Port Washington's Best Pizza [Updated 2026]

As I dove into the vibrant pizza scene of Port Washington, I felt like a kid in a candy store—each slice promising its own little adventure. After reviewing 12 top locations, I can confidently say this charming town has something for everyone, whether you crave a classic Margherita or a quirky gourmet creation.

With years of tasting and critiquing pizzas from coast to coast, I’ve developed a palate that can distinguish the good from the truly exceptional. So, trust me when I say that the best pies in Port Washington are waiting to be discovered, and I can't wait to share my favorites with you!

Lucky Devils Bar & Grill

Highlights
Retro dive bar atmosphere
Exceptional friendly service
Top-notch food quality
Popular smash burger night
Vivacious and attentive staff

Review of Lucky Devils Bar & Grill

Stepping into Lucky Devils Bar & Grill feels like a delightful trip back in time, thanks to its charming retro dive bar atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where you feel instantly welcomed, and the exceptional friendly service is just as inviting as the decor.

Now, let’s talk about the main event: the pizza! I was eager to try their famous pie, and let me tell you, it does not disappoint. Each slice boasts a perfectly crispy crust, kissed by the oven just right. The ingredients are fresh and vibrant, elevating each bite into an experience.

While indulging in this delightful fare, I noticed that the place was buzzing with energy – a testament to their popular smash burger night – but my heart (and stomach) were all in for the pizza. The vivacious and attentive staff ensures that you won't have to wait long for that steamy slice to hit your table.

If you find yourself in Port Washington, do yourself a favor and stop by Lucky Devils. Their delightful pizza is an absolute gem among the local offerings, and it promises a memorable meal! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

The Steerage Dining Saloon

Highlights
Great Irish Old Fashion
Delicious Garlic Bread
Friendly and Welcoming Staff
Outstanding Swedish Meatballs
Excellent Admiral Sandwich

The Steerage Dining Saloon has become a delightful surprise on my quest for the best pizza in Port Washington. As I stepped inside, the friendly and welcoming staff made me feel right at home, a warm start to my culinary adventure.

I couldn’t resist trying their garlic bread as an appetizer, which was simply heavenly—bursting with flavor and the perfect precursor to my pizza feast. When I finally laid eyes on the pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. The crust was both crispy and chewy, a perfect base for the rich flavors that followed. Each slice greeted me with toppings that were carefully curated, showcasing a blend of traditional and innovative choices.

To pair with my meal, I ordered their great Irish Old Fashion, which was a fantastic complement to the robust flavors of the pizza. Although the restaurant is well-known for its outstanding Swedish meatballs and the excellent Admiral sandwich, it was the pizza that stole the spotlight for me.

If you're wandering through Port Washington, don’t miss out on The Steerage; it’s a slice of culinary joy that deserves a visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

John's Pizzaria

Highlights
Authentic small town pizza place
Medium thin crust pizza
Loyal local following
Great food and friendly employees
Family-friendly dining experience

John's Pizzaria has firmly established itself as a beloved gem in the heart of Port Washington. As soon as I stepped inside, I felt the warmth of a family-friendly atmosphere, where smiling faces greeted me like an old friend. The charming decor conjures images of a classic Italian pizzeria, and the comforting scent of freshly baked dough pulls you in like a warm hug.

I opted for their medium thin crust pizza, which is indeed an art form. Each slice boasted a delightful crunch that gave way to a perfectly chewy center, making it impossible to resist going back for more. The toppings were an exquisite blend of freshness and flavor, celebrating the essence of traditional pizza. It's no wonder that this establishment has garnered a loyal local following, as each pizza feels crafted with care and passion.

What truly sets John’s apart is the undeniable sense of community. The friendly employees embody the spirit of Port Washington, making every visit feel more like a gathering than a meal. If you're on the hunt for authentic pizza that resonates with both heart and flavor, John's Pizzaria is an absolute must-try!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

The Pasta Shoppe

Highlights
Fresh and tasty food
Friendly and welcoming staff
Cozy atmosphere
Great for dining experience

The Pasta Shoppe in Port Washington is a delightful gem that truly understands the art of pizza. Upon entering, I was immediately greeted by the friendly and welcoming staff, setting the tone for what was to be a remarkable culinary journey. The cozy atmosphere wraps around you like a warm hug, perfect for enjoying great food with friends or family.

Now, let’s dive into the main attraction—the pizza! Each slice was a testament to freshness, with ingredients that blended harmoniously, resulting in flavors that danced on my palate. The crust struck a perfect balance between crispy and chewy, a true sign of a well-crafted pizza. The variety offered is impressive, catering to both traditionalists and those seeking a bit of adventure in their toppings.

