New Berlin's Best Bloody Mary [Updated 2025]

As I sipped my way through twelve top spots in New Berlin, I couldn't help but marvel at the creativity and flair each place brought to their bloody mary game. Trust me—I've tasted everything from the classic vodka-infused versions to wild concoctions topped with bacon, shrimp, and even pickled veggies that would make any brunch lover's heart skip a beat.

My passion for this iconic cocktail has turned into a quest for the ultimate blend of spices, flavors, and garnishes, and I'm here to share the best of the best with you. Get ready to discover where to find your next favorite bloody mary in this charming Wisconsin town!

Mary's Caddyshack And Grill

Highlights
Laid-back local atmosphere
Live music on Sundays
Friendly, engaging bartenders
Great value for food and drinks
Perfect for golfers

At Mary's Caddyshack And Grill, the atmosphere is laid-back and inviting, making it a perfect spot for both golfers and non-golfers alike. As I settled in, I was greeted by friendly bartenders who genuinely seemed passionate about their craft. And let me tell you, their bloody mary is nothing short of spectacular.

With a vibrant mix of fresh ingredients, this bloody mary boasts a rich and zesty flavor that awakened my taste buds. Each sip was a delightful dance of spices that left me yearning for more. But what truly sets this drink apart is the generous garnishing: think crunchy pickles, tangy olives, and a distinctive touch of their house-made rim.

The value at Mary's Caddyshack is impressive too—delicious drinks at reasonable prices. As a bonus, the lively ambiance complemented by live music on Sundays made my visit even more enjoyable. Whether you’re a golfing enthusiast or just in need of a great bloody mary, I can confidently say, this spot is a must-visit.

So, swing by for a drink that will tantalize your palate and raise your spirits!

You might also want to check out the best bloody marys in Milwaukee.

Cleveland Pub & Grill

Highlights
Friendly and prompt service
Great for group gatherings
Low key sports bar atmosphere
No wait for seating
Perfect for casual date nights

Cleveland Pub & Grill in New Berlin is a delightful spot that perfectly blends casual charm with a warm atmosphere—ideal for anyone looking to enjoy a fantastic Bloody Mary. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by friendly staff who ensured my experience would be top-notch from start to finish. No waiting for seating here, a definite plus for the eager customer!

The vibe of the pub is laid-back, making it a fantastic choice for everything from group gatherings to casual date nights. My Bloody Mary was a delightful concoction—spiced just right with a robust flavor profile that made each sip more enjoyable than the last. Topped with a perfect garnish, it was the ideal complement to the savory notes of this beloved cocktail.

Whether you’re watching a game or simply enjoying a lazy afternoon, Cleveland Pub & Grill is an excellent destination for bloody mary aficionados. I left with a satisfied palate and a promise to return, as this pub has etched its place in my heart for serving one of the best Bloody Marys in New Berlin. Cheers to that!

You might also want to check out the best bloody marys in West Allis.

Nickel's

Highlights
Hometown friendly atmosphere
Friendly bartenders
Unique shakes of the day

Nickel's in New Berlin is truly a hidden gem! As I stepped inside, I was immediately embraced by a hometown friendly atmosphere that set the perfect backdrop for what was about to become a delightful experience. The bartenders, with their warm smiles and contagious energy, made ordering my bloody mary a joy rather than a task.

This is where things got interesting. Nickel's offers a playful twist with its unique shakes of the day, allowing every patron to discover a new flavor profile with each visit. I opted for a spicy variant that was masterfully crafted, perfectly balancing bold flavors and just the right amount of heat. The garnishes were not only fresh but flair-filled, featuring everything from crisp celery to artisan pickles that added that extra wow factor.

The overall vibe was incredibly inviting, making it an ideal spot to relax and enjoy brunch with friends or even a peaceful solo escape. I left Nickel's not only satisfied but excited to return and explore more of what their dynamic bloody mary menu has to offer! If you're in New Berlin, don't miss out on this top-notch experience!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Milwaukee.

