The Absolute Best Pizza in Highland Park [Updated 2026]

As a self-proclaimed pizza aficionado, I’ve savored every slice this charming town has to offer. After devouring pies from a dozen top spots, I can confidently say that Highland Park is a hidden gem for pizza lovers. Each bite tells a story, whether it’s a classic margherita or an adventurous gourmet creation, and trust me, my taste buds have had quite the adventure!

You might wonder why you should trust my opinion. Well, I've spent countless weekends on the hunt for that perfect crust, rich sauce, and gooey cheese. I’ve chatted with passionate chefs, learned the histories behind their recipes, and sampled more toppings than I care to admit. You’re in for a treat as we dive into the delicious world of Highland Park pizza!

Piero's Pizza

Highlights
Great stuffed pizza options
Delicious sauce quality
Helpful and friendly staff
Convenient delivery service
Mixed customer service reviews

Review of Piero's Pizza

Stepping into Piero's Pizza in Highland Park feels like a warm embrace on a chilly day, and let me tell you, their stuffed pizza is a hug worth savoring! The moment I bit into the flaky crust, I was welcomed by an orchestra of flavors, with the rich, tangy sauce harmonizing perfectly with the gooey cheese and generous toppings. Honestly, it’s a slice of heaven wrapped in comfort.

The staff at Piero's are another standout feature—super helpful and friendly, making you feel right at home. They surely know how to guide you through their menu, which is a treasure trove of choices. However, it seems the service can be inconsistent on busy nights, but the deliciousness of the pizza definitely makes up for any minor hiccups.

One thing I appreciated was the convenient delivery service, perfect for when you’re hankering for a slice on the sofa. Overall, Piero's Pizza offers a delightful dining experience that showcases why they hold a special place in the hearts of Highland Park residents. If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza, don’t skip this gem!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evanston.

Judy's Pizzeria

Highlights
Double-decker pizza
Varied food selections
Affordable pricing
Outstanding customer service
Convenient delivery options

Review of Judy's Pizzeria in Highland Park

Walking into Judy's Pizzeria feels like stepping into a cozy neighborhood hangout where the aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese welcomes you with open arms. This charming spot is renowned for its double-decker pizza—a glorious creation that boasts not one, but two layers of toppings and cheese, skillfully sandwiched between two crusts. It’s a delectable delight for someone like me who believes more is merrier when it comes to pizza!

What truly sets Judy's apart is its affordable pricing, allowing you to indulge without putting a dent in your wallet. I was pleasantly surprised by how extensive their menu is, catering not only to pizza lovers but also to those looking for varied food options. The sheer diversity ensures that even the pickiest eaters in a group will find something to munch on.

Let’s not forget the outstanding customer service—the staff treated me like family, making each recommendation based on my taste preferences. And if you're like me and sometimes prefer to enjoy your pizza from the comfort of home, Judy's offers convenient delivery options that make it a cinch to satisfy your cravings. Overall, Judy's Pizzeria positively radiates with charm and deliciousness, making it a must-visit gem in Highland Park!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Pixca Seasonal American Bistro

Highlights
Cozy and welcoming atmosphere
Knowledgeable and attentive staff
Excellent food quality
Great for families with children
Special accommodations for allergies

Review of Pixca Seasonal American Bistro

Stepping into Pixca Seasonal American Bistro is like being welcomed into a cozy, vibrant home where every detail is thoughtfully curated. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for families and friends alike. As I sat down, I was greeted by a knowledgeable staff member who quickly made me feel right at home.

Now, let's talk about the pizza! I opted for their seasonal selection, which boasts a delightful medley of fresh, high-quality ingredients. Each bite was a testament to their commitment to excellence. The crust was perfectly thin and golden, providing a delightful crunch that paired beautifully with the vibrant toppings. Whether you're a fan of classic flavors or adventurous combinations, Pixca does not disappoint.

Moreover, I appreciated their attention to dietary needs; they offer special accommodations for allergies, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice without worry. This is the kind of inclusivity that sets them apart. If you're in Highland Park and on the hunt for a memorable pizza experience, Pixca should be at the top of your list. Their pizza is not just a meal; it’s a celebration of fresh ingredients and hearty flavors! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Highland Bar and Kitchen

Highlights
Perfect pizza dough
Great for sports lovers
Delicious pasta options
Excellent food and drinks
Cozy atmosphere for game nights

Highland Bar and Kitchen quickly captured my heart (and taste buds) with its delightful offerings. Walking in, you’re greeted by a cozy atmosphere perfect for a casual night out or catching the game with friends. As a pizza aficionado, I couldn’t wait to sample their renowned pies.

