experience. If you’re a pizza aficionado or someone simply looking for a new favorite, this place is absolutely worth checking out. If you find yourself in Waukesha, Grimaldi's is the pizza adventure you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

Magellan’s On Main Street

At Magellan’s On Main Street, I was greeted by a cozy atmosphere and a delightful pizza menu that whetted my appetite. I sampled their signature pie, topped with fresh ingredients that danced on my palate. The crust was gloriously thin and perfectly crispy—providing an ideal base for the vibrant flavors. Each bite was a delightful blend of tangy sauce and gooey cheese, leaving me craving more. Pairing my pizza with a local brew made for an irresistible combo. If you're on the hunt for pizza that combines quality and charm, Magellan’s is definitely a slice above the rest!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

Jimmy's Grotto Inc

Jimmy's Grotto Inc is a hidden gem where deep-dish dreams come to life! The crust is perfectly crispy, enveloping a delightful medley of fresh toppings and zesty sauce that sings with flavor. I savored every bite of their signature sausage, which packs a savory punch. The cozy atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a perfect spot for pizza lovers. If you're craving a slice that feels like a warm hug, don’t miss out on Jimmy's! With every slice, you might just find yourself saying, "This is pizza perfection!”

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

A Slice of Waukesha

A Slice of Waukesha is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of the city. As I stepped inside, I was greeted by the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizza. I opted for their signature deep-dish delight, and let me tell you, the layers of gooey cheese and zesty sauce danced on my palate! The crust was a perfect balance of crispy and soft, creating that ideal bite. The friendly staff added a personal touch, making my visit even more enjoyable. If you’re on a quest for scrumptious pizza, this local treasure is a must-visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

Sal’s Pizza Waukesha

From the moment I stepped into Sal’s Pizza Waukesha, I felt the inviting warmth of a classic pizzeria. Their New York-style pizza is a delightful masterpiece, boasting a crispy crust and a generous layer of zesty marinara. Each slice is topped with fresh mozzarella that melts perfectly, creating an irresistible pull. I couldn’t resist trying their signature toppings, which balance flavors harmoniously. The lively atmosphere adds to the charm, making it an ideal spot for a casual dinner or a spirited gathering. For those seeking an authentic slice in Waukesha, Sal’s undoubtedly serves up a memorable experience! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

Michael's Italian Restaurant

Tucked away in Waukesha, Michael's Italian Restaurant is a delightful gem that serves mouthwatering pizza sure to satisfy any craving. The crust was perfectly crispy yet delightfully chewy, creating a wonderful base for their savory homemade sauce. Topped with generous amounts of fresh mozzarella and vibrant veggies, every bite was a burst of flavor. The friendly atmosphere and attentive staff made the experience even more enjoyable. If you're on the hunt for pizza that feels both festive and comforting, head to Michael's—a slice of Waukesha that truly captures the heart of Italian cuisine! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.

Joey's Diner

At Joey's Diner, the pizza truly won me over with its dazzling flavors and homestyle charm. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside yet delightfully chewy within, forming the ideal base for their fresh, vibrant toppings. I savored a slice adorned with zesty pepperoni and a medley of colorful veggies, all blanketed in a gooey layer of mozzarella that stretched like a cheesy dream. The atmosphere was warm, inviting, and sprinkled with a hint of nostalgia. If you're on the hunt for a slice that celebrates comfort food, Joey's is an absolute must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best prime rib in Milwaukee.

Pizza Ranch

Pizza Ranch in Waukesha is a delightful surprise for pizza lovers. With its family-friendly atmosphere and a casual vibe, it’s the perfect place to unwind. The buffet offers an impressive variety, featuring their signature Buffalo Chicken Pizza that packs a flavorful punch, alongside classic favorites like pepperoni—always fresh and gooey. The crust strikes a balance between crispy and chewy, making each bite enjoyable. The friendly staff adds a personal touch to the experience, ensuring you feel right at home. If you’re seeking a fun pizza outing, Pizza Ranch definitely deserves a spot on your must-visit list! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best gluten free restaurants in Milwaukee.