West Allis' Best Bloody Marys [Updated 2025]

Every sip of a well-crafted bloody mary is like a little celebration, and I’ve made it my mission to discover the ultimate versions right here in my beloved West Allis. After scouring the local scene and sampling a dozen standout spots, I’ve unearthed some hidden gems and a few beloved classics that are sure to tantalize your taste buds.

You might wonder why you should trust my findings—well, with years of brunches spent scrutinizing each spice blend and garnish, I’ve developed a discerning palate that knows a great bloody mary when it tastes one. Join me as I dive into the rich flavors and unique twists that make these local concoctions truly unforgettable!

The Crooked Crow

Highlights
Best Caesar Salad in West Allis
Friendly bartenders
Tasty burgers and monthly specials
Limited seating
Delicious food options

The Crooked Crow has certainly carved a niche for itself in West Allis, and I had the pleasure of trying their bloody mary during my visit. Right from the outset, I was greeted by friendly bartenders who made me feel right at home. As I sipped my drink, the first thing that struck me was its perfect balance of spices—a zesty kick that danced on my palate, making it an invigorating start to my day.

Accompanying my bloody mary was a delightful Caesar salad, which is often touted as the best in West Allis. The vibrant greens paired perfectly with the drink, elevating the entire experience. The atmosphere, despite the limited seating, was lively and inviting, making it an ideal spot to gather with friends.

Not to be overshadowed, the burgers and monthly specials also call for a return visit. The opportunity to pair a classic bloody mary with such delicious food is a rare delight. Overall, The Crooked Crow is not just a place to enjoy a bloody mary; it’s a destination for a taste of community and good cheer. Next time you’re in West Allis, don’t miss out on this quirky gem!

You might also want to check out the best bloody marys in Milwaukee.

Natty Oaks Pub & Eatery

Highlights
Fun and casual atmosphere
Friendly service
Nice outdoor space
Great bar food options
High-energy environment

Natty Oaks Pub & Eatery is an unassuming gem tucked away in West Allis that delights with its energetic atmosphere and friendly vibe. As I wandered in, I was immediately drawn to the casual decor and laugh-filled conversations bouncing off the walls. What truly set the stage for my visit, however, was the inviting outdoor space—the perfect backdrop for enjoying a spirited brunch.

Now, let's talk about the bloody mary. This is no ordinary concoction; it’s a bold blend of spices that awakens your senses with every sip. The drink boasts a well-balanced mix of savory and tangy, accompanied by just the right amount of heat—definitely a point in its favor. To enhance the experience, expect generous garnishes that flirt with your taste buds; a crispy celery stalk and a pickled vegetable medley take this drink to the next level.

Pairing this vibrant drink with the tasty bar food options made for an undeniable combination. Natty Oaks is a must-visit for bloody mary enthusiasts looking for a spirited start to their day, wrapped in a friendly atmosphere. If you're in West Allis, do yourself a favor and stop by!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Milwaukee.

Brass Monkey Pub

Highlights
Large fish portions
Friendly and fast service
Great food worth the wait
Busy atmosphere
Music bingo events

As I stepped into Brass Monkey Pub, the bustling atmosphere immediately enveloped me. The excitement of patrons mingling over drinks and food set the perfect backdrop for my exploration of their renowned bloody mary. I was instantly greeted by the friendly and fast service, which only enhanced my anticipation.

The bloody mary itself was a delightful masterpiece. It boasted a robust and flavorful base, perfectly spiced without overwhelming the palate. Topped with a generous assortment of garnishes, it felt like a meal in a glass! I particularly appreciated the use of fresh ingredients, which elevated this classic cocktail to a new level.

While waiting for my drink, I couldn't help but notice the large fish portions being served, which looked utterly tempting. I later learned that great food is worth the wait at this lively venue. It's a place where you can indulge in your craving for a savory cocktail while enjoying events like music bingo—a fantastic way to kick off your weekend.

Overall, my visit to Brass Monkey was a fun experience, and their bloody mary definitely holds a spot among the best in West Allis. If you're on the hunt for bold flavors and a vibrant atmosphere, make your way to this pub for a drink that’s sure to impress!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Milwaukee.

4th Base Restaurant

Highlights
Made-to-order food
Friendly and helpful service
Unique ordering experience
Amazing bacon-wrapped scallops
Casual sports pub atmosphere

4th Base Restaurant is a charming gem in West Allis, where the atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between casual sports pub vibes and delightful culinary offerings. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly and helpful service that set the tone for my visit. The unique ordering experience truly caught my attention; patrons can customize their drinks to their heart's content!

When it came to the bloody mary, I was eager to discover how 4th Base would impress. I was not disappointed. Their perfectly spiced concoction was robust yet smooth, making it utterly enjoyable. But the real showstopper was the pairing of my drink with amazing bacon-wrapped scallops, which complemented the savory boldness of the bloody mary perfectly.