Let’s talk dough—it’s a triumph! The crust is perfectly baked with just the right balance between crispy and chewy, making each bite a heavenly experience. I opted for the classic Margherita, and the fresh ingredients shined through brilliantly; the tangy tomato sauce paired seamlessly with creamy mozzarella and fragrant basil.

What surprised me was not only the outstanding pizza but also the delicious pasta options on the menu. It’s a versatile spot that caters to both pizza lovers and pasta enthusiasts! Plus, the drinks selection is top-notch, which made my meal even more enjoyable.

If you’re in Highland Park and searching for a spot where you can indulge in delectable food while catching a game, Highland Bar and Kitchen should be at the top of your list. With their dedication to quality and a vibrant atmosphere, it’s a slice of pizza paradise you won’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

Il-Forno Pizza & Pasta

Highlights
Fast service under 15 minutes
Friendly and helpful staff
Delicious Greek pizza
Real bacon chunks
Inviting restaurant atmosphere

Since I'm an expert reviewer of pizzas, I recently visited Il-Forno Pizza & Pasta located in Highland Park, and I must say, it was a delightful journey for my taste buds! Upon entering, I was immediately captivated by the inviting restaurant atmosphere. The ambiance was warm and welcoming, perfect for families or a casual date night.

What truly struck me was the fast service; my pizza arrived in under 15 minutes! The friendly staff made the experience even better, always eager to recommend their favorites. I opted for the Greek pizza, and let me tell you, it was a flavor explosion. The toppings were fresh, and those real bacon chunks? Oh, they added a savory crunch that took each bite to another level.

Every aspect of my meal at Il-Forno was satisfying; it’s clear they take pride in their craft. If you’re in Highland Park and searching for a pizza haven, I wholeheartedly endorse Il-Forno. With their delicious offerings and exceptional service, it's a surefire way to indulge your pizza cravings!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Franklin.

Pastificio Inc

Highlights
Best pesto in town
Homemade pasta perfection
Helpful and friendly service
Delicious caponata and tapenade

Pastificio Inc has quickly turned into my personal pizza sanctuary in Highland Park. As I stepped inside, I was greeted by a warm ambiance coupled with incredibly helpful and friendly service that made me feel at home instantly. But let’s talk about the highlight—the pizza!

I was intrigued to find that their offerings beautifully complemented their stellar homemade pasta perfection. I decided to test the waters with their pesto pizza, and oh boy, it redefined my expectations. The best pesto in town lay atop a perfectly baked crust that struck a wonderful balance between crispy and chewy. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors and textures!

But don't overlook their sides—grabbing a scoop of delicious caponata and tapenade elevated the whole experience. It's the perfect accompaniment to whet your appetite before the main event.

In a sea of pizza options, Pastificio Inc delivers a charming blend of traditional and innovative flavors. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this delightful gem in Highland Park promises a pizza experience that deserves all the accolades. Don’t miss it!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

That Little French Guy - French Bakery & Café

Highlights
Great variety of pastries
Delicious baked goods
Friendly and patient staff
Affordable prices
Clean and spacious atmosphere

Oh, where do I even begin with my delightful visit to That Little French Guy - French Bakery & Café in Highland Park? While renowned for its heavenly pastries and baked goods, I couldn't help but discover their unexpected pizza offerings that left me in a state of culinary bliss.

The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the warm, inviting atmosphere filled with the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked bread. The friendly and patient staff made sure I felt right at home, eagerly guiding me through their menu. How refreshing it is to find such affordable prices paired with quality that truly shines!

Now, let's talk pizza. I opted for their unique twist on a classic favorite, and each bite was a testament to their meticulous preparation. Imagine a flaky, buttery crust topped with vibrant, fresh ingredients that danced together in perfect harmony.

In addition to the tantalizing pizza, the selection of pastries was simply irresistible. From flaky croissants to decadent tarts, it’s clear that this café doesn't skimp on quality.

Overall, my visit to That Little French Guy was a playful journey through flavors, making it a must-try destination for pizza lovers in Highland Park!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

Half & Half

Highlights
Elevated pizza and appetizers
Cozy bar for small groups
Reasonable cocktail prices
Amazing service from staff
Great wine selection

Half & Half in Highland Park tantalizes the taste buds with its elevated approach to pizza. As I walked through the cozy bar, the atmosphere embraced me like an old friend, perfect for small gatherings. The pizza menu bursts with creativity, and each slice is a testament to what happens when passion meets craft.

I kicked things off with a delightful appetizer that danced on my palate, setting the stage for their signature pies. The cocktail selection was surprisingly reasonable, making it easy to indulge in a drink while exploring their unique offerings. I decided on a classic pizza, and let me tell you, it was anything but ordinary. Each bite was an experience—flavors blended seamlessly in a harmony that left me wanting more.

