Milwaukee's Best Pie [Updated 2025]

Each slice tells a story, and trust me, I’ve tasted my way through every nook and cranny of this vibrant city to uncover the sweetest secrets. After diving into twelve top-notch pie spots, I’ve savored everything from classic fruit fillings to outrageous flavor combinations that will make your taste buds dance.

You can count on my expertise because I’ve spent countless afternoons chatting with bakers, sampling their creations, and absorbing the warmth of their kitchens. I’ve experienced the joy of a perfectly flaky crust and the bliss of a gooey filling, and now I’m here to share these delicious discoveries with you. Get ready to embark on a pie adventure that will leave you craving more!

Honeypie Cafe

Highlights
Friendly and attentive staff
Delicious cherry pie
Awesome atmosphere
Beautifully prepared food
Cozy gem in Bayview

Review of Honeypie Cafe

Walking into Honeypie Cafe feels like stepping inside a warm embrace, and trust me, that’s just the beginning of a delightful culinary adventure. Nestled in the charming Bayview neighborhood, this cozy gem is not just about the atmosphere—though it is bursting with rustic charm and friendly faces; it's the cherry pie that truly steals the spotlight.

I was greeted by a staff that exudes warmth and attentiveness, making me feel right at home. Once I tucked into a slice of their signature cherry pie, I understood the buzz. The crust was a masterclass in flakiness, perfectly cradling the sweet-tart cherries that danced on my palate. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, striking a balance between nostalgic comfort and artisanal craft.

The cafe’s decor, coupled with beautifully prepared dishes, enhances the experience even more. It’s evident that each element is curated with care. I'd recommend Honeypie Cafe not just for pie enthusiasts but for anyone seeking a slice of happiness in a bowl. It might just become your new favorite spot in Milwaukee! 🍰✨

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

SmallPie

Highlights
Warm, neighborly vibe
Freshly made pies
Excellent savory options
Charming limited menu
Outdoor seating available

Tucked away in a cozy corner of the city, SmallPie offers a warm, neighborly vibe that instantly makes you feel at home. As soon as I stepped inside, the scent of freshly made pies enveloped me like a comforting hug. With a charming limited menu, I was eager to dive into their offerings. I opted for a savory pie, and let me tell you, the flavor was nothing short of spectacular! Each bite was a delightful fusion of wholesome ingredients, showcasing the care taken in crafting these delicious morsels.

What truly set SmallPie apart was their commitment to freshness. The pies are made right on the premises, ensuring that every slice bursts with love and flavor. I was particularly taken by their savory selections—perfect for a hearty meal or a quick snack. As I savored my slice outdoors, I couldn't help but notice the inviting atmosphere, which makes it a great spot for both casual coffee dates and friendly gatherings.

If you're on the hunt for the best pie in Milwaukee, SmallPie is a gem not to be overlooked. With its inviting staff, delicious offerings, and charming ambiance, this delightful eatery is worth every crumb.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

The Bake Sale

Highlights
Freshly baked daily items
Extensive gluten-free selection
Delicious Door County Cherry
Beautifully decorated cookies
Helpful and friendly staff

The Bake Sale Review

Upon stepping into The Bake Sale, I was immediately greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly baked goods wafting through the air. This charming spot boasts an extensive gluten-free selection, catering to those with dietary restrictions without compromising on flavor.

My eyes were irresistibly drawn to the Door County Cherry Pie—a true highlight! The moment I took my first bite, the perfectly flaky crust gave way to a sweet yet tart filling that danced on my palate. It was evident that the cherries were sourced with care, bursting with flavor that transported me straight to cherry-picking season.

Beyond the pies, The Bake Sale also offers beautifully decorated cookies that add a whimsical touch to their menu. But what truly sets this place apart is the helpful and friendly staff. They greeted me with warmth and offered personalized recommendations, making my visit feel special.

In a city known for its culinary delights, The Bake Sale stands out as a must-visit for pie enthusiasts. If you’re in the mood for something sweet, this cozy bakery is the perfect destination to indulge your inner pie lover!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

Greige Pâtisserie

Highlights
Unique French-Mexican fusion
Oatmeal cream pie is a must-try
Woman-owned business
Excellent pastries and baked goods
Worth a drive across town

Greige Pâtisserie is a delightful gem that’s well worth the drive across town! Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, this woman-owned haven offers a unique twist on pie that you simply cannot miss. As I walked in, I was enchanted by the aroma of freshly baked goods and the elegant yet cozy atmosphere that enveloped me.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the oatmeal cream pie. This isn’t your average dessert; it’s a perfect fusion of sweet and earthy flavors that dances on your palate. The creamy filling is luscious without being overly indulgent, surrounded by a wonderfully textured crust that speaks to the exceptional skill of the pastry chefs. I was instantly captivated by the balance of richness and texture in every bite.

