West Allis' Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

With each slice I’ve savored, I’ve gathered a treasure trove of pizza knowledge from the twelve top spots that grace our vibrant city. Trust me when I say, I’ve tasted everything from the classic pepperoni to some daring gourmet combinations that’ll make your taste buds dance.

As someone who has navigated the local pizza scene for years, I’ve developed a keen sense for what makes a pie truly special—whether it’s the perfect crust, the freshest toppings, or a sauce that sings. So, get ready to embark on a mouthwatering adventure with me, as I unveil the hidden gems and beloved staples that make West Allis a pizza lover's paradise!

Alphonso's | The Original Pizzeria

Highlights
Giant mozzarella sticks
Nostalgic and happy atmosphere
Friendly staff
Extra fresh dill on pizza
Tasty food worth the wait

Walking into Alphonso's | The Original Pizzeria feels like stepping into a childhood dream. The vibrant and nostalgic atmosphere wraps around you like a warm embrace, instantly making you feel at home. As I settled in, I couldn't resist starting with their giant mozzarella sticks. These cheesy delights are the perfect prelude to the main act, completely redefining the concept of cheese pull!

Now, let’s discuss the pizza itself. I opted for their classic pie, topped with a generous layer of fresh dill, which added a delightful twist that I hadn't anticipated. Each bite was bursting with flavor, and the crust struck a perfect balance between crispy and chewy. While it may take a little time for your order to arrive, trust me when I say that the food is worth the wait.

The staff here are about as friendly as they come; their smiles add to the overall charm of this lovely establishment. If you're on the hunt for a memorable pizza experience in West Allis, Alphonso's should be at the top of your list. You'll discover not just pizza but a slice of joy!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Mama Mia's

Highlights
Crispy thin crust pizza
Excellent homemade garlic bread
Great service from staff
Delicious house salad
Comfortable for cold weather

Mama Mia's in West Allis is truly a gem that caught my attention! When I stepped inside, I was warmly welcomed by the friendly staff, who set the tone for a delightful dining experience. The ambiance is cozy, making it a perfect refuge, especially on a chilly day.

Now, let's talk pizza! I couldn't resist ordering their crispy thin crust pizza. With each bite, I was treated to a delightful crunch followed by a burst of flavor. The sauce was rich and perfectly seasoned, complementing the fresh toppings beautifully. And speaking of flavor, I couldn’t help but indulge in their excellent homemade garlic bread—a delightful addition to my meal that had me wanting more.

Before diving into my pizza, I savored the delicious house salad. It was crisp and refreshing, a perfect start to the culinary journey. The overall experience was elevated by the attentive service, making me feel right at home.

If you're searching for a place that serves exquisite pizza with a welcoming atmosphere, Mama Mia's is your go-to slice of heaven in West Allis. Trust me—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Balistreri's Bluemound Inn

Highlights
Great clam pasta dish
Decent pizza options
Vibe is enjoyable
Good drinks selection
Inconsistent service quality

Balistreri's Bluemound Inn is a charming venue that invites you in with its welcoming atmosphere and the promise of delicious cuisine. While my primary goal was to sample their pizza, I was first tempted by their clam pasta dish, which proved to be a delightful surprise. The blend of flavors was simply exquisite, but the star of the show was undoubtedly their pizza.

The pizza options here are decent, although they didn’t quite reach the heights of heavenly perfection I’ve discovered elsewhere in West Allis. However, the crust had a satisfying crispness and a pleasant chew. I appreciated the balanced toppings, which had a harmonious blend of flavors that flirted with my taste buds.

As I savored my slice, I was enveloped by the enjoyable vibe of the restaurant. The drink selection complemented the food beautifully, making my meal feel a little more special. Service, however, was a mixed bag—some moments were smooth sailing, while others felt slightly sluggish.

Overall, Balistreri's Bluemound Inn is a worthy stop for pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike. It may not reign supreme, but it’s certainly a locale worth your time.

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

The Crooked Crow

Highlights
Best Caesar Salad
Tasty Monthly Specials
Friendly Bartenders
Delicious Burgers
Popular Bar Atmosphere

Review of The Crooked Crow

Upon stepping into The Crooked Crow, I was immediately drawn in by its vibrant bar atmosphere. The friendly bartenders not only took my order with a smile but also ensured I was well-informed about the monthly specials, which were too tempting to resist.

Now, let's talk pizza! I decided to indulge in one of their signature pies, and I must say, it exceeded my expectations. The crust was perfectly crispy, while the toppings were generously applied, creating a delightful flavor explosion with every bite. It paired beautifully with their best Caesar salad, which was a refreshing palate cleanser.

As I savored my pizza, I couldn't help but notice the lively chatter and laughter around me—this place has an undeniable charm that makes it perfect for a casual night out. And if you’re a fan of burgers, you're in luck; they offer tasty options that are just as noteworthy.