What truly set Half & Half apart was the attentive service. The staff exuded enthusiasm and knowledge, guiding me through my choices as if we were old pals reminiscing about our favorite toppings. With a fantastic wine selection complementing the heavenly pizzas, I can confidently say that Half & Half deserves a prime spot on anyone’s pizza pilgrimage in Highland Park!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Fort Atkinson.

Pizza By Sal

Highlights
Delicious thin crust pizza
Friendly and attentive staff
Charming dining atmosphere
Must-visit in Highland Park
Great for casual dining

Pizza By Sal is a delightful gem in Highland Park, where the crust is as thin and crisp as a perfectly aged wine! Walking in, I was greeted by a friendly and attentive staff that set the stage for a memorable evening. The atmosphere exudes charm, making it an ideal spot for casual dining with friends or family.

The first slice of their pizza took me on a flavorful journey. With a delightful balance of sauce and cheese, every bite was a celebration of flavors. The thin crust pizza was baked to perfection, providing an ideal canvas for all those delicious toppings. I couldn’t resist finishing off this delectable treat, appreciating the attention to detail that Pizza By Sal puts into their pies.

If you’re searching for a slice of paradise, look no further—Pizza By Sal is an absolute must-visit in Highland Park. It’s a place where everybody feels right at home, and where you’re bound to come back for more. Whether you're a local or just passing through, let the pizza charm you and savor each moment. Trust me, this is a culinary experience you won’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Germantown.

Goodstuff Eats

Highlights
Incredible BBQ ribs
Artisan grilled cheeses
Helpful and friendly staff
Great for catering
Unique seasonal sauces

Goodstuff Eats is a delightful treasure in Highland Park that stands out for more than just its pizza. As I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly staff, whose enthusiasm made me feel right at home. Diving into their menu, I was pleasantly surprised to find not only incredible BBQ ribs but also artisan grilled cheeses that dance beautifully in the realm of comfort food.

Now, onto the pizza itself! The crust is perfectly crisp, providing the ideal foundation for their diverse toppings. I particularly enjoyed their unique seasonal sauces, which elevated each bite to new heights. You can genuinely taste the care that goes into each pie.

Whether you're looking for a cozy dinner or planning a gathering, Goodstuff Eats has you covered with their efficient catering options. If you’re in the mood for a laid-back atmosphere combined with quality pizza and an array of mouthwatering sides, this spot is a must-visit. Goodstuff Eats has certainly earned its place in the Highland Park pizza scene, serving up slices that are both satisfying and memorable! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

Curt's Cafe

Highlights
Cozy and clean ambiance
Quality food exceeds expectations
Slow service, check orders
Mission-driven cafe experience
Good selection of drinks

Review of Curt's Cafe

Walking into Curt's Cafe feels like stepping into a warm embrace. The cozy and clean ambiance instantly sets the stage for a delightful dining experience. As I settled in, the anticipation grew for the star of the show—pizza!

The menu features a variety of pizzas, all crafted with quality ingredients that truly exceed expectations. I opted for their classic Margherita, and each bite was a revelation! The crust was perfectly charred, providing a satisfying crunch while the fresh basil and mozzarella danced in harmony with the tangy tomato sauce. It's delightful to discover a local gem that takes ingredients seriously.

However, patience is key here; the service can be on the slower side. Be sure to double-check your order to avoid any hiccups. But don't let that dissuade you, as every pizza is made with love and care, embodying the cafe's mission-driven ethos to serve the community.

To wash it all down, they offer a good selection of drinks that pair perfectly with their offerings. Ultimately, Curt's Cafe stands out as a must-visit destination for pizza aficionados in Highland Park. It's a place that beautifully blends passion with flavour!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

Grateful Bites Pizza Shoppe

Highlights
Wild selection of pizzas
Friendly and fast service
Great presentation and taste
Fresh, quality ingredients
Cozy dining space available

When I walked into Grateful Bites Pizza Shoppe, I was immediately taken by the cozy ambiance, which sets the perfect stage for what’s about to come—delicious pizza! They offer a wild selection of pizzas that range from classic to uniquely crafted pies. I decided to try their signature “Grateful Gourmet,” and let me tell you, it was a revelation. The fresh, quality ingredients were evident in every single bite, making the cheese melt harmoniously with the toppings.

The presentation of the pizza was also remarkable, with vibrant colors that made it almost too beautiful to eat—almost! The crust had just the right amount of crispiness, creating a delightful texture that complemented the rich flavors beautifully.

Additionally, the friendly and fast service made the experience even better. It’s clear that the staff take pride in what they serve, which resonates with every flavorful slice. If you're looking for an inviting spot that combines taste and quality, Grateful Bites Pizza Shoppe should definitely be on your radar. I can’t wait to visit again and explore more of their menu! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.