Milwaukee's Best Lobster Roll [Updated 2025]

After devouring countless lobster rolls and soaking up the vibrant flavors of our city, I’ve narrowed it down to twelve standout places that truly elevate this classic dish. Trust me, I didn’t take this task lightly; each bite was a delicious adventure, and I’ve savored every buttery, lobster-filled moment along the way.

As a true Milwaukee enthusiast, I know the local scene like the back of my hand. I’ve chatted with chefs, gathered insider tips, and of course, indulged my taste buds to find the ultimate lobster roll experience. So, whether you’re a lobster lover or just curious about why these rolls have captured my heart, get ready to embark on a flavorful journey through Milwaukee’s best bites!

The Bridgewater Modern Grill

Highlights
Excellent gluten-free options
Delightful craft cocktails
Beautiful riverside outdoor seating
Friendly and engaging service
Recommended for special occasions

The moment I stepped into The Bridgewater Modern Grill, I was greeted with warm smiles and an inviting atmosphere. With beautiful riverside outdoor seating, it’s the perfect spot to indulge in a lobster roll while soaking up the Milwaukee sun. Touted for its delightful craft cocktails, I decided to start with a refreshing cucumber gin fizz that paired beautifully with the coastal vibe.

Now, let’s talk lobster. The roll itself was a masterpiece, a buttery brioche that cradled generous chunks of lobster, all tossed in a light, zesty aioli. It wasn’t just a dish; it was a celebration of flavors dancing on my palate. Each bite encapsulated the essence of the sea, and the freshness was undeniable—definitely a contender for the best lobster roll in Milwaukee!

Speaking of indulgences, gluten-free options caught my eye, ensuring everyone can join the feast. The service was friendly, making me feel like a welcomed guest rather than just another customer. If you’re seeking a spot for a special occasion or simply a flavorful culinary escape, I highly recommend making a reservation at this gem. You won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Lowcountry Milwaukee

Highlights
Great food quality
Vibrant atmosphere
Limited beer selection
Concerns about portion sizes
Mixed reviews on sauce

Lowcountry Milwaukee is a charming gem nestled in Milwaukee that promises a delightful culinary adventure. The atmosphere buzzed with life and energy, creating an inviting scene just perfect for seafood lovers like me. As I settled in, the enticing aroma of fresh seafood wafted through the air, teasing my taste buds.

Now, let’s focus on the star of the show: the lobster roll. I must say, the quality of the ingredients was impressive. The lobster was succulent and tender, embodying that delightful ocean freshness. However, I did find the portion sizes a tad on the smaller side, which left me wishing for just a little more of that delectable lobster goodness.

The sauce used on the roll drew mixed reactions from my table. While some adored its creamy richness, others felt it overpowered the natural sweetness of the lobster. Perhaps it’s a matter of personal preference. Complementing the roll, the limited beer selection offers a nice touch, though it might leave some craft beer enthusiasts wanting more.

In short, Lowcountry Milwaukee delivers a delicious lobster roll experience in a vibrant setting, but do come prepared with an appetite! It’s definitely worth a visit for any lobster lover.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Empire Fish Company

Highlights
Great customer service
Fresh seafood options
Delicious crab legs
High-quality shrimp
Consistent product quality

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Empire Fish Company is a seafood lover's paradise, and their lobster roll truly stole the show during my visit. The moment I walked in, I was impressed by the great customer service; the staff greeted me with a smile and quickly guided me through their fresh seafood offerings.

When my lobster roll arrived, I couldn't wait to dig in. As I took my first bite, the high-quality meat was evident—succulent chunks of lobster enveloped in a perfectly toasted roll, lightly dressed for just the right amount of flavor. Paired with a refreshing slaw, it was clear that freshness was a top priority at Empire.

But they didn't stop at lobster; I also sampled their delicious crab legs and high-quality shrimp, both of which were equally delightful. Each element of the meal echoed a commitment to consistent product quality that left me eagerly anticipating my next visit. If you find yourself searching for a top-notch lobster roll in Milwaukee, do yourself a favor and stop by Empire Fish Company—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

The Vanguard

Highlights
Interesting menu options
Unique Thai dog experience
Mixed drink on tap
Disappointing portion sizes
Average food experience

When I stepped into The Vanguard, I was instantly drawn in by their interesting menu options. As a lobster roll enthusiast, I felt a tingle of excitement thinking about how they might twist this classic dish in a way that could surprise me. However, while I indulged in their take on a lobster roll, I found it left me wanting more in terms of portion sizes.

The roll itself came beautifully presented but felt a bit scant—almost as if it was whispering, “I could be more!” Though the flavors were there, the overall experience was average, lacking the punch I’ve come to expect from Milwaukee’s hidden gem eateries. One highlight, however, was sampling their unique Thai dog, which brought a delightful fusion twist that momentarily distracted me from my lobster roll cravings.

And let's not forget the mix of drinks on tap, which certainly enhanced the atmosphere, even if the food didn’t quite match up to my lofty expectations. In the end, The Vanguard serves up a fun vibe, but for pure lobster roll bliss, I continue my quest for that ultimate bite. If only this roll could’ve had more of the ocean’s bounty to savor!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Mallards Restaurant

Highlights
Great service at the bar
Delicious Elote Corn Fritters
Consistently flavorful dishes
Fresh and hot food
Friendly and attentive staff

If you're searching for a top-notch lobster roll, look no further than Mallards Restaurant in Milwaukee. From the moment I stepped in, the ambiance wrapped around me like a warm embrace. The service at the bar was not just great; it was spectacular, and I felt like a VIP with every interaction. After some friendly banter, I decided to pair my lobster roll with their tantalizing Elote Corn Fritters—a perfect choice that brought a delightful crunch to my meal.

