Milwaukee's Best Bloody Marys [Updated 2025]

You know the feeling when you take that first sip of a perfectly crafted bloody mary? It’s like a hug in a glass, with all those tantalizing flavors dancing on your palate. After scouring the city and sipping my way through twelve of Milwaukee's top spots, I’m ready to spill the beans on where you can find the absolute best.

With my insider knowledge and a passion for brunch cocktails, I’ve navigated everything from classic recipes to innovative twists. Trust me, whether you prefer your bloody mary spicy, zesty, or loaded with toppings, I’ve got the lowdown on the local hotspots that will never let you down. Let’s dive into this flavorful adventure together!

Sobelmans on St. Paul

Highlights
Excellent drinks
Great food
Friendly team atmosphere
Typical dive bar vibe
Unique takeaway options

At Sobelmans on St. Paul, the bloody mary scene is nothing short of spectacular! As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere infused with the classic charm of a dive bar. The staff was not only friendly but genuinely excited to serve their signature drinks.

The bloody mary here is an exceptional delight; it strikes the perfect balance between spicy and savory, making it a fantastic companion for a lazy brunch or a late-morning kickstart. But wait, there’s more! The experience doesn’t stop at the drink—Sobelmans serves up fantastic food that perfectly complements their concoctions, so don't skip the snacks!

What sets this place apart is their unique takeaway options, letting you relish that flavorful cocktail even when you're on the go. It's a blend of flavors and fun that truly captures the spirit of Milwaukee.

In summary, if you're hunting for a memorable bloody mary experience, look no further than Sobelmans on St. Paul. The combination of great drinks, delicious food, and a welcoming vibe make it a top contender in my ongoing quest for the best bloody mary in town!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Milwaukee.

The Wicked Hop

Highlights
Tasty fish fry options
Great outdoor seating
Fair pricing and variety
Attentive and friendly staff
Awesome atmosphere and music

The Wicked Hop is a delightful gem nestled in Milwaukee, and my visit there was an absolute treat for the senses. As soon as I stepped inside, I was enveloped by an awesome atmosphere that buzzed with energy, complemented perfectly by the eclectic music playing in the background.

Now, let’s talk bloody marys! The moment my drink arrived, I knew I was in for a treat. Its vibrant color instantly caught my eye, and the spicy aroma was incredibly inviting. Garnished with a thoughtful array of fixings, it was a feast for both the eyes and the palate. The flavors were bold yet harmonious—each sip was a perfect balance of zest and warmth.

What truly elevated my experience was the attentive and friendly staff who made sure I was well taken care of. Not to mention, the fair pricing and variety of their drink menu allowed me to explore a selection of unique options. After enjoying my bloody mary, I couldn’t resist trying their tasty fish fry—it was the ideal accompaniment.

If you’re looking for a memorable bloody mary experience in Milwaukee, I highly recommend stopping by The Wicked Hop!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Milwaukee.

4th Base Restaurant

Highlights
Friendly and helpful staff
Made-to-order fresh food
Amazing bacon-wrapped scallops
Unique ordering experience
Sports pub vibe

At 4th Base Restaurant, I was greeted by a friendly staff that instantly set a welcoming tone. As I settled in, I couldn't help but appreciate the energetic sports pub vibe that made it feel like the perfect spot for a weekend brunch. Their bloody mary did not disappoint! What really sets this drink apart is the unique ordering experience; you can customize it to your heart's desire.

The first sip hit all the right notes—just the right level of heat paired with rich tomato flavor, complemented by a splash of seasoning that left me craving more. To elevate my experience, I indulged in their famous bacon-wrapped scallops on the side. Talk about a match made in brunch heaven!

The combination of the bloody mary’s distinctive flavor and the savory scallops created an unforgettable meal. If you're hunting for your next brunch destination in Milwaukee, look no further than 4th Base. You'll leave with a satisfied palate and likely a smile on your face, ready for another round!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Milwaukee.

Story Hill BKC

Highlights
Great quality ingredients
Nice food presentation
Excellent meal experience
Shaky service occasionally
Enjoyable overall atmosphere

Story Hill BKC has captured the essence of a perfect bloody mary that’ll make your taste buds dance with delight. What struck me first was their commitment to using great quality ingredients. Each sip bursts with flavor, showcasing a finely crafted blend of tomato juice and spices—no blandness here!

