Milwaukee's Best Mac and Cheese [Updated 2025]

I’ve tasted every gooey, cheesy bite this city has to offer, scouring menus from dive bars to upscale eateries in my quest for the ultimate comfort food. After reviewing 12 top locations, I can confidently say that Milwaukee is a hidden gem when it comes to mac and cheese.

You can trust my taste buds—I've navigated the cheesy landscape with a discerning eye and an insatiable appetite, and I’m here to share the crème de la crème of this beloved dish. Whether you’re a lifelong fan or just curious, get ready to discover some seriously mouthwatering options that will make you fall in love with mac and cheese all over again!

Oak Barrel Public House

Highlights
Great food and service
Spacious interior
Attentive staff
Convenient downtown location
Tasty butter fat popcorn

Oak Barrel Public House welcomed me with a warm and inviting atmosphere that immediately set the tone for a delightful dining experience. As I settled into the spacious interior, I could sense the excitement in the air, and I was eager to dive into their highly-praised mac and cheese.

What I encountered was nothing short of a revelation: a rich, creamy blend that danced with flavor. Each bite of that heavenly concoction was like a cozy embrace, with the cheese perfectly melted and enveloping every macaroni morsel in its cheesy goodness. It wasn’t just great—it was the stuff of dreams!

Attentive staff ensured my glass was never empty, and their recommendations made the meal even more enjoyable. After indulging in that rich dish, I couldn’t resist the siren call of their tasty butter fat popcorn—a decadent treat that pairs so well with a cold brew.

With its convenient downtown location and a menu bursting with flavor, Oak Barrel Public House has certainly earned its place among Milwaukee's finest mac and cheese locations. I left with a full heart and a happy belly, already fantasizing about my next cheesy adventure.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

The Vanguard

Highlights
Unique sausages offered
Mixed drinks available on tap
Interesting menu options
Casual dining experience
Notable flavor combinations

Review of The Vanguard's Mac and Cheese

If you’re on the hunt for a unique twist on the classic mac and cheese, look no further than The Vanguard. Nestled in the vibrant heart of Milwaukee, this casual eatery offers an unexpected blend of flavors that elevate the traditional comfort dish.

As I stepped inside, the tantalizing aroma of sizzling sausages caught my attention, because here, they take their mac and cheese to the next level with creative mix-ins! The options are intriguing, from spicy andouille to smoked bratwurst, allowing you to personalize your dish to perfection. Bold and rich, each bite of their mac and cheese was a delightful surprise, balancing creamy textures with a punch of flavor.

And let's not overlook the extensive drink menu. Pairing their decadent mac with a local craft beer truly enhances the dining experience. I found it to be a casual yet charming atmosphere, perfect for a lunch break or dinner with friends.

To sum it up, The Vanguard deserves a spot on your culinary map for its playful take on mac and cheese. If you’re craving a lively meal, this is the place to indulge!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Honeypie Cafe

Highlights
Friendly and attentive staff
Delicious cherry pie and coffee
Awesome atmosphere
High-quality food
Picturesque presentation

Honeypie Cafe is a delightful culinary oasis that captures the essence of comfort food, and their mac and cheese is no exception! Upon entering, I was greeted by the warm smile of the friendly staff who set the tone for a cozy yet vibrant dining experience. The atmosphere is just as irresistible as the food, with a charming, picturesque decor that invites you to linger.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the mac and cheese. This dish is a masterclass in high-quality ingredients melded into creamy perfection. The combination of sharp cheddar with a hint of gruyère creates a rich and indulgent flavor that will make your taste buds dance. It’s baked to perfection, offering a delightful crust on top that gives way to a velvety center.

And if you have room for dessert (which you should!), the delicious cherry pie paired with a cup of coffee is the perfect ending to a meal that’s truly memorable. If you’re in Milwaukee, make your way to Honeypie Cafe—this gem is sure to satisfy your mac and cheese cravings while leaving a lasting impression!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

Riley's Social House

Highlights
Dog-friendly establishment
Quick and friendly service
Vegetarian options available
Indoor and outdoor seating
Delicious, fresh food

Riley's Social House is not just another restaurant; it’s a cozy refuge for both dog lovers and mac and cheese aficionados alike. I stepped into this dog-friendly establishment and was immediately captivated by the inviting atmosphere. With both indoor comfort and outdoor charm, it’s the perfect place to relax with your pup while indulging in some cheesy goodness.

I decided to sample their mac and cheese, and I was delighted to find that it was made with fresh ingredients, resulting in a creamy and flavorful dish that beautifully balanced richness with a hint of zest. The chefs here have created not just a side dish but a delightful experience. Oh, and did I mention the vegetarian options? Great for those of us looking for a meatless alternative!

