Milwaukee's Best Afternoon Tea [Updated 2025]

As I sipped my first cup of Earl Grey at a quaint little tearoom tucked away in a historic neighborhood, I knew I was in for a treat. Over the past few weeks, I’ve indulged in the delights of twelve top locations around the city, each offering their own spin on this cherished tradition.

You can trust my expertise—I've navigated the bustling café scene and savored countless scones, sandwiches, and pastries, all while soaking in the unique atmospheres of each spot. Whether you're a seasoned tea aficionado or just looking for a cozy afternoon escape, I promise there's something in my findings that will make your taste buds rejoice!

Schuster Mansion Bed & Breakfast

Highlights
Beautiful historical mansion
Warm and welcoming hosts
Delicious breakfast options
Charming details throughout
Great opportunity for socializing

Nestled in a stunning historical mansion, Schuster Mansion Bed & Breakfast offers a delightful afternoon tea that is as charming as its surroundings. Upon entering, I was immediately enveloped in a warm, welcoming atmosphere, thanks to the gracious hosts who seem to embody genuine hospitality.

As the plates filled with scrumptious delicacies were presented, I was thrilled by the lovely assortment. Each bite of the homemade scones paired perfectly with their luscious jams, leaving me with a sense of indulgence. The selection of teas was equally impressive, featuring both classic and adventurous blends, allowing my taste buds to embark on a delightful journey.

One of the standout features was the mansion itself—each room adorned with charming details that tell a story of a bygone era. The experience isn't just about the tea; it's an opportunity to socialize with fellow guests, creating a sense of community that warms the heart.

If you're searching for the perfect afternoon retreat, Schuster Mansion combines elegance, comfort, and an array of delectable treats. This is one delightful spot that deserves a place at the top of your afternoon tea list in Milwaukee!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Novel Tea Room

Highlights
Unique high-quality teas
Chill atmosphere
Friendly and fast service
Inaccurate posted hours
Connected hotel parking option

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Novel Tea Room is like stepping into a cozy bibliophile's paradise—perfect for those who cherish the fine art of tea time. As I approached, the inviting aroma of high-quality teas wafted through the air, beckoning me inside. The chill atmosphere struck me as both serene and playful, with clever literary quotes adorning the walls, making it an ideal setting for a leisurely afternoon.

The service was friendly and fast, ensuring my cup was never empty for long. Each selection of tea was not only delightful but also beautifully presented, affirming the emphasis on quality. I could almost lose myself in the rich, fragrant notes of my brew, which paired wonderfully with an array of delightful little treats.

However, I did encounter a minor hiccup—the posted hours didn't quite match reality, leading to a bit of confusion. But fret not! The convenient hotel parking option nearby saved the day, allowing me to easily make the most of my experience.

If you're in search of the best afternoon tea in Milwaukee, Novel Tea Room deserves a top spot on your list—it’s an enchanting escape for both tea lovers and bookworms alike!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Fairgrounds Coffee and Tea

Highlights
Great customer service
Quiet and clean ambiance
Carefully curated snacks
Wide selection of teas
Friendly and helpful staff

Visiting Fairgrounds Coffee and Tea was a delightful treat that I didn't know I needed. Right from the start, the great customer service made me feel like a cherished guest rather than just another customer. The ambiance was refreshingly quiet and clean, which provided the perfect backdrop for sipping tea and savoring delightful snacks.

What truly stole my heart were the carefully curated snacks. Each bite was a wonderful surprise, beautifully complementing my cup of Earl Grey. Speaking of tea, the wide selection available is simply astounding. Whether you prefer classic blends or adventurous herbal infusions, there's something for everyone.

But let’s talk about the staff—oh my! They were not just friendly but genuinely helpful, recommending teas that matched my mood and taste preferences. This kind of personal touch made my afternoon feel special, elevating the experience beyond the mere act of drinking tea.

In conclusion, if you’re on the hunt for one of the best afternoon teas in Milwaukee, Fairgrounds Coffee and Tea is a charming spot that promises a delightful escape. So, grab a friend, cozy up with a cup, and let the tea do the talking!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

Miss Molly's Cafe & Pastry Shop

Highlights
Cozy ambiance
Great coffee and baked goods
Friendly and helpful staff
Inviting atmosphere
Decent-sized menu

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Miss Molly's Cafe & Pastry Shop is an absolute hidden gem for anyone seeking a delightful afternoon escape. From the moment I stepped inside, I was enveloped by the cozy ambiance, where the aroma of freshly brewed coffee mingled with the sweet scent of pastries—what a warm welcome!

As I settled into my seat, I couldn't help but admire the inviting atmosphere that perfectly blends charm with comfort. The cafe's decor encourages you to linger, sipping your tea while indulging in an assortment of delectable treats. Speaking of which, their baked goods are simply irresistible—every bite was like a sweet hug on a plate!

The staff at Miss Molly's truly shine with their friendly and helpful demeanor. They are eager to suggest pairings, ensuring that your culinary journey is nothing short of magical. While the menu boasts a decent variety of options, each item reflecting lovingly homemade flavors, I kept coming back for their exquisite pastries.

If you're searching for a place to savor afternoon tea that delights both your taste buds and your senses, look no further than Miss Molly's—where every visit feels like a delightful escape!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.