What makes Greige Pâtisserie even more special is its commitment to quality and creativity. Each pastry and baked good is crafted with care and showcases their French-Mexican fusion, a true reflection of the owner’s passion. In short, if you’re on the hunt for a remarkable pie experience in Milwaukee, make sure to stop by this charming spot and taste the magic for yourself!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Bakehouse 23

Highlights
Family-owned business
Amazing cherry almond toast
Delicious chocolate butter cake
Great sweet treats
Must-try cowboy cookie

Bakehouse 23 is a delightful gem tucked away in Milwaukee, and if you're on a quest for the ultimate pie experience, this bakery should be at the top of your list. As soon as you step inside, the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked goods greets you, embracing you like a warm hug.

I had the pleasure of tasting their signature cherry almond toast, a dish that brilliantly combines tart cherries with a subtly nutty base. This delightful treat caught me completely off-guard; its balance of flavors was simply heavenly. But let's not forget about their incredible chocolate butter cake—a slice of rich, decadent bliss that made me question my loyalty to pie, if only for a moment!

One of the most charming aspects of Bakehouse 23 is its family-owned vibe; you can truly feel the love baked into each creation. And while I didn't indulge in the cowboy cookie this time, I’ve heard it deserves a spotlight of its own!

In essence, Bakehouse 23 is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking extraordinary flavors and comforting delights. Treat yourself; your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

MOR Bakehouse MKE

Highlights
Prime location for accessibility
Dedicated gluten-free offerings
Friendly and passionate owner
Gourmet desserts available
Active community engagement

MOR Bakehouse MKE: A Slice of Heaven on Earth

The moment I stepped into MOR Bakehouse MKE, I was welcomed by the sweet aroma of freshly baked goods. Located conveniently for all pie enthusiasts, this charming spot instantly feels like home. More than just a bakery, it’s a haven for gluten-free pie lovers as well. Knowing the challenges some face in finding delightful alternatives, their dedicated gluten-free offerings make them a standout.

I had the pleasure of meeting the passionate owner, whose enthusiasm for pie creation is infectious. Each dessert is a gourmet adventure—crafted with love and an impressive attention to detail. I was particularly drawn to their signature pie, bursting with fresh, local ingredients that dance on your palate. The balance between the flaky crust and the sumptuous filling was just sublime.

What really ties MOR Bakehouse to the heart of Milwaukee is their active engagement with the community. They host events that spread joy and foster connections among fellow pie aficionados. In a city known for its culinary treasures, MOR Bakehouse MKE is carving out its reputation as a must-visit destination for anyone seeking the best pie experience. Trust me, once you try their pies, you’ll be enchanted!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

Amaranth Bakery & Café

Highlights
Charming atmosphere
Delicious bakery treats
Excellent Anodyne coffee
Helpful and friendly staff
Dense, flavorful scones

Amaranth Bakery & Café is a delightful little gem nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, and I found its ambiance simply charming. The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by the irresistible aroma of freshly baked goods that beckoned me to explore. I couldn't help but pair my slice of pie with a cup of their excellent Anodyne coffee, a match made in culinary heaven!

Now, let's talk about the pie, shall we? Each bite was a heavenly experience, with a buttery crust that simply melted in my mouth, cradling a filling bursting with flavor. It was a slice of nostalgia that reminded me of the best kind of homemade goodness. And if you’re a fan of the palate-pleasing scones, be sure to try those too! They are dense and flavorful, making for a perfect accompaniment alongside their delicious bakery treats.

The staff here is wonderfully helpful and friendly, adding a personal touch that enhances the overall experience. Amaranth Bakery & Café truly embodies the heart of Milwaukee's culinary scene, making it a must-visit for pie lovers and pastry enthusiasts alike. Treat yourself; you won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

Blooming Lotus Bakery

Highlights
Beautiful and delicious treats
Perfect for special events
Packed full of flavor
Friendly and welcoming staff
Gluten-free and dairy-free options

Blooming Lotus Bakery is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, where the passion for creating beautiful and delicious treats shines through every slice of pie. Upon entering, I was warmly welcomed by the friendly staff, who certainly make you feel right at home from the moment you step in. The aroma of freshly baked goods enveloped me like a cozy hug, promising a delightful indulgence ahead.

As I indulged in their signature pie, I was blown away by how packed it was with flavor—each bite was a carefully orchestrated symphony of textures and tastes. What truly stood out to me was their commitment to inclusivity, offering gluten-free and dairy-free options that don’t skimp on the deliciousness!

