The Absolute Best Bloody Mary in Cedarburg [Updated 2025]

I dove headfirst into Cedarburg's vibrant brunch scene, and let me tell you, the quest for the perfect Bloody Mary is no small feat. After reviewing 12 top locations, I’ve sipped, savored, and soaked up the unique twists each spot offers.

You can trust my taste buds—I’ve navigated everything from classic recipes to wild concoctions that challenge the palate. Each Bloody Mary I encountered had its own character, and I can’t wait to spill the beans on which one truly reigns supreme in this charming town. So, grab your celery stick and let’s get into the mouthwatering details!

Brunch

Highlights
Spectacular Bloody Mary flights
Delicious food options
Patient server for large groups
Wobbly tables cause spills
Long wait for table availability

At Brunch in Cedarburg, the quest for the perfect Bloody Mary hits a delightful peak! As I settled down, I was instantly drawn to their spectacular Bloody Mary flights, which offered an enticing variety. Each sip took me on a zesty journey, packed with flavor and garnished to perfection.

The menu didn’t disappoint either; the delicious food options perfectly complemented my bold concoctions. I highly recommend pairing your drink with their scrumptious brunch items. However, as I settled into my meal, I couldn’t help but laugh at the wobbly tables—a minor hiccup that caused a couple of spills along the way, much to the amusement of my dining companions.

Despite this, the ambiance was vibrant, though we faced a lengthy wait for our table—definitely something to consider if you’re headed there on a bustling weekend!

One aspect I truly appreciated was the patient server, who adeptly managed our large group without breaking a sweat. All in all, Brunch offers a rich experience for anyone in search of a standout Bloody Mary that’s sure to make your taste buds tingle!

You might also want to check out the best bloody marys in Milwaukee.

Toast Cedarburg

Highlights
Super cute hippie vibes
Delicious breakfast options
Beautifully crafted lattes
Quiet, cozy atmosphere
Tasty tomato basil soup

Toast Cedarburg is a delightful hidden gem that beautifully marries style and flavor. Stepping into this charming establishment, I was immediately enveloped in its super cute hippie vibes—the kind of place that makes you want to kick back and savor every moment. Now, let’s get to the main event: the bloody mary!

At Toast, the bloody mary is an exquisite experience, crafted with care and depth of flavor. The blend of perfectly spiced tomato juice reflects the dedication of the staff, and each sip bursts with vibrancy. They also offer a variety of breakfast options that complement a lazy weekend brunch perfectly. Pairing my drink with their delicious breakfast feels like a celebration on a plate!

One of the highlights is the cozy atmosphere that makes it ideal for quiet conversations or solo enjoyment, accompanied by some beautifully crafted lattes. As I sipped my bloody mary, the tranquil setting was the cherry on top, inviting me to linger a little longer.

So, if you're wandering through Cedarburg and searching for a bloody mary that ticks all the right boxes, Toast Cedarburg is the place to be. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Milwaukee.

Union House Cedarburg | Restaurant & Bar

Highlights
Exceptional Customer Service
Charming Holiday Decorations
Unique Tapas Menu Options
Inviting Atmosphere
Family-Owned Comfort

When I stepped into Union House Cedarburg, I was immediately enveloped by its inviting atmosphere, a perfect blend of cozy charm and light-hearted decor. The holiday decorations added a festive flair, making the space feel warm and welcoming. The friendly staff greeted me with smiles, and their exceptional customer service only enhanced the experience.

Now, let’s get to the star of the show: the bloody mary. This concoction was a masterpiece, bursting with bold flavors and a remarkable balance of spices. Each sip was a delightful adventure, with a hint of smoky undertones that lingered just long enough to beckon me back for more. I appreciated the creative garnishes that accompanied the drink, making it feel like a full-fledged meal rather than just a cocktail.

Pairing this bloody bliss with some unique offerings from their tapas menu was a stroke of genius. The delectable small plates complemented the drink beautifully without stealing the spotlight. If you're on the hunt for a bloody mary that delights the senses, look no further than Union House. This gem of Cedarburg has certainly earned its place in my heart!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Brookfield.

The Rooftop Cedarburg

At The Rooftop Cedarburg, the bloody mary is nothing short of spectacular! This delightful concoction bursts with flavors that perfectly blend spice and tang. The garnish is an adventurous array of olives, pickles, and even a crispy strip of bacon—yes, please! The moment you take a sip, you’re transported to a sun-drenched patio, savoring the vibrant atmosphere. The cocktail's presentation is as stunning as the scenic views, making it an ideal spot for a weekend brunch. If you’re searching for a bloody mary that’s both delicious and inventive, look no further than The Rooftop—a true Cedarburg gem!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Milwaukee.