What I particularly enjoyed was the ability to watch the staff craft the pizzas in real-time—this level of transparency adds to the experience, making it feel even more special. If you’re on the hunt for a memorable dining experience, The Pasta Shoppe is undoubtedly a must-visit in Port Washington. If you find yourself in the area, I encourage you to grab a slice or two—you won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Franklin.

Twisted Willow Restaurant

Highlights
Welcoming and comfortable
Quick, attentive service
Incredible food quality
Excellent cocktail selection
Romantic dining atmosphere

Stepping into Twisted Willow Restaurant feels like a warm hug on a chilly night—the ambiance is both inviting and romantic. As I settled into my chair, I was greeted by the quick and attentive service that immediately set the tone for the evening.

Now, let's talk pizza! Twisted Willow’s offerings showcase incredible food quality with a creative twist. I opted for their signature pizza, and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly baked—crispy yet chewy—topped with fresh ingredients that danced on my palate. The sauce, with its rich, robust flavor, complemented the toppings beautifully, showcasing a balance that many pizzerias strive for but rarely achieve.

To elevate the experience, their cocktail selection is equally impressive, making it an ideal spot for both a casual dinner or a special occasion. Overall, I left with a full belly and a happy heart, ready to return for more. If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Port Washington, Twisted Willow is definitely a slice of heaven you won’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Plier's Full Circle Pub & Restaurant

Highlights
Amazing fresh and delicious food
Friendly and prompt service
Cozy and inviting atmosphere
Quick food preparation
Affordable dining options

Stepping into Plier's Full Circle Pub & Restaurant felt like a warm hug on a chilly night. The ambiance was cozy and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a casual dinner. I was greeted by a friendly staff who seemed genuinely eager to ensure my experience was fantastic.

Now let's talk about the star of the show: the pizza. I ordered their signature pie, and I was delighted to find it loaded with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The crust was a delightful balance of crisp and chewy – the kind you want to savor fully. Each bite revealed an explosion of flavors, with a rich sauce that didn’t overpower but complemented the toppings beautifully.

What impressed me most was how quickly my pizza arrived, allowing me to enjoy my meal without the typical long wait. This swift service, combined with affordable pricing, makes Plier’s an excellent choice for anyone craving great food without breaking the bank.

If you’re in Port Washington and seeking a slice of heaven, look no further than Plier's Full Circle. It’s a gem that hits all the right notes!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

Fork & Tap

Highlights
Plentiful gluten-free options
Delicious pub-style dining
Open and friendly atmosphere
Generous portion sizes
Unique bottom fill beers

Fork & Tap is an absolute gem in Port Washington, serving up some of the best pizza I’ve had in a while. As soon as you step inside, the open and friendly atmosphere wraps around you like a warm hug—ideal for families or a casual night out with friends. The decor is inviting, enhanced by the buzz of laughter and clinking glasses from their vibrant bar area.

What really caught my attention were the generous portion sizes. Their pizzas are crafted to satisfy even the heartiest appetites! I opted for their signature pie, topped with a medley of fresh ingredients that burst with flavor in every bite. And for those who are gluten-sensitive, Fork & Tap proudly offers plentiful gluten-free options, making it a fantastic choice for everyone at the table.

To accompany the meal, I indulged in one of their unique bottom fill beers, expertly curated to pair with their delightful crusts. Those who enjoy pub-style dining will feel right at home here. Overall, Fork & Tap strikes a perfect balance between great food and a welcoming vibe, making it a top contender for the best pizza in Port Washington!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Germantown.

Schooner Pub

Highlights
Warm, inviting atmosphere
Stunning harbor views
Outstanding service
Delicious, well-prepared food
Great drinks and cocktails

Schooner Pub is an absolute gem tucked away in Port Washington, showcasing not just pizza, but an entire dining experience! As I stepped inside, I was welcomed by a warm, inviting atmosphere, perfect for a cozy night out or a casual lunch. What truly sets it apart is the breathtaking harbor view—it’s hard to resist a slice of pizza while gazing at the serene waters.

The service here is commendable; the staff is both attentive and friendly, ensuring every need is met with a smile. Now, onto the pizza! The crust is always perfectly baked—thin enough for that delightful crunch yet sturdy enough to hold a generous amount of toppings. The sauce is rich and flavorful, complementing the cheese and toppings without overshadowing them.

