The Absolute Best Italian Restaurant in Highwood [Updated 2026]

After diving into the delightful world of Highwood’s culinary scene, I’ve had the pleasure of exploring twelve incredible Italian restaurants, each with its own unique flair. Trust me, I didn’t just stop by for a quick bite—I savored every dish, chatted with passionate chefs, and soaked in the ambiance that makes each spot special.

With my taste buds primed and a love for authentic Italian cuisine, I’m here to guide you through the gems that truly stand out. Whether you’re craving a classic marinara or an innovative twist on traditional dishes, I’ve got the scoop on where to find the best of the best in town. Let's dig in!

Disotto

Highlights
Exceptional service from Margo
Amazing family-style plates
Lovely atmosphere
Attentive and friendly staff
Unforgettable tiramisu

Disotto: A Taste of Italy in Highwood

Stepping into Disotto feels like a warm embrace from a beloved Italian aunt. The atmosphere is charming, inviting diners to linger a little longer over each course. I was fortunate to be served by the delightful Margo, who not only provided exemplary service but also made recommendations that truly enhanced our meal.

Now, let’s talk about the food! The family-style plates were nothing short of spectacular, overflowing with rich flavors that made every bite a delight. Each dish felt like a loving homage to traditional Italian cooking, designed for sharing and savoring. But the true showstopper was the tiramisu—absolutely unforgettable! It was an ethereal combination of coffee, cocoa, and mascarpone that danced on my palate and left me yearning for more.

The staff’s attentiveness paired with the restaurant’s cozy charm created a memorable dining experience that I can’t wait to relive. If you're looking for a slice of Italy right here in Highwood, Disotto should be at the very top of your list. With its welcoming vibe and tantalizing cuisine, it’s a culinary journey you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Glenview.

Del Rio Restaurant

Highlights
Exceptional Chicken Piccata
Live Jazz Enhances Experience
Friendly Family-Owned Vibe
Responsive and Personable Staff
Intimate Dining Atmosphere

Del Rio Restaurant in Highwood is truly a gem that captures the essence of Italian dining with panache and charm. Upon stepping into the intimate atmosphere, I was immediately enveloped in the delightful aroma of garlic and herbs—a sure sign of culinary magic in the making.

One of the standout dishes was the Chicken Piccata. It was prepared to perfection, featuring a beautifully sautéed chicken breast drizzled with a lemony caper sauce that danced on my palate. Each bite was a burst of flavor that left me wanting more!

What truly sets Del Rio apart is its warm, family-owned vibe. The staff was not only responsive but also exuded a genuine friendliness that made me feel right at home. I even enjoyed live jazz music, which subtly enhanced my dining experience without overpowering the ambiance.

With its intimate dining atmosphere and scrumptious offerings, Del Rio is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary experience worth savoring. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, the charm and flavors at Del Rio make it a must-visit spot in Highwood!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Downtown Milwaukee.

Pastificio Inc

Highlights
Best pesto in Highwood
Homemade pasta excellence
Friendly, helpful service
Delicious caponata options
Memorable eggplant parm

Pastificio Inc in Highwood is a delightful treasure that truly captures the spirit of Italian cuisine. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by an ambiance that was both inviting and charming. The tantalizing aroma of fresh ingredients wafting through the air had my stomach grumbling in anticipation.

One of the stars of the menu is their homemade pasta, which was nothing short of a revelation. Each bite was al dente perfection, embodying the essence of traditional Italian craftsmanship. And let's talk about the pesto – it’s hands down the best in Highwood! Bursting with flavor, it transported me straight to the sunny hills of Liguria with every forkful.

Equally impressive was the eggplant parm, which was memorable for its rich, creamy layers and a delightful crunch. The caponata options also deserve a shoutout; they were both hearty and refreshing, providing a lovely balance to my meal.

The service at Pastificio Inc was friendly and attentive, making my dining experience even more enjoyable. If you’re looking for an authentic Italian dining experience filled with deliciousness, look no further than Pastificio Inc!

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurants in Milwaukee.

Alex's Washington Gardens

Highlights
Outstanding server experience
Garlic lover's delight
Excellent minestrone soup
Crispy Italian beef pizza
Clean and cozy ambiance

Alex's Washington Gardens is a delightful gem nestled in Highwood that truly captures the heart of Italian cuisine. From the moment I walked in, the clean and cozy ambiance enveloped me, making me feel right at home. The servers here are nothing short of phenomenal; they genuinely care about your dining experience, which sets this spot apart from the rest.

As a self-proclaimed garlic lover, I was thrilled to see that the menu offered plenty of tempting options. I began with the excellent minestrone soup, bursting with flavor and perfect for a cozy autumn evening. Next, I couldn't resist trying the crispy Italian beef pizza—an irresistible combination that danced on my palate with each bite.