Uncle Jimmy's Pub And Grill

Highlights
Friendly and cool owner
Homemade meatball sandwiches
Top-notch cheese curds
Fair prices for quality food
Respect for first responders

Uncle Jimmy's Pub And Grill is an absolute gem in New Berlin, and boy, did they impress me with their bloody mary! As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly and cool owner, who instantly made me feel at home. The atmosphere was relaxed, the kind of place you can unwind after a long week.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the bloody mary. It was well-balanced, with just the right kick of spice. Topped generously with a zesty celery stalk, it danced on my palate in the most delightful way. They even have a fun twist, possibly inspired by their famous homemade meatball sandwiches.

And while you're there, don't miss out on their top-notch cheese curds; they pair perfectly with the cocktail. Not to mention, the fair prices for quality food make it an ideal spot to indulge without breaking the bank. Plus, I truly appreciate their respect for first responders, which adds a charming touch.

If you're in search of a vibrant spot for a bloody mary that hits all the right notes, Uncle Jimmy's should definitely be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Downtown Milwaukee.

Clubhouse Bar & Grill

Highlights
Excellent food and service
Delicious homemade chili dip
Phenomenal brisket sandwiches
Friendly and attentive staff
Unique indoor/outdoor golf

Review of Clubhouse Bar & Grill

Stepping into Clubhouse Bar & Grill felt like walking into a warm hug—both welcoming and vibrant. The ambiance perfectly sets the stage for what soon became an unforgettable day, especially when it comes to their bloody mary. This concoction is a true masterpiece; a delightful blend of spices and flavors awakens the senses and instantly embraces your taste buds.

The garnishes—an array that could outshine a fireworks display—include everything from a zesty pickle to plump olives, all perched atop that tantalizing rim of seasoning. I couldn’t resist pairing my drink with their delicious homemade chili dip, and I can confidently say the combination was pure magic.

While sipping my bloody mary, I couldn’t help but admire how the friendly and attentive staff made everything feel seamless. They are like old friends, eager to ensure every sip is savored. Adding to the charm, the indoor/outdoor golf setup gave the entire experience a relaxed vibe, inviting visitors to unwind.

In a town rich with competition, Clubhouse Bar & Grill has undeniably raised the bar, making it a must-visit for anyone in search of the best bloody mary in New Berlin. Cheers to that! 🍹

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Cedarburg.

Natty Oaks Pub & Eatery

Highlights
Fun, casual bar atmosphere
Friendly service
Great outdoor space
High-energy dining experience
Popular local favorite

Natty Oaks Pub & Eatery is a true gem in New Berlin's vibrant dining scene, and their bloody mary is nothing short of spectacular. Stepping into this lively establishment, I immediately felt the fun, casual bar atmosphere that sets the perfect backdrop for brunch or a laid-back afternoon. The friendly service was a delightful bonus; the staff genuinely enjoys what they do, making the experience all the more enjoyable.

Now, let’s dive into the star of the show: the bloody mary. This concoction arrives with a vibrant hue and a garnish that could easily double as a meal. The balance of flavors is executed beautifully – the spice level is just right, awakening the senses without overwhelming them. The addition of unique garnishes showcases Natty Oaks' commitment to elevating this classic cocktail beyond the ordinary.

What really sets this spot apart is the high-energy dining experience. Whether you’re enjoying your drink on the spacious outdoor patio or inside, the ambiance is infectious. Locals flock here not just for the drinks but for a community feel. If you’re on a quest for the best bloody mary in New Berlin, look no further than Natty Oaks – it’s a flavorful ride you won’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Brookfield.

Brass Monkey Pub

Highlights
Friendly and fast service
Great food despite delays
Large portions available
Busy atmosphere with events
Need for improved customer attention

Brass Monkey Pub in New Berlin is a lively spot that had my taste buds dancing the moment I walked in. The atmosphere pulses with energy, especially during their vibrant weekend events, making it the ideal place to indulge in a bloody mary.