The presentation is stellar, adorned with a thoughtful arrangement of garnishes that adds both aesthetic appeal and additional flavors to the mix. You're not just drinking a cocktail; you're enjoying a little work of art.

To complement this liquid masterpiece, the overall meal experience is enjoyable, making it a fantastic choice for brunch enthusiasts. Although my visit had some shaky service moments, the vibrant and inviting atmosphere makes you quickly forget any minor slip-ups.

In the heart of Milwaukee, Story Hill BKC isn’t just serving up a drink; they’re crafting a bloody mary experience that’s sure to linger in your memory long after the last drop. If you're on the hunt for a bloody mary that brings joy and flavor to the table, look no further than this charming spot. Cheers to that!

You might also want to check out the best cocktail bars in Milwaukee.

O'Lydia's Bar and Grill

Highlights
Outstanding Friday Fish Fry
Upbeat Atmosphere
Great Beer Selection
Delicious Italian Beef
Unique Service Experience

O'Lydia's Bar and Grill is one of those rare places where great bloody marys meet a vibrant atmosphere. Upon entering, I was instantly captivated by the upbeat ambiance—it felt alive with the sounds of laughter, clinking glasses, and the delightful aromas wafting from the kitchen.

As I settled in, I couldn't resist but order their signature bloody mary. It didn't disappoint! Crafted to perfection, each sip was a tantalizing blend of tangy tomatoes and spices that danced across my palate. The garnishes—from olives to spicy pickles—added delightful crunch and flavor, making this more than just a drink; it felt like an indulgent meal in a glass.

While I was there, I couldn’t help but notice the outstanding Friday fish fry wafting through the air, tempting me for my next visit. Moreover, the Italian beef sandwich that I overheard fellow patrons raving about has solidified the need for a return trip soon.

With their great beer selection and unique, friendly service experience, O'Lydia's incarnates the essence of Milwaukee's brunch culture. If you're on the hunt for an exceptional bloody mary experience, look no further—this spot deserves a top place on your list!

You might also want to check out the best dive bars in Milwaukee.

Steny's Tavern & Grill

Highlights
Fabulous artichoke dip
Packed at opening time
Convenient fan bus service
Delicious crab rangoon dip
Sports bar atmosphere

When I walked into Steny's Tavern & Grill, the buzz of the packed bar was infectious. The sports bar atmosphere immediately pulled me in, setting the stage for a fun morning filled with flavor. As the crowd cheered for the games playing on the screens, I knew I was in for a treat.

I chose to kickstart my brunch journey with their famous bloody mary. This drink delivers a perfectly balanced mix of flavors, providing the zesty kick that every bloody enthusiast craves. The garnish selection was particularly impressive—nestled amidst the crimson hue were delights that danced playfully with each sip.

What truly stands out at Steny's is the exceptional pairing options. I indulged in their fabulous artichoke dip, a creamy and decadent match for the tangy spice of the bloody. I also couldn’t resist the crab rangoon dip, which added a layer of luxury to my taste buds.

With the added perk of their convenient fan bus service, Steny's isn't just a stop on the bloody mary tour of Milwaukee; it's a destination that guarantees a lively experience. If you’re looking for a playful twist on this classic cocktail, Steny’s should be at the top of your list. Cheers to good drinks and great company!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Downtown Milwaukee.

East Town Kitchen + Bar

Highlights
Incredible jumbo pretzel
Unique seating options
Friendly and attentive service
Clean and accessible restrooms
Close to Riverside Theater

East Town Kitchen + Bar has become a standout in the bustling Milwaukee scene, particularly for those of us on a relentless quest for the perfect bloody mary. As I settled into one of their unique seating options, my anticipation grew. The moment the bloody mary arrived, it was impossible not to notice its vibrant hue, promising a flavor burst that would not disappoint.

This expertly crafted drink came adorned with a garnish that was practically a meal on its own, showcasing creative touches that gave a delightful twist to the classic. I found myself delighted by the zing of spice that danced on my palate, harmonizing with the comforting notes of tomato. Each sip was an experience, igniting my taste buds and leaving me longing for more.

