Milwaukee's Best Reuben Sandwich [Updated 2025]

After tasting my way through 12 top locations, I can confidently say that Milwaukee’s reuben game is nothing short of legendary. Trust me, I’ve savored every bite, dissected each layer of flavor, and chatted with the passionate chefs behind these iconic sandwiches. My taste buds are practically locals themselves at this point!

Whether you’re a lifelong fan of this classic or a curious newbie, you’re in for a delightful ride. I can’t wait to share the standout spots that not only serve up mouthwatering reubens but also have their own unique twists that’ll keep you coming back for more. Let’s dive into this delicious adventure together!

Benji's Deli & Restaurant

Highlights
Friendly, attentive service
Delicious, solid menu
Breakfast served all day
Quick food preparation
Classic diner experience

Visiting Benji's Deli & Restaurant in Milwaukee instantly felt like stepping into a classic diner, where the aroma of hearty food embraces you like a warm hug. The service was incredibly friendly, evoking a sense of comfort that’s often hard to find in today’s fast-paced world.

Now, let’s talk about the star attraction: their reuben sandwich. This delightful creation features perfectly layered corned beef, crowned with tangy sauerkraut and a generous slathering of thousand island dressing. All of this is embraced by two slices of rich, buttery rye bread—grilled to perfection—giving it that coveted crunch. The flavors meld beautifully, creating a harmony that dances on your palate with each bite.

What impressed me further was the quick food preparation without sacrificing quality, allowing me to savor my sandwich in a timely manner—all while enjoying breakfast served all day! With such a varied and delicious menu, I could easily find myself returning again and again. If you're a fellow reuben enthusiast, Benji's is definitely a must-visit for a delicious taste of Milwaukee tradition!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Riley's Sandwich Co.

Highlights
Friendly and helpful staff
Unique indoor dining experience
Dog-friendly atmosphere
Delicious food offerings
Local recommendation

Riley's Sandwich Co. is an absolute gem nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, and my taste buds can’t thank me enough for stopping by. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly and helpful staff who made me feel right at home. There's something about their unique indoor dining experience that combines a cozy vibe with a touch of playful charm – perfect for a casual meal or a lunch break.

Now, let’s get to the main event: the reuben sandwich. Oh, this masterpiece is a thing of beauty! Generously layered with smoky corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, and a luscious swath of creamy dressing, every bite bursts with flavor. The toasted rye bread added just the right amount of crunch, elevating the experience to a whole new level.

And what’s more, Riley's embraces a dog-friendly atmosphere which speaks volumes about their commitment to creating a warm and welcoming space. Overall, Riley's Sandwich Co. is not just a place to grab a bite; it's a delightful culinary adventure that deserves its place among the best reubens in Milwaukee. If you're craving a sandwich that warms the heart, this is the spot!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Riley's Social House

Highlights
Dog-friendly atmosphere
Quick and friendly service
Delicious, fresh food
Indoor and outdoor seating
Vegetarian menu options

At Riley's Social House, the atmosphere is both friendly and inviting, making it the perfect spot to indulge in a classic reuben. As a dog-lover, I appreciated the dog-friendly vibe, allowing my furry companion to join in on the fun. The service staff was quick and genuinely friendly, setting the tone for a delightful afternoon.

Now, let’s talk about that reuben! Their version of the sandwich is simply divine—boasting layers of tender corned beef, perfectly melted Swiss cheese, and a zesty homemade sauerkraut that dances on your palate. The rye bread is toasted to perfection, providing that satisfying crunch with each bite. It's clear that freshness is a priority in their kitchen, making every component shine.

With options for vegetarians too, there’s a little something for everyone at Riley's! Indoor and outdoor seating allows you to enjoy your meal basking in the Milwaukee sun or cozying up inside. If you're on a quest for the best reuben in Milwaukee, look no further than Riley's Social House—each bite is a celebration of flavor that will leave you craving more!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

Benji's Deli

Highlights
Fantastic corned beef
Warm and inviting atmosphere
Great variety of menu options
Convenient takeout availability
Ample parking at shopping plaza

Discovering the best Reuben sandwich in Milwaukee led me to the charming oasis of Benji’s Deli. Nestled in a bustling shopping plaza, this deli boasts a warm and inviting atmosphere that instantly made me feel at home. I ordered their signature Reuben, and let me tell you, the fantastic corned beef was the star of the show!

With each bite, I savored the perfectly marbled meat, which was both tender and bursting with tradition. The tangy sauerkraut complemented the rich flavors, and the Swiss cheese melted beautifully, wrapping everything together like a cozy blanket. As for the bread, it was toasted to golden perfection, providing that satisfying crunch with every mouthful.

What truly enhances the experience is the variety of menu options available. While the Reuben is undoubtedly a showstopper, I found myself intrigued by other offerings — from classic pastrami to mouthwatering brisket. Benji’s also makes it easy to indulge with convenient takeout for those on the go, ensuring you can enjoy this deliciousness anywhere.

All in all, for anyone on the quest for a remarkable Reuben in Milwaukee, Benji's Deli should be at the top of your list! Don't miss out!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Megawich - The Ultimate Sandwich

Highlights
Fast and efficient service
Fresh and hot sandwiches
Chewy, crispy bread
Flavorful fries
Room for improvement on sauce

Upon walking into Megawich - The Ultimate Sandwich, I was greeted with the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked bread that immediately tickled my senses. I decided to take the plunge and order their highly touted Reuben sandwich. When it arrived, I was pleased to see the chewy yet crispy bread cradling layers of perfectly cured corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese, all kissed by the grill. The sandwich came hot, oozing with cheesy goodness—a feast for the eyes as well as the stomach!

