Sussex's Best Restaurants [Updated 2025]

Each bite tells a story, and I’ve savored enough of them to fill a book! After diving into the culinary treasures of Sussex, I’ve handpicked 12 standout spots that showcase the vibrant flavors and unique experiences this area has to offer.

With years of exploring hidden gems and local favorites under my belt, I’ve developed a keen palate and a deep appreciation for the artistry behind each dish. Whether you’re a lifelong resident or just visiting, trust me to steer you toward those unforgettable meals that make dining out here a true delight. Let’s dig in and discover the culinary heart of Sussex together!

The GOAT Bar & Grill

Highlights
Fabulous bartenders
Delicious food options
Live music entertainment
Outstanding service
Great for game watching

The GOAT Bar & Grill in Sussex is nothing short of a delightful revelation! From the moment I stepped inside, I was welcomed by the vibrant atmosphere and the fabulous bartenders ready to serve up creative cocktails. Their expertise behind the bar is impressive, crafting drinks that tantalize the palate while you soak in the upbeat vibe.

As for the food, the delicious options on the menu are both comforting and adventurous, expertly prepared to satisfy even the pickiest eater. I particularly loved the succulent grilled meats, which truly steal the show. Pair that with some of their delectable sides, and you've got a meal that’s bound to leave a lasting impression.

Adding to the charm, the live music entertainment creates an inviting backdrop, turning an ordinary dinner into an unforgettable evening. Whether you're there to catch the game or simply enjoy a relaxing dinner, the ambiance is just right.

Throughout my visit, the outstanding service ensured that my glass was never empty, and my dining experience was top-notch. If you find yourself in Sussex, don’t miss the chance to indulge at The GOAT—it's a place that truly delivers on every front!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Artisan 179

Highlights
Exceptional event space
Outstanding personalized service
Delicious and creative menu
Casual or dressy ambiance
Rave reviews for charcuterie board

Artisan 179 is a delightful culinary discovery tucked away in Sussex that merges casual comfort with a touch of sophistication. From the moment I stepped inside, I could sense the warm, inviting ambiance, perfect for any occasion—whether you're dressed to the nines or just stopping by in your favorite jeans.

What truly stands out at Artisan 179 is their creative menu brimming with fresh, seasonal ingredients. Each dish is a testament to culinary artistry, and I found myself utterly enchanted, particularly with their charcuterie board that has received rave reviews. It’s a feast for the eyes as much as for the palate, showcasing an impressive array of locally sourced meats and artisanal cheeses.

The personalized service I experienced was exceptional, with staff who genuinely seemed passionate about the menu and eager to share recommendations. It felt less like a restaurant and more like a well-hosted gathering among friends.

Whether you’re planning a special event in their charming event space or simply indulging in a casual dinner, Artisan 179 happily caters to both moods. For anyone seeking a remarkable dining experience in Sussex, this gem is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Muskego.

Belfast Station Northwoods Irish Pub & Grill

Highlights
Large outdoor beer garden
Flavorful smashburger
Excellent value dining
Friendly bartender
Vibrant old school atmosphere

Stepping into Belfast Station Northwoods Irish Pub & Grill felt like a warm embrace from an old friend. The vibrant old school atmosphere is charming and instantly inviting, making it the perfect spot to unwind after a busy day. One of the standout features is their expansive outdoor beer garden, where you can sip your drink while enjoying the fresh air—an essential for those sunny Sussex days.

Now, let’s talk about the food. The smashburger is nothing short of a flavor explosion. It’s meticulously crafted and cooked to perfection, rich in taste and definitely worth every bite. I was pleasantly surprised by the excellent value dining that Belfast Station offers, making it accessible without sacrificing quality.

And let’s not forget the service! The friendly bartender added to the overall experience, sharing his recommendations with genuine enthusiasm, which only enhances the vibrant environment of the pub. In Sussex, it’s not just about dining; it’s about the experience, and Belfast Station brilliantly hits that mark. If you’re looking for a place that combines great food, a welcoming atmosphere, and value, this pub is a definite must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Hartland.

Joe Mama's Bar & Grill

Highlights
Amazing burger sauces
Friendly and attentive staff
Inviting and warm atmosphere
Unique vegetarian options
Phenomenal overall experience

Stepping into Joe Mama's Bar & Grill is like receiving a warm hug from an old friend. The inviting atmosphere immediately puts you at ease, making it the ideal spot for a casual evening out. Once seated, I was welcomed by the friendly and attentive staff who made sure I felt right at home.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the burgers! Joe Mama's boasts an array of amazing burger sauces that elevate each bite to a new level. I opted for their signature burger, paired with a unique sauce that perfectly complemented the juicy patty. Trust me, every mouthful was an explosion of flavor!

For those seeking options beyond beef, the menu offers unique vegetarian options that even the most dedicated carnivores will appreciate. My dining companion couldn’t stop raving about the robust flavors and textures.

Overall, I had a phenomenal experience at Joe Mama's. If you're in Sussex and craving a delightful meal, this vibrant grill should be at the top of your list. I can't wait to return for another round of those burgers and friendly smiles!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Milwaukee.

5 O'Clock Club

Highlights
Excellent lunch service
Delicious homemade ice cream
Classic Wisconsin supper club vibe
Generous portion sizes
Great view of Pewaukee Lake

5 O'Clock Club in Sussex is an absolute gem that radiates warmth and nostalgia, reminiscent of a classic Wisconsin supper club. The moment I stepped through the doors, I felt enveloped by a relaxed yet vibrant atmosphere that set the tone for an enjoyable meal. The lunch service was exemplary, with attentive staff eager to ensure a delightful dining experience.