Five20 Social Stop

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Inviting atmosphere
Engaging owner interactions
Great live music
Fresh and unique cocktails

At Five20 Social Stop, I was greeted with warm smiles and an inviting atmosphere that immediately set the tone for a delightful brunch. The friendly staff made me feel right at home, and the engaging conversation with the owner added a personal touch to my visit.

But let's get to the star of the show: the bloody mary! This cocktail was not merely a drink; it was an experience that tantalized my taste buds. Crafted with fresh ingredients, the mix burst with vibrant flavors, perfectly balanced with a zesty kick that left me wanting more. I could taste the attention to detail in every sip, showcasing the mixologist's expertise.

To complement the lively ambiance, the backdrop of great live music elevated the entire experience, making it not just a meal but a celebration. Five20 is a haven for bloody mary lovers and social butterflies alike. Every visit is a reminder that brunch is not just about food; it's about community.

So, if you find yourself in Cedarburg and yearning for the best bloody mary, look no further than Five20 Social Stop — your palate will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Milwaukee.

Anvil Pub & Grille

Highlights
Historic riverside location
Fast and friendly service
Exceptional outdoor seating
Great food
Repeat visits highly anticipated

Anvil Pub & Grille, nestled by the scenic riverside in Cedarburg, has firmly planted itself in my heart as a top contender for the best bloody mary in the area. The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by a vibrant ambiance and the fast, friendly service that instantly put me at ease. I was particularly impressed with the exceptional outdoor seating, which provided a delightful backdrop to my bloody mary adventure.

Now, let’s talk about the drink itself! The mixologist at Anvil clearly knows their craft. The bloody mary was a perfect balance of spicy and savory, adorned with an array of tasty garnishes that would make any bloody aficionado swoon. I couldn’t help but savor each sip, contemplating how the flavors danced on my palate.

What sets Anvil apart, besides the stellar drink, is the mouthwatering food that complements the cocktail experience. I found myself eagerly planning a repeat visit to explore more of their menu items while enjoying another bloody mary. If you’re in Cedarburg and seeking a delightful brunch spot, Anvil Pub & Grille is a must-stop for an unforgettable bloody mary experience!

You might also want to check out the best cocktail bars in Milwaukee.

Rebellion Brewing USA

Highlights
Hidden gem by a waterfall
Good beer, great atmosphere
Cozy, intimate setting
Unique political decor
Small but inviting space

Review of Rebellion Brewing USA

Nestled beside a charming waterfall, Rebellion Brewing USA is truly a hidden gem in Cedarburg, and their bloody mary is nothing short of a masterpiece. Upon entering, I'm immediately enveloped in a cozy, intimate atmosphere that feels both welcoming and invigorating. The unique political decor adds a quirky touch, making it a delightful spot to sip on a drink while soaking in the vibes.

Now, let’s talk about that bloody mary! It's crafted with care, featuring a perfect balance of spices and flavors that tantalize the taste buds. The presentation is bold and eye-catching with vibrant garnishes that elevate the experience. Each sip is like a culinary adventure, with the smoky undertones and a hint of heat dancing harmoniously together.

Complementing the experience are their exceptional beers, which offer a fantastic pairing option. Honestly, Rebellion Brewing offers an ambiance that beckons you to stay longer, especially when you have a drink in hand that you never want to end. It’s clear: when it comes to bloody maries, this spot has firmly planted its flag in Cedarburg’s vibrant food scene. So if you're in the area, treat yourself—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best dive bars in Milwaukee.

Brandywine

Highlights
Cozy and inviting atmosphere
Excellent service and attentiveness
Outstanding hand-made pastas
Clearly marked gluten-free options
Unique drink selections

Visiting Brandywine in Cedarburg was like stepping into a warm embrace on a chilly weekend morning. As I settled into the cozy atmosphere, the attention I received from the staff was simply exemplary—they truly know how to make you feel cherished as a guest.

Now, let's talk about their bloody mary. This isn’t just any cocktail; it’s crafted with meticulous care, showcasing a balance of classic flavors and bold spices. The careful infusion of house-made ingredients elevates it above the rest. It's topped with a delightful array of garnishes that could easily make a meal on their own, such as crunchy pickles and zesty olives. Each sip was a joyful exploration of flavors that reminded me why I adore this iconic drink.