One notable highlight was the fast and efficient service; I barely had time to contemplate which side to choose before my meal was ready! I opted for their flavorful fries, which paired beautifully with the richness of the Reuben. However, the sauce could use a touch more zing—something to give it that extra oomph it craved.

All in all, my experience at Megawich was delightful, making it a must-try for anyone seeking a solid reuben. I can't help but feel that with a slight sauce adjustment, this might just become my top pick in Milwaukee. Cheers to more sandwich adventures!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

Blue's Egg + Bakery

Highlights
Creative breakfast dishes
Fantastic service by Jose
Busy yet efficient seating
Delicious crispy hash browns
Rotating charity specials

When I stepped into Blue's Egg + Bakery, I was immediately enveloped by the lively atmosphere that buzzed with the scents of sizzling hash browns and expertly grilled sandwiches. Their reuben sandwich, a twist on a classic, caught my eye and did not disappoint. The corned beef was tender and flavorful, layered generously with just the right amount of sauerkraut that added that signature tang.

What truly set this reuben apart was the toasted rye—golden and crispy—providing a satisfying crunch with each bite. The seasoned crew, particularly my server Jose, ensured my experience was delightful, attending to every whim with a smile that brightened the bustling diner. I could see the hustle and bustle around me, yet the service remained effortless and efficient, even during peak hours.

I couldn't resist complementing the sandwich with their semi-famous hash browns. Crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, they were a worthy sidekick to the rich flavors of the reuben. If you find yourself in the area, don't miss the chance to indulge in this delightful sandwich while supporting their charity specials. Blue's Egg is a delightful blend of creativity and comfort!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

Wonderland

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Unique and cool atmosphere
Juicy and flavorful food
Gluten-free options available
Consistent dining experience

Wonderland is like a culinary rabbit hole, and I happily tumbled down it with great anticipation for their reuben sandwich. From the moment I walked in, the friendly and welcoming staff made me feel right at home, setting the stage for an exciting dining adventure. The atmosphere here is undeniably cool, merging quirky decor with a relaxed vibe—perfect for a casual bite.

Now, let’s talk about the sandwich itself: the reuben was a delightful medley of flavors! Juicy, tender corned beef nestled between perfectly toasted rye bread, lovingly layered with tangy sauerkraut and a generous swipe of creamy thousand island dressing. Each bite was an explosion of taste—every flavor harmoniously intertwined. Plus, they offer gluten-free options, which is an added bonus for diners with dietary restrictions.

One aspect that truly stood out was the consistency of the dining experience; I left Wonderland feeling satisfied and eager for a return trip. In a city brimming with competition, Wonderland’s reuben may just be the rabbit that hops its way to the top of my list for the best in Milwaukee!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

McBob's Pub & Grill

McBob's Pub & Grill boasts a charming neighborhood vibe that welcomes you as soon as you step inside. Their reuben sandwich is a delightful concoction of tender corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, and perfectly melted Swiss, all embracing a perfectly toasted marbled rye. What makes it truly stand out is the subtle kick from house-made thousand island dressing—a creamy companion that elevates each bite. The generous portion ensures you leave satisfied but not stuffed. If you’re on a quest for Milwaukee’s best reuben, definitely stop by McBob’s; it’s a delicious destination that deserves a spot on your list!

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

Jake's Deli

When I stepped into Jake's Deli, the aroma of freshly baked bread instantly enveloped me, setting the stage for a remarkable meal. Their Reuben sandwich was a symphony of flavors: tender corned beef, perfectly melted Swiss cheese, and a sauerkraut that added a delightful crunch. The homemade thousand island dressing brought everything together, creating a balance that was both rich and refreshing. Served on grilled rye, each bite was a heavenly explosion of taste. If you're seeking a classic reuben with a twist, look no further—Jake’s Deli just might serve up Milwaukee’s finest.

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

Hen's Deli

At Hen's Deli, the reuben is a delightful adventure for the taste buds. The corned beef is tender and packed with flavor, while the house-made sauerkraut adds a zesty crunch. The Swiss cheese melts beautifully, creating a perfect harmony on buttery rye bread. Each bite is a satisfying dance of flavors, making it a must-try for any sandwich lover. The atmosphere is cozy, and the staff is friendly, enhancing the overall experience. If you’re hunting for the ultimate reuben, Hen's Deli shouldn’t be missed. It’s a local treasure that elevates this classic sandwich to new heights!

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

Top Corned Beef

At Top Corned Beef, the Reuben is a true standout! Nestled between perfectly toasted rye, the layers of tender corned beef are generous and flavor-packed. The balance of tangy sauerkraut and rich Swiss cheese creates a delightful harmony, all enhanced by a zesty house-made dressing. Each bite bursts with mouthwatering goodness, leaving me craving another. The friendly atmosphere adds to the charm, making it the perfect spot for a casual lunch. If you’re on the hunt for a Reuben that dazzles your taste buds, Top Corned Beef should definitely be on your Milwaukee must-try list!

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.

Deli 1614 | “That Corned Beef Place”

At Deli 1614, the reuben is a delightful revelation! The corned beef is succulent and generously piled, perfectly offsetting the robust tang of the sauerkraut. Their homemade thousand island dressing adds a creamy richness that elevates every bite. The marble rye? Absolutely toasted to a golden crisp. As I savored this marvel, I realized: this isn't just a sandwich; it’s an experience! The bustling atmosphere adds to the charm, solidifying Deli 1614 as a must-visit for any reuben aficionado. If you're searching for a reuben that dances on your palate, look no further. This place truly knows its corned beef!

You might also want to check out the best prime rib in Milwaukee.