In the heart of West Allis, The Crooked Crow is a must-visit for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike. Their unique blend of great food, a cozy atmosphere, and exceptional service ensures that you’ll not only enjoy your meal but also want to come back for more. Keep an eye on their specials; you won’t want to miss out!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Balistreri's Italian-American Ristorante

Highlights
Authentic neighborhood feel
Exceptional food and service
Crunchy, loaded Hawaiian pizza
Sweet and attentive staff
Wonderful festive atmosphere

Upon stepping into Balistreri's Italian-American Ristorante, I was immediately enveloped by an authentic neighborhood feel that made me feel right at home. The atmosphere had a festive charm, perfect for both family gatherings and cozy date nights. Now, let me spill the beans about their pizza! I opted for the Hawaiian, and wow, it was a delightful surprise packed with flavor. The crust had a perfectly crunchy bite, holding up gloriously under generous layers of sweet pineapple and savory ham — a pie that certainly challenged the usual pizza stereotypes.

Throughout my meal, I was lavished with sweet and attentive service that only enhanced my experience. The staff, genuinely warm and engaging, made sure my glass was never empty and offered up charm with every interaction. It felt good knowing that I was truly valued as a patron.

In a town buzzing with options, Balistreri's stands out as a beacon of quality and heart. If you're on the hunt for a comforting slice of pizza that embodies the spirit of West Allis, it's a stop you simply can't afford to miss!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

Paulie's Pub & Eatery

Highlights
Great food and drinks
Electric atmosphere
Friendly and attentive staff
Live music and events
Perfect family hangout spot

Paulie's Pub & Eatery is truly a hidden gem in West Allis, and I must say, they know how to elevate the pizza experience! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by an electric atmosphere that buzzed with excitement. The friendly and attentive staff added to the charm, making sure my dining experience was top-notch from the very start.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza—oh, the pizza! Each bite was an explosion of flavors that danced on my palate. The crust was perfectly crispy, yet chewy enough to deliver that satisfying bite we all crave. Topped with quality ingredients, my pie was a delightful balance of savory and fresh. Whether you prefer a classic pepperoni or a loaded veggie, I found something for every taste.

What adds to the allure of Paulie’s is their commitment to crafting a family-friendly environment. It’s not just about the great food and drinks; the live music and events create a lively backdrop that keeps the good times rolling. If you find yourself in West Allis, make sure to stop by Paulie's for a slice of pizza heaven! It's a place where you can indulge and unwind in style. 🍕

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

Nico’s Pizza

Nico’s Pizza in West Allis is a true gem! From the moment I walked in, the aroma of fresh dough and zesty sauce enveloped me like a warm hug. I savored their signature Margherita, where the tender crust perfectly cradled the vibrant tomatoes and creamy mozzarella. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors that made me smile. The laid-back atmosphere added to the charm, making it a great spot for friends and family alike. If you’re in the mood for a slice of heaven, look no further than Nico’s—where every bite is a reason to celebrate pizza!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

Amelia's Pizzeria

At Amelia's Pizzeria, I was greeted by an inviting aroma that hinted at deliciousness. The thin-crust pizza is a must-try—crispy yet perfectly pliable. Topped with fresh mozzarella and tangy tomato sauce, each bite was an explosion of flavor. I particularly loved the way their spicy pepperoni added a delightful kick. The atmosphere was cozy, making it an ideal spot for a casual dinner or a fun night out. If you’re looking for satisfying slices that balance quality and comfort, Amelia's is a place that deserves a spot on your pizza bucket list! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

Capri di Nuovo

Nestled in the heart of West Allis, Capri di Nuovo dazzled me with its vibrant ambiance and mouth-watering aromas. The moment I took a bite of their signature thin-crust pizza, I was transported to pizza paradise! Topped with fresh ingredients and a perfectly balanced sauce, each slice offered a delightful crunch and a burst of flavor. The staff was friendly and attentive, enhancing the overall experience. Whether you're a lifelong pizza aficionado or a casual diner, Capri di Nuovo is a must-visit for anyone seeking an unforgettable slice in West Allis! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

Travinos Pizza

My recent visit to Travinos Pizza in West Allis was a delightful adventure for my taste buds. The aroma of freshly baked dough welcomed me as I stepped inside. I opted for their signature Travinos Special—a perfect harmony of zesty sauce, generous toppings, and gooey cheese. Each bite was a joyous explosion of flavors, making it hard to resist devouring the entire pie! Their crust struck a lovely balance between crisp and chewy, providing the ideal foundation for this masterpiece. If you’re hunting for pizza that dances on your palate, Travinos is an absolute must-try! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

Pizzeria Scotty

Pizzeria Scotty is a delightful slice of heaven in West Allis! From the moment I stepped in, the cozy ambiance set the tone for a spectacular meal. I savored the Sicilian-style pizza, with its perfectly chewy crust and vibrant toppings bursting with flavor. The balance of tangy tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella was simply divine. Their use of fresh, high-quality ingredients truly shines through. Don’t skip their garlic knots – they’re the perfect companion for any pizza lover! If you’re in the area, make sure to treat yourself to a pie from this charming spot. It’s a must-try for pizza aficionados!

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.

Cataro's Italian Villa

Stepping into Cataro's Italian Villa felt like a delightful journey to Italy! The ambiance exuded warmth and charm. I opted for their signature Margherita pizza, and it was a game-changer! The thin crust, perfectly crispy and golden, provided a delightful base for the vibrant tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella. Each bite was bursting with fresh basil, making it a true medley of flavors. To top it off, the generous sprinkle of Parmesan added a delightful zing. If you’re on the hunt for a memorable slice, Cataro's is a must-visit in West Allis for pizza lovers seeking authentic Italian flair!

You might also want to check out the best prime rib in Milwaukee.