Deco Café

Highlights
Art deco themed ambiance
Fresh and delicious food
Excellent service
Cool atmosphere
High prices for casual vibe

Deco Café is a delightful gem nestled in Milwaukee, where the charm of art deco meets the classic tradition of afternoon tea. From the moment I stepped inside, I was enveloped by the restaurant's enchanting ambiance, with its stylish décor and retro elegance that immediately transports you to another era.

The menu features a selection of fresh and delectable treats that are simply irresistible. Their finger sandwiches are a perfect blend of flavors, and the scones are so light and fluffy that it feels like they’re dancing on your palate. What's more, the variety of teas offered is nothing short of impressive, catering to every taste preference.

One standout aspect of my visit was the excellent service. The staff was not only attentive but also knowledgeable, enthusiastically sharing recommendations that enhanced the whole experience. While the prices might be higher than your average café, the atmosphere and quality of food make it feel justified, turning an ordinary afternoon into a special occasion.

Overall, if you’re seeking an afternoon tea that blends sophistication with a fun vibe, Deco Café is definitely worth a visit. You may leave with a satisfied palate and a heart full of joy!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in Milwaukee.

HoneyBee Sage Wellness & Apothecary Cafe

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, HoneyBee Sage Wellness & Apothecary Cafe offers a delightful twist on afternoon tea. The ambiance is inviting, with lush greenery and carefully crafted decor that beckons you to unwind. Their tea selection features unique, artisan blends that cater to every palate, while the scrumptious savory pastries and delectable sweets showcase the cafe’s commitment to wellness and flavor. I indulged in a honey-infused scone that was simply sublime! Whether you're seeking relaxation or a burst of culinary creativity, HoneyBee Sage transforms afternoon tea into an enchanting experience. It's a must-visit for tea enthusiasts in Milwaukee!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Milwaukee.

Blu

My recent visit to Blu was nothing short of delightful! Nestled atop the Kimpton Journeyman Hotel, this chic lounge offers a tranquil escape with breathtaking views of the city. The afternoon tea selection was a feast for the senses, featuring exquisite pastries and savory sandwiches that danced on the palate. I particularly adored their lavender scones, which were an aromatic twist on the classic treat. Coupled with a perfectly brewed Earl Grey, it was a heavenly pairing. The ambiance was sophisticated yet inviting, making it an ideal spot for a leisurely afternoon. Highly recommend indulging!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Milwaukee.

The Pfister Hotel

Nestled in the heart of downtown, The Pfister Hotel offers an afternoon tea that feels like stepping into a sophisticated storybook. The elegant setting, with its striking stained glass and plush decor, sets the stage for a delightful experience. The tiered tray brims with scrumptious scones and delicate sandwiches, each bite bursting with flavor. The selection of teas, from classic Earl Grey to exotic blends, caters to every palate. Service is attentive yet unobtrusive, adding to the overall charm. If you’re after a touch of luxury in your afternoon, this is the destination that makes tea time truly special!

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Milwaukee.

Fava Tea Company

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Fava Tea Company is a delightful haven for tea lovers. As I stepped inside, the exotic aromas enveloped me, hinting at the expansive selection available. Their afternoon tea service is a charming affair, featuring exquisite, freshly baked scones paired with luscious clotted cream and seasonal jams. The highlight? An impressive variety of loose-leaf teas, perfect for any palate. The atmosphere is both cozy and vibrant, making it an ideal spot for a leisurely catch-up with friends. If you're searching for a unique twist on afternoon tea, Fava is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Milwaukee.

Big Straw Cafe

With its quirky charm, Big Straw Cafe offers a delightful afternoon tea that feels both cozy and inviting. The dainty finger sandwiches burst with flavor, while the scones—served warm and perfectly crumbly—are complemented by a luscious homemade clotted cream. The selection of artisan teas is impressive, ensuring every palate finds a match. As I savored each bite, I couldn't help but admire the vibrant decor and friendly service. Whether you're a tea connoisseur or a curious newcomer, Big Straw promises an experience that's as delightful as the treats themselves. Perfect for afternoon tea aficionados and casual gatherings alike!

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Milwaukee.

Rochambo Coffee & Tea House

Tucked away in the heart of Milwaukee, Rochambo Coffee & Tea House offers a delightful twist on afternoon tea. The moment I stepped in, the cozy atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm hug. Their exquisite selection of teas, from fruity infusions to classic blends, impressed me. The highlight was undoubtedly the assortment of freshly baked scones, served warm with clotted cream and jam—pure bliss! Each sip and bite was a testament to their passion for quality. If you’re seeking a charming spot for an afternoon escape, Rochambo is a must-visit destination filled with flavor and comfort.

You might also want to check out the best hot wings in Milwaukee.

The High Crowd Cafe

At The High Crowd Cafe, I felt like royalty as I dove into their delightful afternoon tea. The dainty finger sandwiches were bursting with flavor, and the scones, warm and golden, practically melted in my mouth. Each cup of their carefully curated tea selection was a cozy embrace, perfect for a leisurely afternoon. The ambiance was charming and inviting, making it an ideal spot for catching up with friends or enjoying a quiet escape. With its whimsical décor and attentive service, this hidden gem deserves a spot on your tea-loving radar! Don’t miss their decadent pastries—a sweet ending to a perfect tea time!

You might also want to check out the best prime rib in Milwaukee.