New Berlin's Best Burgers [Updated 2026]

Each bite of a juicy burger has a story to tell, and after devouring my way through 12 top spots in New Berlin, I’m ready to spill the juicy details. Trust me, my taste buds have been on a rollercoaster ride, sampling everything from classic cheeseburgers to gourmet creations that push the boundaries of flavor.

As someone who's spent countless hours perfecting my burger-hunting skills, I’ve developed a nose for spotting the best in town. Whether you're a local or just passing through, I've got the inside scoop on where to find the ultimate burger bliss. Let’s dive into the mouthwatering world of New Berlin’s best burgers together!

Mary's Caddyshack And Grill

Highlights
Laid-back local bar vibe
Friendly and fun bartenders
Live music on Sundays
Handmade thick and juicy burgers
Great value for food and drinks

At Mary's Caddyshack And Grill, I discovered a delightful gem nestled in the heart of New Berlin, perfect for burger lovers seeking a laid-back vibe. From the moment I walked in, the friendly bartenders made me feel right at home with their playful banter and welcoming smiles.

What truly stole the show, however, was the handmade thick and juicy burger that I couldn't resist. Each bite offered a mouthwatering explosion of flavors, complemented perfectly by the bar's relaxed atmosphere. And if you’re lucky to visit on a Sunday, you might catch some live music that adds a cheerful soundtrack to your meal.

But here's the kicker: the value for food and drinks is simply unbeatable! I left with a satisfied appetite and a lighter wallet than I expected. If you’re in the area and craving a solid burger experience, I wholeheartedly recommend checking out Mary’s Caddyshack. It’s not just a dining option; it’s a culinary adventure waiting to happen! Come for the burgers, stay for the vibe—it’s a win-win in my book! 🍔✨

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Uncle Jimmy's Pub And Grill

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Great tribute to first responders
Amazing cheese curds
Fair prices
Room for menu expansion

Uncle Jimmy's Pub And Grill offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like stepping into a local favorite—a comforting embrace after a long day. As I entered, I was greeted by the friendly and welcoming staff, whose smiles made me feel right at home.

The menu is a delightful mix of American fare, but what truly caught my attention were their burgers. I decided to indulge in the house special, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The patty was juicy and grilled to perfection, nestled gently between two perfectly toasted buns. Each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors that danced on my palate.

Before diving into the burger, I couldn't resist trying their amazing cheese curds—a true revelation! These golden nuggets of gooey goodness complemented the burger beautifully and left me craving more. While I appreciated the fair prices, I couldn't help but think there’s room for menu expansion. Perhaps more intriguing burger combinations could elevate this charming spot even further.

They also pay homage to our first responders, adding a unique touch that speaks volumes about their community spirit. Overall, Uncle Jimmy's is a delightful gem in New Berlin’s burger landscape, making it a must-visit for any burger enthusiast!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Cleveland Pub & Grill

Highlights
Amazing event organization
Prompt and friendly service
Low-key sports bar vibe
Great food and drinks
Consistent date night spot

When it comes to finding a burger that tantalizes the taste buds, Cleveland Pub & Grill is a commendable contender on my list. Walking into this cozy establishment, you're immediately greeted by a low-key sports bar vibe that invites you to make yourself at home. The prompt and friendly service truly sets the tone, making you feel like a regular even on your first visit.

Now, let’s talk about the main attraction: the burger. I indulged in their signature burger, and it was a delight! Juicy, well-seasoned, and piled high with toppings, this burger delivered flavors that danced on my palate. The balance of ingredients spoke volumes about their commitment to quality.

Perhaps what impressed me most was the seamless organization of their special events, making it a consistent date night spot without feeling overhyped. There’s a charm in the air here, where you can enjoy great food and drinks while catching a game with friends.

If you're in New Berlin and craving a burger experience that checks all the boxes, don't miss out on Cleveland Pub & Grill—it's worth every bite!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

Sunny Side Up Cafe New Berlin

Highlights
Exceptional Customer Service
Chef Lee's Personal Touch
Great for Large Groups
Delicious Breakfast Options
Efficient and Friendly Staff

Sunny Side Up Cafe New Berlin has carved a delightful niche in the bustling food scene of New Berlin, and let me tell you, their burgers certainly stand out! Upon entering, I was immediately welcomed by the exceptional customer service that forms the backbone of this establishment. The staff, always with a smile, ensured that my experience was nothing short of stellar.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the burger! Crafted with a personal touch by Chef Lee, every bite bursts with flavor and freshness that truly elevates the standard. Not only do they offer a range of unique toppings, but they also ensure each burger is cooked to perfection, making it a memorable culinary delight.

What I found particularly impressive is how Sunny Side Up caters to large groups, making it the perfect spot for family gatherings or friendly meet-ups. While their breakfast options are certainly tempting, the burger game is also strong here.