Whether you’re looking to treat yourself or planning for a special event, Blooming Lotus Bakery serves up perfection. Their pastries are not just desserts; they’re an experience filled with joy and warmth. It’s safe to say I’ve found a new favorite spot and can’t wait to return for a slice or two! If you’re a pie lover in Milwaukee, do yourself a favor and pay them a visit—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

National Bakery & Deli | East – Milwaukee

Highlights
Extremely friendly staff
Clean, homemade baked goods
Hidden gem of the city
Quality traditional bakery
Must-visit for pie lovers

National Bakery & Deli | East – Milwaukee is truly a hidden gem for pie lovers! From the moment I entered, I was greeted by the extremely friendly staff who made me feel right at home. The atmosphere buzzes with the delightful aroma of homemade baked goods, setting the tone for a memorable visit.

I had heard whispers about their pie, and I was eager to see if it lived up to the hype. After scanning the delightful display, I settled on a classic apple pie. Let me tell you, this pie was sensational! The crust was perfectly flaky, just the right amount of golden brown, and each bite melted in my mouth. The filling burst with juicy apples and just the right hint of cinnamon, striking a perfect balance of sweetness that left me craving more.

The bakery is spotlessly clean, underlining their commitment to quality and service. If you're wandering around Milwaukee and have a sweet tooth calling your name, make sure you stop by National Bakery & Deli. It’s a slice of heaven that every pie enthusiast must experience! 🍰✨

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Highlights
Exceptional wedding cake experience
Outstanding cake tasting process
Efficient and friendly staff
Anniversary cake gift included
Smooth and simple planning

Review of Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop

Stepping into Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop, I was greeted by a bouquet of aromas; the scent of fresh pie and baked goods wafting through the air is nothing short of heavenly. As an aficionado of pie, I was eager to dive into their offerings. I must say, their exceptional wedding cake experience left quite the impression, but it was the pies that truly stole the show during my visit.

Their cake tasting process was incredibly smooth, and the staff, often buzzing around, were always friendly and efficient. They made every moment delightful, ensuring I felt right at home amidst the sweet chaos. The pies themselves were luscious, with a flaky, buttery crust that cradled the filling to perfection. I sampled the classic apple pie—its balance of sweet and tart was an orchestra of flavors in my mouth.

What truly set Aggie's apart was their thoughtful gesture of including a free anniversary cake with certain purchases—how charming! In all, my visit to Aggie's was not just about pie; it was a jubilant celebration of flavor and hospitality. If you're on the hunt for the best pie in Milwaukee, this cozy shop is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

Simma's Bakery

Highlights
Incredible cake decorations
Moist and flavorful cakes
Friendly and helpful staff
Attention to detail
Perfect for special occasions

Simma's Bakery Review

Tucked away in the heart of Milwaukee, Simma's Bakery is a gem for anyone seeking a slice of pie paradise. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere and the friendly staff who genuinely seem to love what they do. The bakery's charm is evident not just in the decor but also in their incredible cake decorations—it’s a visual feast!

Now, let’s talk pie. I indulged in their signature fruit pie, which was wonderfully balanced, showcasing a moist and flavorful filling that had me swooning with every bite. The crust? Oh, it was a perfect blend of flaky and buttery, providing just the right amount of crispness that complemented the luscious filling beautifully.

What truly stands out at Simma’s is the attention to detail—they don’t just make pies; they create edible works of art that are perfect for any special occasion. If you’re looking for the best pie in Milwaukee, you must visit Simma’s. Whether you're entertaining guests or simply treating yourself, their pies are sure to impress. I left with a smile on my face and a box of goodies in hand, already planning my return for more. 🍰✨

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.

Sweet Diner

Highlights
Casual upscale atmosphere
Fast food preparation
Attentive and friendly service
Some dishes lack flavor synergy
Clean and modern facilities

Sweet Diner Review

Visiting Sweet Diner was like unwrapping a gift box filled with delightful surprises! The casual upscale atmosphere invited me to relax, sip on a warm beverage, and prepare for the star of the show: their pie. I ordered a slice of their famed pecan, and my taste buds danced with joy. The crust was perfectly flaky, a harmonious embrace for the rich, nutty filling that wasn’t overly sweet—just right!

While the fast food preparation might seem off-putting to some, I found it added a sense of urgency that made each bite even more gratifying. The service was another highlight; the staff was not only attentively friendly but also genuinely excited to share pie recommendations, which added a personal touch to my visit.

That said, a few other dishes I sampled seemed to lack the flavor synergy I'd hoped for. However, the clean and modern facilities made for a pleasant dining experience. If you’re on the quest for the best pie in Milwaukee, Sweet Diner definitely deserves your attention. Just make sure to save room for a slice—you won't regret it! 🍰

You might also want to check out the best prime rib in Milwaukee.