Pair this with one of their great drinks or cocktails, and you’ve got the perfect recipe for an enjoyable meal. Overall, Schooner Pub has become one of my top picks for pizza in Port Washington. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, be sure to stop by and indulge in what they have to offer—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

Inventors Brewpub

Highlights
Creative menu planning
Excellent staff coordination
Impressive charity event hosting
Unique flavor combinations
Beautiful dessert options

At Inventors Brewpub, pizza is not just a food choice; it's an experience. Nestled in the heart of Port Washington, the ambience here radiates a playful charm that pairs beautifully with their inventive menu. As I settled in, I was immediately drawn to the unique flavor combinations they offered. The house-made pizza dough serves as the perfect canvas for bold toppings that dance on the palate.

The staff's exceptional coordination was evident as they moved effortlessly around the bustling eatery, ensuring that every dish emerged from the kitchen in pristine condition. One bite of their signature pizza and I was pleasantly surprised by a delightful medley of flavors that made my taste buds sing.

Moreover, it was inspiring to learn that Inventors Brewpub showcases their commitment to the community through impressive charity event hosting. This spirit of giving not only enriches the local scene but adds an extra layer of warmth to an already inviting atmosphere.

Don’t even get me started on their beautiful dessert options—the perfect sweet finale to a fantastic meal! If you're looking for innovative pizza in a welcoming environment, Inventors Brewpub is a must-visit in Port Washington.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

Patio Bar & Grill

Highlights
Outdoor dining experience
Fresh appetizers
Generous portion sizes
Comfortable patio seating
Mixed reviews on fish fry

The moment I stepped into Patio Bar & Grill, I was greeted by a charming outdoor vibe that’s just perfect for those sunny Port Washington days. With its inviting patio seating, this locale exudes a warm and friendly atmosphere that immediately makes you feel at home.

Now, let's talk pizza! Their crust was just the right amount of crispy, while the toppings were generously laid—a delight for any pizza lover. I opted for their classic Margherita, which dazzled my taste buds with its fresh basil and rich tomato sauce, delivering a symphony of flavors.

But what truly elevated my dining experience were the fresh appetizers that complemented my pie. I couldn’t resist ordering a side of their garlic knots, which were fluffy and decadent—perfect for sharing (or not). While the consensus on their fish fry seems mixed, I was too busy reveling in the pizza perfection to care.

Overall, Patio Bar & Grill wins bonus points for not just its delectable pizza but for creating a space where good food and great company meet! If you find yourself in Port Washington, this gem is worth a visit.

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

Tomaso's

Highlights
Delicious deep fried ravioli
Perfect cheese-to-crust ratio
Friendly and attentive staff
Unique cheese-on-bottom style
Sweet and tangy sauce

At Tomaso's, pizza transcends mere nourishment; it’s an experience! My visit was delightfully marked by the symphony of flavors that danced on my palate. The first course to arrive was an indulgent plate of deep-fried ravioli that was a crispy and creamy delight—truly a perfect precursor to the main event.

When the pizza made its grand entrance, I was immediately struck by the unique cheese-on-bottom style. Each slice flaunted a perfect cheese-to-crust ratio, making for a gooey yet crunchy texture that was nothing short of divine! The sauce, a delightful concoction that was both sweet and tangy, elevated the pie to new heights, creating a flavor profile that was simply remarkable.

Moreover, the staff at Tomaso's were as engaging as the food; their friendly and attentive service made the evening even more enjoyable. As I savored each bite, I couldn’t help but feel that this pizza was crafted with love and passion. If you find yourself in Port Washington, a visit to Tomaso’s isn’t just recommended; it’s a must for anyone who cherishes a slice of perfection!

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

Sir James Pub

Highlights
Impressive beer selection
Knowledgeable staff
Great cocktail deals
Best late-night hangout
Unique dive bar ambiance

Sir James Pub is more than just a place to grab a bite; it's a delightful dive embracing the heart and soul of Port Washington. As I stepped inside, the unique ambiance immediately captured my attention—decor that tells a story, combining a cozy neighborhood feel with vibrant energy. With an impressive beer selection, finding the perfect brew to accompany my pizza was almost as thrilling as the dish itself.

Now, let's talk about the pizza. Sir James offers a variety of pies, each crafted with care. The crust was perfectly crisp, yet delicately chewy with every bite. I indulged in the classic pepperoni, where the toppings were generously piled on—evidence of the knowledgeable staff who ensure quality at every turn. It was nostalgic yet elevated, hitting all the right notes.

To top it off, Sir James is the ideal late-night hangout. After a night of laughter and good conversation, I found the combination of great cocktails and delicious bites created an unforgettable experience. If you're in search of both a hearty pizza and a lively atmosphere, Sir James Pub should definitely be on your radar!

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.