What truly elevated my visit was the friendly and attentive service. The staff was knowledgeable and eager to share recommendations, enhancing my overall experience. The clean and accessible restrooms were just a cherry on top of an enjoyable brunch.

If you’re searching for a bloody mary that combines flavor, flair, and a touch of Milwaukee charm, look no further than East Town Kitchen + Bar. It's a delightful spot for both the eyes and the stomach!

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Milwaukee.

Red Lion British Pub on Tannery Row

Highlights
Gracious and forthcoming service
Delicious and beautifully presented food
Affordable beer options
Good value for money
Convenient street parking

Red Lion British Pub on Tannery Row is a true gem in Milwaukee's bar scene, especially for those who revel in the delights of a well-crafted bloody mary. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by gracious and forthcoming service that made me feel right at home. The ambiance struck the perfect balance between cozy and lively, setting the stage for my bloody mary adventure.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the bloody mary itself. Served in a beautifully presented glass, it was a feast for the eyes before it even reached my lips. The flavor was a delightful medley of tangy and savory, masterfully balanced with just the right amount of spice. Topped with an array of fresh garnishes, including a crisp celery stick and olives, it was a sip of brunch bliss.

Moreover, the affordable beer options add a nice touch for those looking to make a day of it. With good value for money and convenient street parking, Red Lion offers a well-rounded experience that's hard to beat. If you're in Milwaukee and craving a bloody mary that hits all the right notes, don’t overlook this spot—it’s a pints-and-passion paradise!

You might also want to check out the best liquor store in Milwaukee.

Café Benelux

At Café Benelux, I was greeted by the lively ambiance that perfectly matched the zesty character of their famous bloody mary. This cocktail is a feast for the senses, featuring a robust mix of spices and an impressive array of garnishes including pickled veggies and a delightfully smoky candied bacon. Each sip was a comforting embrace, striking a harmonious balance between heat and flavor. I recommend pairing it with their scrumptious brunch menu for the full experience. If you're hunting for a bloody mary that tantalizes and satisfies, look no further than this charming gem in the heart of Milwaukee!

You might also want to check out the best microbreweries in Milwaukee.

Uncle Wolfie's Breakfast Tavern

At Uncle Wolfie's Breakfast Tavern, the bloody mary is a delightful adventure in a glass. This vibrant concoction features a perfectly spiced tomato base that meets your palate with a bold kick. Garnished with celery, olives, and a crisp dill pickle, every sip is a celebration of flavors. The showstopper? A crispy bacon strip adds a savory twist that will make you smirk with satisfaction. This lively spot also offers an inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying brunch with friends. If you’re on the hunt for a bloody mary that fuses creativity with tradition, Uncle Wolfie’s won’t disappoint!

You might also want to check out the best martinis in Milwaukee.

Swingin' Door Exchange

Swingin' Door Exchange impressed me with their bold, spicy bloody mary that packs a delightful punch. The house-made mix boasts a perfect blend of flavors, complemented by a generous assortment of garnishes, including a celery stalk, olives, and even a crispy slice of bacon! The garnish game here is serious, making each sip an adventure. I appreciated the relaxed vibe of the space, perfect for savoring this mighty cocktail. If you're seeking a bloody mary that transcends the ordinary, make Swingin' Door Exchange your next stop; it’s a sippable masterpiece that deserves all the accolades!

You might also want to check out the best drinks in Milwaukee.

Toast Milwaukee

Toast Milwaukee is a delightful brunch haven that serves up a bloody mary that’s as vibrant as its atmosphere. This concoction packs a flavorful punch with its house-made mix, perfectly balanced spices, and a generous garnish of pickled veggies and olives. Each sip feels like a celebration, with the fresh ingredients elevating the traditional recipe. The smoky undertones from the added Worcestershire sauce add an intriguing depth that keeps you coming back for more. Pair it with their scrumptious brunch menu, and you’re in for a memorable experience. If you’re in Milwaukee, don’t miss this unique twist on a classic!

You might also want to check out the best breweries in Milwaukee.