In a bustling town like New Berlin, this cafe strikes the perfect balance between cozy ambiance and a playful meal experience. If you’re in the area, do yourself a favor and treat your taste buds to this gem!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Natty Oaks Pub & Eatery

Highlights
Fun, casual atmosphere
Friendly and attentive service
Popular smash burgers
Great outdoor space
Excellent cheese curds

Review of Natty Oaks Pub & Eatery

If you’re on the hunt for a delightful burger experience, Natty Oaks Pub & Eatery is definitely worth a visit! The atmosphere is a playful blend of fun and casual, perfect for unwinding after a long week. I was welcomed by a friendly and attentive staff who made me feel right at home.

Now, let’s talk about the burgers! The smash burgers here are simply legendary. Cooked to perfection, each bite is a symphony of juicy flavors. I opted for their signature burger, topped with all the fixings, and it did not disappoint. The patty had a delightful crunch on the outside, while remaining tender and flavorful within.

As I savored my burger, I couldn't resist the urge to order their excellent cheese curds as well. They were crispy, gooey, and the perfect complement to my main dish.

I highly recommend enjoying your meal in the great outdoor space they offer – it’s a lovely setting to indulge in some delicious grub. All in all, Natty Oaks is a must-visit for any burger enthusiast! 🍔✨

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

Dave's Hot Chicken

While Dave's Hot Chicken is primarily known for its fiery chicken sandwiches, I couldn’t resist trying their juicy burger offering. The crispy, golden bun embraced a perfectly seasoned patty that was both moist and flavorful. Topped with a luscious spread of spicy sauce and crunchy pickles, each bite was a delightful explosion of taste. Though the spotlight shines on chicken, their burger stands tall with its mouthwatering juiciness and bold flavors. If you’re in the mood for a twist on tradition, don't overlook this gem in New Berlin—your taste buds will thank you! 🌶️🍔

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

19th Hole Country Club

Nestled in a picturesque setting, the 19th Hole Country Club offers a delightful culinary escape for burger enthusiasts. Their signature burger, crowned with sharp cheddar and crispy bacon, was an absolute game-changer. The beef patty was cooked to perfection, juicy and bursting with flavor, complemented perfectly by fresh toppings. What truly stood out was the inviting atmosphere, making it an ideal spot to savor a meal after a round of golf. If you're searching for a satisfying bite, this hidden gem in New Berlin is worthy of your next burger craving!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

Varsity Club

Varsity Club is nothing short of a burger lover’s paradise! Nestled in the heart of New Berlin, this lively spot serves up a burger that’s both juicy and flavorful. I indulged in the classic cheeseburger, topped with perfectly melted cheese and fresh, crisp veggies. The toasted bun held it all together beautifully, adding just the right crunch. What truly sets Varsity apart is the vibrant atmosphere, making each bite even more enjoyable. If you're hunting for a delightful burger experience, Varsity Club is definitely worth a visit! Don’t forget to bring your appetite—these burgers are a treat! 🍔

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

Matty's Bar & Grille

Matty's Bar & Grille in New Berlin is a delightful haven for burger enthusiasts. I indulged in their signature cheeseburger, which is a juicy masterpiece topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, and a heavenly special sauce. The brioche bun was perfectly toasted, enhancing each bite. I adored the crispy fries on the side, offering a wonderful crunch that complemented the burger's tenderness. The lively atmosphere adds to the experience, making you feel right at home. If you're seeking a top-notch burger that satisfies both cravings and taste buds, Matty's is a must-visit destination in New Berlin! 🍔✨

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

The Local

The Local has quickly become a standout in my burger quest across New Berlin. Stepping into this vibrant eatery, I was greeted with the mouthwatering aroma of sizzling patties that instantly teased my tastebuds. I opted for the signature Local Burger, topped with melted cheddar and crispy bacon—it was a symphony of flavors! The brioche bun was perfectly toasted, cradling that juicy goodness. Each bite was a delightful dance between savory and slightly sweet. Their hand-cut fries were the ideal sidekick, crunchy yet fluffy. If you’re in town, don’t miss out on this gem—your burger cravings will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

Lagniappe Brasserie

At Lagniappe Brasserie, I was greeted by a delightful atmosphere that perfectly matched the savory allure of their burgers. I indulged in the Louisiana burger, topped with house-made remoulade and crispy onion straws. Each bite offered a delightful crunch, complemented by a juicy patty that sang with flavor. The sweet potato fries were an irresistible sidekick, marrying well with the burger's rich spices. Overall, Lagniappe Brasserie serves not just a meal but a culinary experience that’s a must-try for any burger aficionado in New Berlin. Don't miss this gem that perfectly blends local charm with bold tastes!

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.

Texas Roadhouse

At Texas Roadhouse, the Burger Madness was a delightful surprise! The hand-crafted patties were juicy, cooked to perfection, and crowned with a generous layer of melted cheddar cheese. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, especially when topped with their signature steak seasoning, which added a perfect kick. The brioche bun was soft yet sturdy, holding everything together without becoming soggy. Paired with their endless supply of freshly baked bread and cinnamon butter, it was hard to resist going back for another round. If you’re craving a satisfying burger experience, Texas Roadhouse is definitely a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best prime rib in Milwaukee.