What struck me most was how well the staff managed the bustling dining space while ensuring every guest felt valued and attended to. It’s this level of service that keeps patrons returning. If you’re in search of a wonderful Italian experience in Highwood, look no further than Alex's Washington Gardens. It’s a place where good food and great service unite for an unforgettable meal!

You might also want to check out the best halal restaurants in Third Ward Milwaukee.

DeNucci's Highland Park

Highlights
Amazing food and service
Great gluten-free options
Friendly and helpful staff
Clean and inviting atmosphere
Busy yet accommodating ambiance

Visiting DeNucci's Highland Park was a delightful culinary adventure! As soon as I stepped into this charming establishment, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere that instantly set the tone for my meal. The friendly and helpful staff made me feel right at home, ready to guide me through their mouthwatering menu.

Now, let's dive into what truly matters—the food! Each dish I sampled was a testament to authentic Italian cuisine. I was particularly thrilled to discover their great gluten-free options, allowing diners with dietary restrictions to indulge without compromise. My plate of handcrafted pasta was rich in flavor and expertly prepared, making each bite a celebration of Italian tradition.

Despite the bustling environment, the restaurant managed to maintain a cozy vibe, creating a perfect setting for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings. I appreciated how accommodating they were, ensuring my experience was memorable.

In conclusion, DeNucci's Highland Park isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a culinary gem in Highwood. If you're searching for the best Italian dining experience, look no further—this place is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Milwaukee.

Maria's Cafe

Highlights
Delicious homemade pasta
Top-notch service
Great ambiance
Vegetarian-friendly options
Irresistible cookies

Maria's Cafe is an enchanting gem tucked away in Highwood, capturing the essence of Italian culinary delight. From the moment I stepped inside, the welcoming ambiance wrapped around me like a warm hug. The decor is a delightful combination of rustic charm and contemporary flair, making it the perfect spot for everything from casual lunches to romantic dinners.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the homemade pasta! The moment I took a bite, I was transported to the sun-soaked hills of Tuscany. Each twirl of spaghetti was cooked to perfection and marinated in a rich sauce that danced on my taste buds. I also appreciated their vegetarian-friendly options, which were tempting and thoughtfully crafted.

What truly stood out was the impeccable service — attentive without being intrusive. After my meal, I couldn't resist trying their irresistible cookies, a delightful sweet ending to my culinary journey.

In a town filled with Italian eateries, Maria's Cafe shines brightly. If you're looking for a place where passion meets pasta, this is your destination. I left not just satisfied but excited to return for another taste of their unmatchable food. 🍝

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in Milwaukee.

Miramar Bistro

Highlights
Top-notch service
Classy old-school vibe
Welcoming atmosphere
Attention to detail
Great dining experience

When I stepped into Miramar Bistro, I was instantly struck by its classy, old-school vibe that enveloped me like a warm embrace. The charming decor set the stage for an extraordinary dining experience, filled with rich Italian flavors and attentive service. Each detail seemed meticulously curated, elevating my mealtime into an event rather than just another dinner.

The moment I settled in, the staff greeted me with genuine warmth, creating an inviting atmosphere that made me feel right at home. Their approach to service was exemplary—considerate yet unobtrusive, striking the perfect balance. As I glanced through the menu, every dish told a story, teasing with tantalizing options that reflected the soul of Italian cooking.

The attention to detail in the presentation of the food was impressive. Each plate looked like a work of art, boasting fresh ingredients and vibrant colors. The flavors, however, were the true showstoppers—bold yet harmonious, a symphony on my palate.

In a city full of options, Miramar Bistro stands out without doubt. If you’re seeking authentic Italian cuisine paired with impeccable service, look no further. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best thai restaurants in Milwaukee.

Francesca's Intimo

Highlights
Well-fried calamari
Intimate seating arrangements
Tasty pollo Milanese
Affordable prices
Friendly staff

Francesca's Intimo is a delightful gem nestled in Highwood, and it truly encapsulates the spirit of traditional Italian dining with a modern twist. Upon entering, the intimate seating arrangements set the perfect tone for a cozy meal, making it ideal for date nights or gatherings with close friends.

Starting with the fried calamari, I must say it was impeccably prepared—crisp and perfectly seasoned, making for a delightful appetizer. As a main dish, I opted for the pollo Milanese, which was not only generously portioned but also bursting with flavor. Every bite reminded me of the sunny streets of Italy!

What truly stands out at Francesca's is the staff's warm and inviting nature. Their friendliness adds to the overall dining experience, making you feel right at home. Moreover, the pricing here is surprisingly affordable, proving that you don’t have to break the bank for quality Italian cuisine.

In a town filled with dining options, Francesca's Intimo shines brightly as a top contender for the best Italian restaurant in Highwood, making it a must-visit for anyone craving authentic flavors in a welcoming atmosphere.