When the lobster roll arrived, it was fresh and hot, beautifully presented, and practically begged me to take a bite. Yes, I indulged with glee! The flavors were bold yet surprisingly comforting, showcasing the incredible quality of the seafood. Each mouthful was pure joy, a testament to their kitchen’s consistency in flavorful dishes that keeps patrons coming back for more.

In a city known for its culinary delights, Mallards stands out not just for its delicious offerings but also for its friendly and attentive staff. If you're looking for a memorable dining experience and a splendid lobster roll, you won't want to miss out on this gem!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

The Edison

Highlights
Delicious food
Artful industrial atmosphere
Amazing cocktails
Upscale dining experience
Unique decor and ambiance

The Edison in Milwaukee is a delightful surprise for seafood lovers, especially those on the hunt for the ultimate lobster roll. Nestled in a chic, artful industrial space, this place exudes a vibe that’s both playful and sophisticated. The moment I stepped in, the unique decor and ambiance made me feel like I was part of something special.

Now, let’s talk about the lobster roll! It’s not just a dish; it’s an experience. The fresh, succulent chunks of lobster are generously piled high on a buttery, perfectly toasted bun. Each bite is a harmonious blend of flavor, not overly dressed, allowing the sweetness of the lobster to shine through. Paired with their amazing cocktails, it’s a match made in culinary heaven.

The Edison also provides an upscale dining experience that doesn’t feel pretentious—just the right atmosphere for savoring such a delectable creation. If you’re in Milwaukee and craving a memorable lobster roll, The Edison should be at the top of your list. With its delicious food, artful vibe, and delightful service, this charming spot just might have the lobster roll that wins your heart!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

4th Base Restaurant

Highlights
Fresh, made-to-order food
Friendly and helpful service
Unique ordering experience
Delicious seafood options
Casual, laid-back atmosphere

4th Base Restaurant is a delightful gem in Milwaukee that caught my attention while on a quest for the best lobster roll. From the moment I stepped inside, I was welcomed by a friendly and helpful staff that made me feel right at home. The atmosphere is delightfully casual—perfect for a relaxing meal.

What sets this place apart is their philosophy of fresh, made-to-order food. When I ordered the lobster roll, I could sense the quality immediately. The chunks of lobster were perfectly succulent and flavorful, dressed lightly with a creamy seafood mayo that complemented rather than overwhelmed. The soft, toasted bun held it all together, creating a mouthwatering experience that I couldn't resist.

One of the highlights was the unique ordering experience; it is more interactive than your average meal, which made my visit feel special. Plus, the delicious seafood options beyond the lobster roll left me eager to return for more.

In a nutshell, 4th Base offers an inviting setting, a superb lobster roll, and a promise of fresh flavors that make it a must-try for any seafood lover. Don't miss it!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

St. Paul Fish Company | Historic Third Ward, Milwaukee

During my visit to St. Paul Fish Company in the Historic Third Ward, I was greeted with a seafood lover’s paradise. Their lobster roll was a delightful surprise—generously filled with succulent lobster, perfectly seasoned with a whisper of lemon and a hint of herbaceousness. The buttery roll cradled the treasure within, ensuring each bite was a delightful blend of flavors. What really stood out was the freshness of the seafood, which made me feel like I was dining on the coast, rather than in the heart of Milwaukee. If you're seeking a lobster roll that truly captures the essence of the ocean, this is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

Barnacle Bud's

Nestled along the scenic Milwaukee River, Barnacle Bud's offers a delightful escape with its charming outdoor seating. Their lobster roll is a captivating masterpiece – succulent chunks of fresh lobster meat served atop a buttery, toasted roll. Each bite bursts with flavor, complemented by a hint of lemon and a touch of mayo. The casual vibe and friendly service enhance the experience, making you feel at home. While the side of fries is crispy perfection, it’s the lobster roll that steals the show. For a taste of the coast in Milwaukee, Barnacle Bud's is a must-visit for any seafood lover!

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

Harbor House

Harbor House is a delightful gem along Lake Michigan that truly knows how to craft a lobster roll. Their version is a symphony of flavors, featuring tender, succulent lobster meat nestled in a perfectly toasted bun. The addition of zesty mayo and a sprinkle of fresh herbs elevates this dish to new heights. Each bite delivers ocean-fresh essence, making it a must-try for seafood lovers. The charming waterfront view only enhances the experience, making it feel like a mini vacation with every bite. If you're searching for a top-notch lobster roll in Milwaukee, Harbor House should definitely be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

Milwaukee Sail Loft

At Milwaukee Sail Loft, I dove into a lobster roll that felt like a coastal vacation in every bite. Nestled in a soft, buttery bun, the fresh lobster was exquisitely tender, complemented by a light drizzle of lemon aioli that brightened the flavors. The generous portion made each bite a delight, while a sprinkle of chives added a touch of elegance. The casual ambiance and friendly staff just enhanced the experience. If you're in search of a lobster roll that blends freshness and flavor, Milwaukee Sail Loft is a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of the sea in the heart of the city!

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.

Twisted Fisherman

At Twisted Fisherman, I was greeted with a delightfully fresh take on the classic lobster roll. The succulent lobster danced in a perfectly seasoned mayo, embracing a toasted, buttery bun that was simply heavenly. Each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors, complemented by a hint of citrus that elevated the dish. The presentation was striking, leaving my taste buds tingling with anticipation. While the atmosphere was casual, the quality of the roll felt anything but ordinary. Twisted Fisherman has definitely set the bar high in the quest for Milwaukee's best lobster roll—a true maritime delight that’s hard to resist!

You might also want to check out the best prime rib in Milwaukee.