The quick and friendly service only heightened my enjoyment—I barely had to wait before my plate was in front of me. This spot is ideal for a casual lunch or an evening out, making it one of my favorite mac and cheese destinations in Milwaukee. If you’re seeking comfort food in a welcoming setting, I wholeheartedly recommend trying the delicious mac and cheese at Riley's Social House!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Smoke Shack

Highlights
Fast and friendly service
Dog friendly atmosphere
Perfect music and ambiance
Food is to die for
Spotless with character

Review of Smoke Shack's Mac and Cheese

When I strode into Smoke Shack, the first thing that struck me was the perfectly curated ambiance. The mellow tunes in the background set a delightful mood, making it an ideal spot for indulging in comfort food. As a bonus, the atmosphere is dog-friendly, which is a definite plus for pet lovers who can't bear to leave their furry companions behind.

Now, let’s talk about the main event: the mac and cheese. Oh boy! This dish is nothing short of culinary magic—creamy, rich, and slathered in a blanket of gooey, melting cheese that envelopes the pasta like a warm hug. Each bite is a celebration of flavor, and I could easily understand why this dish is to die for! The generous portion size means you’ll be savoring every creamy morsel longer than you might expect.

What sealed the deal was the fast and friendly service; the staff made me feel like a VIP. All in all, Smoke Shack has positioned itself as a must-visit for any mac and cheese enthusiast roaming the streets of Milwaukee. Don’t miss out on this cheesy treasure!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

Camino

Highlights
Great food and drinks
Attentive and welcoming service
Delicious Cubanski sandwich
$5 burger night on Mondays
Robust selection of draft beers

Review of Camino's Mac and Cheese

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Camino serves up an experience that’s simply irresistible. From the moment I walked in, the welcoming atmosphere wrapped around me like a cozy blanket, perfectly complemented by their attentive service. Ah, but the star of the show—let’s talk mac and cheese!

When I ordered their famed mac and cheese, I expected a classic comfort dish, but what I received was an explosion of rich, creamy goodness that had me diving back for more. The cheese was perfectly melted, creating that delightful stretch with every forkful, while the pasta was cooked to al dente perfection. The way each bite melded together felt like a warm hug on a chilly day.

Now, add to that a Cubanski sandwich that was bursting with flavor and the house selection of draft beers—talk about a pairing made in foodie heaven! Plus, if you’re inclined to indulge on a Monday, their $5 burger night is an absolute steal.

In summary, if you're on the lookout for a stellar mac and cheese experience in Milwaukee, Camino is a must-visit that will leave your taste buds dancing!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

The Wicked Hop

Highlights
Excellent outdoor seating
Fair prices and variety
Attentive wait staff
Tasty, well-portioned food
Vibrant atmosphere

At The Wicked Hop, the delightful blend of a vibrant atmosphere and delicious comfort food makes for a truly enjoyable dining experience. I was immediately drawn to their excellent outdoor seating, perfect for soaking up the hustle and bustle of Milwaukee while savoring what I hoped would be some memorable mac and cheese.

Upon ordering, I appreciated the fair prices and variety offered on the menu. Their mac and cheese arrived piping hot – a generous portion that promised indulgence. The first bite delivered a creamy, luscious blend of cheeses, perfectly balanced to avoid being overly rich. Each mouthful was a joy, full of robust flavor that paired wonderfully with the ambiance surrounding me.

The wait staff was incredibly attentive, ensuring my glass was always full and that I was satisfied with my meal. After tasting their delightful creation, I can confidently say that The Wicked Hop knows how to elevate this classic dish. Whether you're after a casual dinner or a Sunday brunch, this spot should make it to the top of your Milwaukee mac and cheese pilgrimage. With hearty servings and a welcoming vibe, this location truly stands out amongst the city's offerings.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

Sobelmans on St. Paul

Highlights
Excellent food quality
Great drink selection
Welcoming team atmosphere
Unique dive bar vibe
Tradition-worthy experience

During my recent culinary adventure at Sobelmans on St. Paul, I dove headfirst into their legendary mac and cheese, and let me tell you, it deserve every bit of the hype! Nestled in a cozy dive bar setting, the ambiance strikes a delightful balance between casual and inviting. You can’t help but feel at home here, which is a testament to their welcoming team atmosphere.

Now, let’s talk about the mac and cheese itself—rich, creamy, and absolutely decadent. Sobelmans prides itself on quality, and it’s evident in each bite. The blend of cheeses creates a luxurious sauce that clings perfectly to the perfectly cooked pasta. It’s not just a dish; it’s a comforting hug in a bowl, making it one of the finest offerings in Milwaukee.