You might also want to check out the best vegan restaurants in Milwaukee.

Nico Restaurant

Highlights
Transportational Italian experience
Perfectly blistered pizza crust
Attentive and friendly service
Tender and beautifully seasoned octopus
Thoughtfully tailored menu

Nico Restaurant in Highwood is a gem that offers a truly transportational Italian experience. Upon entering, I was warmly greeted by the staff, who provided attentive and friendly service throughout my meal. This warm atmosphere is a big part of what makes dining here feel so special.

Now, let’s talk about the food—where Nico really shines. I indulged in their pizza, which featured a perfectly blistered crust that was both crispy and chewy in all the right places. Each bite was a delightful testament to their dedication to authentic Italian cuisine. But the standout dish for me was the tender and beautifully seasoned octopus. The seasoning was thoughtful, complementing the freshness of the seafood, and it truly blew my taste buds away.

With a thoughtfully tailored menu that balances classic favorites and innovative creations, Nico has something for everyone. It's a place that invites you to linger and savor, making it clear why it holds the title of one of the best Italian restaurants in Highwood. I can't recommend it enough for anyone looking to indulge in a slice of Italian paradise!

You might also want to check out the best patio restaurants in Milwaukee.

Bella Via Restaurant

Highlights
Affordable small group dining
Well-portioned Italian staples
Great waitstaff
Simple, pleasant interior design
Inconsistent flavor profiles

Bella Via Restaurant Review

Tucked away in charming Highwood, Bella Via Restaurant has become my go-to spot for authentic Italian fare. Upon entering, I was immediately drawn in by the simple, yet inviting ambiance. The understated decor allows the food to take center stage, which is exactly how it should be when you're dining at an Italian restaurant.

The affordable small group dining option makes this a perfect choice for friends or family gatherings, and I found the portions to be quite generous, perfect for sharing or indulging on your own. Each dish showcased the classic Italian staples we know and love, though I did encounter some inconsistency with the flavor profiles. Some dishes dazzled with their robust, home-cooked flavors, while others left me wanting a bit more pizzazz.

What truly stood out was the waitstaff, who were not only attentive but genuinely passionate about the menu. Their recommendations helped elevate my dining experience significantly. Overall, Bella Via is a delightful Italian stop in Highwood that beautifully balances affordability and quality with a touch of warmth that keeps you coming back for more.

You might also want to check out the best healthy restaurants in Milwaukee.

Longitud315

Highlights
Outstanding menu options
Top-notch service
Comfortable, cozy atmosphere
Delicious food
Exceptional cocktails

Longitud315 in Highwood is a delightful Italian gem that deserves all the accolades. Walking in, I was immediately enveloped by a cozy atmosphere that combines elegance with a homey feel. The outstanding menu options had my taste buds dancing; from traditional pasta dishes to inventive specials, there was something to entice everyone.

What truly stood out, however, was the exceptional service. The staff was not only knowledgeable but also incredibly attentive, making me feel like a valued guest rather than just another customer. They recommended their signature cocktails, and let me tell you, they were nothing short of delightful, elevating my dining experience.

As I savored each bite of my delicious meal, I couldn't help but admire the attention to detail in both the flavors and presentation. Longitud315 is not just a place to eat; it’s an experience to savor. Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner or a celebratory gathering, this restaurant delivers on all fronts. In a town brimming with Italian options, Longitud315 effortlessly claims its spot among the best. It's a place I would recommend to anyone craving true Italian cuisine infused with passion!

You might also want to check out the best german restaurant in Milwaukee.

Tapas Del Lago

Highlights
Exquisite small plates
Attentive and knowledgeable service
Perfect outdoor atmosphere
Unique and flavorful sauces
Must-try desserts

Tapas Del Lago is a gem tucked away in Highwood, where the unexpected charm of Italian tapas meets a lakeside ambiance. Upon stepping into this delightful establishment, I was greeted by its inviting outdoor atmosphere, which sets the perfect scene for a meal that promises to be more than just food—it’s an experience!

The small plates here are a true highlight, boasting an exquisite variety that kept my taste buds dancing. Each dish is crafted with precision and brimming with flavor, but it was the unique and flavorful sauces that truly stole the show. They elevate even the simplest ingredients into something remarkable. My server was not only attentive but also incredibly knowledgeable, guiding me through the menu with care and enthusiasm, which made selecting my plates all the more enjoyable.

As if the savory delights weren’t enough, I couldn’t resist indulging in their must-try desserts. Trust me—leaving without trying one would be a crime! If you’re on the lookout for the best Italian experience in Highwood, look no further than Tapas Del Lago; it’s a feast for both the palate and the soul!

You might also want to check out the best german restaurant in Downtown Milwaukee.