Upon ordering, I was greeted with a friendly smile and swift service that set the tone for an enjoyable brunch. The bloody mary itself was a delightful concoction, bursting with flavor and beautifully garnished. Each sip was a zesty adventure, featuring a robust spice blend that left a tantalizing kick. However, I must admit, I found the drink a tad on the milder side for my adventurous palate; a more daring choice of heat could elevate it to perfection.

Despite a few delays in food coming out due to the bustling crowd, the portions were generous and definitely worth the wait. Brass Monkey Pub seamlessly combines a lively ambiance with comfort, making it a great weekend destination. Just a nudge towards improved customer attention when it’s crowded, and this place could easily bring home the title of the best bloody mary in New Berlin. Overall, if you’re looking for a fun and flavorful brunch experience, Brass Monkey should be on your radar!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Milwaukee.

Brunch Berry

At Brunch Berry, the bloody mary left me both delighted and intrigued. This vibrant concoction features a bold mix of spices, perfectly complemented by a generous array of toppings, including crispy bacon and a tangy pickled green bean. The fresh flavors burst with every sip, providing a delightful balance of heat and zest. The presentation was equally impressive, served with a colorful skewer of garnishes that made my taste buds dance. Overall, Brunch Berry offers an unforgettable bloody mary experience that undoubtedly earns its place among the best in New Berlin. Cheers to enhanced brunches!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Milwaukee.

Matty's Bar & Grille

At Matty's Bar & Grille, the bloody mary is a culinary masterpiece that elevates brunch to a whole new level. Their signature mix, perfectly seasoned with just the right amount of spice, offers a delightful kick without being overwhelming. I was particularly enchanted by the garnish tower, featuring crispy bacon, olives, and even a pickled green bean—talk about a flavor explosion! Served ice-cold, it’s a refreshing treat that pairs wonderfully with their brunch offerings. If you’re on the hunt for a bloody mary that’s both bold and satisfying, Matty’s definitely deserves a spot on your list!

You might also want to check out the best cocktail bars in Milwaukee.

19th Hole Country Club

At the 19th Hole Country Club, I was greeted by an ambiance that perfectly matched the spirit of a relaxed Sunday brunch. Their bloody mary is a vibrant concoction, boasting a blend of rich, tomatoey goodness and a perfect kick of spice. Topped with a delightful skewer of olives, celery, and a bold shrimp, it’s a feast for the eyes and palate alike! What truly sets it apart is the house-made seasoning that adds a unique flair to each sip. If you’re hunting for a bloody mary that embodies both creativity and comfort, this is where your search ends. Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best dive bars in Milwaukee.

West Side Pub

When I stepped into West Side Pub, the vibrant atmosphere set the stage for their highly acclaimed bloody mary. This concoction boasts a perfect balance of spice and tang, making each sip a delightful adventure. The garnish was a feast for the eyes and palate—think crispy bacon and pickled veggies that elevate the drink from ordinary to extraordinary. Not only does it pack a flavorful punch, but the pub's cozy vibe is perfect for a relaxed brunch or a spirited gathering. If you're on a quest for the ultimate bloody mary in New Berlin, West Side Pub is a must-visit gem!

You might also want to check out the best bloody marys in Milwaukee.

Varsity Club

At Varsity Club, the bloody mary is nothing short of a delightful game-changer. The perfectly balanced blend of spices offers a piquant kick that dances on the palate, while the generous garnishes—think crispy bacon and zesty pickles—elevate it to a gourmet experience. The smoky essence hints of horseradish and Worcestershire invite you to sip slowly, savoring each moment. The ambiance buzzes with a playful energy, making it a perfect spot for weekend brunch. If you're seeking a bloody mary that packs a punch, Varsity Club should be your first stop in New Berlin! Cheers to delicious adventures!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Downtown Milwaukee.