I was particularly taken by the generous portion sizes—you definitely won’t leave hungry! The menu's delightful selection makes it hard to choose just one thing, but every bite was a testament to their dedication to quality. Speaking of quality, a trip here would be incomplete without indulging in their homemade ice cream. It was rich, creamy, and bursting with flavors that danced on my palate.

As I savored my meal, the stunning view of Pewaukee Lake added an extra layer of charm to my experience. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch or a special dinner, 5 O'Clock Club effortlessly combines great food with a wonderful ambiance. I left feeling content, already planning my next visit to this delightful establishment. 🎉

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Milwaukee Open Now.

North Star American Bistro

Highlights
Great fish fry Fridays
Pleasant and warm atmosphere
Excellent and friendly service
Delicious, beautifully presented food
Varied dining areas

Nestled in the heart of Sussex is the delightful North Star American Bistro, where culinary dreams come true—especially on Fish Fry Fridays! Upon stepping inside, I was greeted by a pleasant and warm atmosphere that felt like a cozy embrace. The decor perfectly complements the vibrant energy of the staff, who are nothing short of friendly and attentive, making you feel right at home from the moment you sit down.

Now, let me rave about the food! Each dish is not just a meal but a beautiful presentation on a plate. The flavors burst forth, crafted with care and creativity that had me savoring every bite. I indulged in a feast that ranged from succulent burgers to tantalizing seafood, showcasing a variety that caters to every taste bud.

One standout element is the dining space—separate areas that create an intimate feel without sacrificing the lively buzz of the bistro. I left with a heart full of joy and a satisfied belly, already planning my next visit. If you're exploring Sussex, don’t miss out on this culinary star! ⭐

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Waukesha.

"the" Kitchen

The Kitchen in Sussex is a delightful culinary gem that whisked me away with its charming atmosphere and vibrant décor. As I perused the menu, I was struck by the innovative twists on classic dishes, seamlessly crafted from locally sourced ingredients. My tastebuds danced with delight as I savored their creamy risotto, each bite bursting with flavor. The staff was not only attentive but also radiated a genuine passion for food, which enhanced the entire dining experience. If you’re seeking a restaurant that masterfully balances sophistication and warmth, The Kitchen is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Whitefish Bay.

El Jimador

Tucked away in the heart of Sussex, El Jimador is a culinary fiesta waiting to be discovered. As I stepped in, the vibrant décor instantly set the mood, transforming the space into a lively haven of Mexican culture. The sizzling fajitas danced on the plate, tantalizing my senses, while the house-made guacamole stole the show—so smooth and fresh! The staff’s warmth added an inviting touch, making me feel like part of the family. If you're craving authentic flavors with a twist, El Jimador should be at the top of your list! Don't miss the margaritas—they're pure bliss!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Riverwest Milwaukee.

Thirsty Duck Sussex

Nestled in the heart of Sussex, the Thirsty Duck offers a delightful blend of cozy ambiance and mouthwatering dishes. I was immediately drawn in by the charming decor and friendly staff. Their selection of locally sourced ingredients shines through in every bite, particularly the Duck and Ale Pie—a true testament to comfort food! Pair it with a craft beer from their impressive list, and you’re in for a treat. The dessert menu is equally compelling; I highly recommend the chocolate fondant. Overall, the Thirsty Duck is a culinary gem that beautifully captures the essence of Sussex dining!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Milwaukeeth a View.

Rumors Sports Bar & Grill

Nestled in the heart of Sussex, Rumors Sports Bar & Grill is a lively haven for sports enthusiasts and food lovers alike. Upon entering, I was immediately enveloped in the vibrant atmosphere, buzzing with excitement. The menu boasts a delightful variety of comfort food, from juicy burgers to zesty chicken wings, each dish carefully crafted to satisfy every craving. I highly recommend the signature buffalo wings—they're a game-changer! The friendly staff adds to the charm, ensuring you feel right at home. For the ultimate game day experience or a casual night out, Rumors surely hits the mark!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Milwaukee Third Ward.

Ichiban 一番 | Japanese Sushi & Steakhouse

From the moment I stepped into Ichiban 一番, I was swept away by the elegant ambiance and tantalizing aroma. The sushi, crafted with precision, was a delightful dance of flavor—each piece looked like a work of art! Their teppanyaki chef showcased delicious skills, adding a sprinkle of excitement to the dining experience. The staff were attentive and knowledgeable, enhancing the overall vibe. With its perfect blend of tradition and innovation, this gem in Sussex is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Japanese cuisine. I left with a satisfied palate, eagerly planning my next visit! ✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Milwaukee Suburbs.

Main Moon

Stepping into Main Moon feels like entering a culinary haven! The vibrant atmosphere buzzes with energy as the aroma of sizzling dishes dances in the air. I savored their Kung Pao chicken, which was a delightful balance of heat and flavor, while the vegetarian spring rolls offered a perfectly crisp accompaniment. Service was attentive yet unobtrusive, and the charming decor added to the experience. With generous portions and a menu that keeps the palate on its toes, I found myself grinning from ear to ear. For a taste of the East in Sussex, Main Moon is certainly a delicious destination worth visiting!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Milwaukeeth Outdoor Seating.