While the restaurant buzzed with excitement, it felt welcoming enough to linger a little longer over the perfectly crafted mix. Overall, the 4th Base is a delightful spot for blood mary lovers, especially if you're looking for a casual hangout where you can indulge in extraordinary flavors. I left satisfied, already planning my next visit to savor more of their delightful offerings; it’s a must-try in West Allis!

You might also want to check out the best cocktail bars in Milwaukee.

Camino - West Allis

At Camino - West Allis, the bloody mary was a delightful experience that danced on my palate. Their mix is a perfect balance of spicy and savory, complemented by a vibrant array of garnishes, including crisp vegetables and a bold pickle. The drink is served in a generously sized glass, ensuring you savor every famous sip. What truly sets this bloody apart is their homemade mix, which boasts a tantalizing kick. The friendly atmosphere and attentive staff elevate the whole experience, making it a prime destination for brunch lovers. If you're on the hunt for a stellar bloody mary, look no further than Camino!

You might also want to check out the best dive bars in Milwaukee.

Burnsie's Bar & Grill

At Burnsie's Bar & Grill, the bloody mary packs a flavor punch that's hard to forget! This delightful concoction features a perfect balance of spice with a house-made mix that dances on the taste buds. Topped with crispy bacon, a dill pickle spear, and even a mini cheeseburger, it’s not just a drink; it's a meal in a glass! The ambiance is warm and welcoming, making it an ideal spot for brunch with friends. If you're on a quest for a bloody mary that goes the extra mile, this gem in West Allis is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best bloody marys in Milwaukee.

Station No. 06

At Station No. 06, the bloody mary is an adventurous symphony of flavors! Served in a generous glass, its robust tomato base sings with just the right kick of spice. I particularly enjoyed the vibrant garnishes, including pickled veggies and a crispy bacon strip that added a delightful crunch. The house-made mix truly stands out, making each sip a unique delight. If you're seeking a bold, brunch-ready cocktail, this spot is a must-visit. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you! Don't miss out on this West Allis gem!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Downtown Milwaukee.

Paulie's Pub & Eatery

At Paulie's Pub & Eatery, the bloody mary is a delightful revelation. Their blend of vibrant spices and fresh ingredients creates a drink that’s both robust and refreshing. The garnish game is strong, featuring a skewer of house-pickled vegetables that adds an unexpected crunch. With a hint of jalapeño to spice things up, it's a perfect companion for brunch. The ambiance is welcoming, making it an ideal spot to sip and savor. If you're on the hunt for a bloody mary that dances on your palate, Paulie's might just be your new favorite go-to. 🍅🌶️

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Milwaukee.

Schotskis West Allis

At Schotskis West Allis, I was greeted with a bloody mary that truly shines. The moment I took my first sip, I was captivated by the rich, bold flavors that danced on my palate. The house-made mix, featuring a perfect balance of spices, complemented the generous garnishes—a crisp celery stalk, tangy olives, and a zesty pickle spear. This concoction also boasted a delightful splash of horseradish, adding just the right kick. What really set it apart was their imaginative twist with smoky bacon floating alongside. If you're a bloody mary enthusiast, this spot is a must-visit! Cheers to great mornings in West Allis!

You might also want to check out the best liquor store in Milwaukee.

Studz Pub

At Studz Pub, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere that set the perfect stage for a delightful brunch. Their bloody mary is a true masterpiece—spicy, flavorful, and beautifully garnished with an array of toppings that elevate the experience. The house-made mix is rich and tangy, complemented by a generous stick of celery and a zesty pickle spear that dances on your palate. The kick from the seasoning had me savoring every sip, making it a splendid choice for anyone looking to indulge. Overall, Studz Pub’s bloody mary is a must-try for enthusiasts seeking a delicious twist.

You might also want to check out the best singles bars in Milwaukee.

Flappers

At Flappers, the bloody marys are a delightful concoction that dances on the palate. This vibrant spot offers a smoky twist, featuring a generous splash of Worcestershire sauce and a hint of hot sauce that elevates the flavor profile. Each drink comes adorned with an impressive array of garnishes: crisp celery, briny olives, and an unexpected slice of bacon that adds a savory touch. The atmosphere buzzes with energy, making it the perfect place to sip and savor your morning. If you’re on the hunt for a bloody mary that blends flavor with fun, Flappers is a must-try destination!

You might also want to check out the best rooftop bars in Milwaukee.

Fourth-N-Long

At Fourth-N-Long, the bloody mary transcends the ordinary; it's an adventure in a glass! This vibrant concoction is served with a delightful array of garnishes, including crispy bacon and a zesty pickle spear, making each sip a flavorful journey. The balance of spices is just right, bringing a satisfying kick without overwhelming the palate. The atmosphere is lively, perfectly complementing the drink's spirited essence. Each visit feels like a celebration, and their bloody mary is truly a standout. If you're on the hunt for an extraordinary morning pick-me-up, look no further than Fourth-N-Long!

You might also want to check out the best microbreweries in Milwaukee.