And let’s not forget about their great drink selection that complements a hearty mac and cheese meal splendidly. Whether you're enjoying a craft beer or a classic cocktail, each sip enhances the dining experience.

In short, Sobelmans on St. Paul delivers a tradition-worthy feast that keeps you coming back for more. If you love food that warms both the heart and stomach, this place is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

Who's on Third | A Cream City Concepts Destination

Highlights
Friendly and attentive staff
Tasty St Patty’s cocktails
Great bar burger experience
Reasonable pricing for lunch
Quick food service

Review of Who's on Third | A Cream City Concepts Destination

As a mac and cheese connoisseur, stepping into Who's on Third felt like entering a cozy culinary haven. The friendly and attentive staff welcomed me with warm smiles, setting the stage for a delightful meal. I couldn't resist ordering their signature mac and cheese, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The cheese was creamy and rich, with just the right balance of flavors that danced on my palate.

What made the experience even better were the St. Patty's cocktails that perfectly complemented my cheesy delight. The reasonable pricing for lunch was a pleasant surprise, allowing me to indulge without worrying about my wallet. Service was impressively quick, which is always a bonus when your taste buds are eager to dive into that gooey goodness.

Additionally, Who's on Third offers a great bar burger experience, making it a versatile spot for both indulgent lunch breaks and cozy dinners with friends. If you're in Milwaukee and on the hunt for the best mac and cheese, this charming destination should definitely make your list. Each bite is a reminder that comfort food can be elevated, yet remain utterly satisfying.

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

1700 PULL UP

Highlights
Friendly and knowledgeable staff
Memorable Southern-style dishes
Contemporary jazz ambiance
Caution advised for food safety
Unique dining experience

Review of 1700 PULL UP

Upon stepping into 1700 PULL UP, I was immediately enveloped by the contemporary jazz ambiance that set the perfect stage for a delightful meal. The friendly and knowledgeable staff truly add to the charm of this establishment, making you feel right at home from the moment you arrive.

Now, let's talk mac and cheese! What sets their dish apart is the unique Southern-style twist, bringing an exciting flavor profile that dances on your palate. It's creamy, rich, and topped with a crispy layer that adds a delightful crunch. Each bite transports you to a cozy Southern kitchen, and I couldn't help but savor every morsel.

However, a word of caution: make sure to heed any food safety guidelines offered by the staff; being informed only enhances the experience. Balancing indulgence with safety is key, after all!

In a city brimming with options, 1700 PULL UP distinguishes itself by offering not just a meal, but a memorable dining experience. If you're on the hunt for the best mac and cheese in Milwaukee, this gem is a must-try for those seeking a taste of something truly special.

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

The Edison

Highlights
Upscale dining experience
Chill and artistic atmosphere
Excellent cocktails
Unique exposed brick decor
Great background music

Review of The Edison

At The Edison, the moment you step inside, you're embraced by an ambiance that sings of casual elegance. The unique exposed brick decor adds a nice touch, giving it that artsy feel that seems to resonate with the vibrant energy of the city. Even when relaxing with a fabulous cocktail — and let me tell you, their drink menu is worth exploring — I felt enveloped in a perfect blend of chic and comfort.

Now, let’s talk mac and cheese! This culinary masterpiece is a revelation. Creamy, cheesy, and utterly divine, each bite transports your taste buds to a higher realm of comfort food nirvana. The mix of cheeses creates a symphony of flavors that's bound to have you coming back for more. The Edison doesn't just serve mac and cheese; it crafts an experience that both satiates and delights.

As I savored this delightful dish, the background music added an extra layer of enjoyment, setting the stage for what turned out to be a memorable dining adventure. Whether you're looking for a casual dinner or an upscale evening out, The Edison hits the mark for those craving the best mac and cheese Milwaukee has to offer. Don’t skip it!

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.

MACS (Macaroni And Cheese Shop) Brookfield

At MACS, I was greeted by a delightful array of mouthwatering mac and cheese options. The classic blend of creamy cheese and perfectly cooked pasta was incredibly satisfying. I opted for the Buffalo Chicken Mac, which expertly balanced spice and richness in a way that danced on my taste buds! The atmosphere felt like a cozy embrace, filled with the comforting aroma of baked goodness. For anyone on a quest for soul-soothing mac and cheese in Milwaukee, MACS is a definite must-try. Their creativity and love for this ultimate comfort food truly shine through!

You might also want to check out the best prime rib in Milwaukee.