While the atmosphere invites you to linger, the presence of a unique drink selection had me contemplating my order well before I arrived. Pair it with their outstanding hand-made pastas, and you've got a meal that celebrates indulgence. If you're on the hunt for a delightful and thrilling bloody mary experience, Brandywine should be at the top of your list in Cedarburg. It's a flavorful adventure you don't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best bloody marys in Milwaukee.

PJ Piper Pancake House

Highlights
Fantastic server experience
Incredibly fast service
Food is to die for
Busy yet nice atmosphere
Reasonable pricing for groups

At PJ Piper Pancake House, my quest for the ultimate bloody mary unfolded in a delightful atmosphere. The place was bustling, yet it exuded a cozy charm that made me feel right at home. With incredibly fast service promptly bringing my drink, I was excited to dive into what this location had to offer.

The bloody mary itself was a vivid masterpiece—a bold blend of spices that danced on my palate with every sip. Garnished with all the right fixings, this cocktail perfectly complemented my meal, which, by the way, was to die for. Their pancakes are legendary, but it was the bloody mary that truly stole the show!

What impressed me beyond the drink, though, was the fantastic server experience. The staff was not only friendly but also attentive, making sure I had everything I needed. And with reasonable pricing for groups, it’s a perfect spot to gather with friends after a long week.

Overall, if you're looking for an exquisite bloody mary in Cedarburg, make PJ Piper Pancake House your next stop. This delightful establishment will surely satisfy your craving for a well-crafted cocktail!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Downtown Milwaukee.

Cream & Crepe Cafe

Highlights
Exceptional Service
Charming Atmosphere
Delicious Crepes Available
Amazing Daily Specials
Highly Recommended

Cream & Crepe Cafe in Cedarburg is a delightful gem that truly knows how to serve a bloody mary. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by exceptional service that set the tone for my visit. The charming atmosphere—adorned with whimsical decor—made sipping this drink feel like a special occasion.

Now, let's talk about that bloody mary! It was a concoction of vibrant flavors that danced on my palate, featuring house-made mix that was perfectly balanced, neither too spicy nor too mild. The garnishes were generous and imaginative, with fresh pickles, olives, and even a playful twist of bacon that not only added a savory crunch but also appreciated the cafe's flair for creativity.

I paired this zesty delight with one of their delicious crepes—the perfect companion to my drink. On top of that, I couldn't resist their amazing daily specials which took the experience up a notch. If you’re searching for a standout bloody mary in Cedarburg, Cream & Crepe Cafe comes highly recommended. With their warmth and vibrant offerings, you're bound to leave with a smile and perhaps a renewed love for brunch!

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Milwaukee.

Sierzant

Highlights
Charming and inviting space
Knowledgeable and friendly staff
Fantastic drink selection
Great for date nights
Beautifully renovated ambiance

Sierzant in Cedarburg is an absolute gem! The moment I stepped into this charming and inviting space, I knew I was in for a treat. The renovated ambiance strikes a perfect balance between chic and cozy, making it ideal not just for a casual brunch but also for those romantic date nights.

Now, let’s talk about their bloody mary. This signature drink is not just your average cocktail; it's a carefully crafted masterpiece! Each sip enveloped my palate with a delightful blend of spices and a perfect level of heat that makes the experience truly memorable. What I particularly enjoyed was the knowledgeable and friendly staff, who were eager to share their insights about the drink’s unique ingredients. They clearly take pride in every aspect of their craft.

Whether you’re with friends or out for a special occasion, Sierzant has you covered. Their fantastic drink selection pairs wonderfully with their well-curated menu, ensuring that your visit is nothing short of extraordinary. If you find yourself in Cedarburg, make sure Sierzant is on your list for the best bloody mary experience! 🥂

You might also want to check out the best liquor store in Milwaukee.

Art of Joy Social House & Mercantile

At Art of Joy Social House & Mercantile, the bloody mary is a vibrant feast for the senses. This delightful concoction strikes the perfect balance between spicy and savory, with a robust tomato base complemented by a kick of top-shelf vodka. The garnishes, ranging from crisp bacon to tangy pickles, elevate the drink into a mini-meal. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it an ideal spot for brunch. If you’re searching for a bloody mary that embodies both creativity and flavor, this gem deserves a top spot on your list during your Cedarburg adventures!

You might also want to check out the best singles bars in Milwaukee.