The Absolute Best Italian Restaurants in Downtown Milwaukee [Updated 2025]

Every bite tells a story, and trust me, I've tasted my way through the heart of Milwaukee to find the most mouthwatering Italian spots. After reviewing twelve top-notch locations, I can confidently say that this city has some culinary treasures just waiting to be uncovered.

You see, I’ve spent countless hours indulging in rich pastas, savory sauces, and the perfect crust on a pizza, all while soaking in the unique ambiance each restaurant has to offer. Whether you’re a true Italian food aficionado or just on the hunt for your next favorite dinner destination, my recommendations come straight from my heart—and my stomach! So, get ready to embark on a flavorful journey through Downtown Milwaukee’s finest Italian eateries.

Onesto

Highlights
Fantastic food and service
Well-seasoned fish dishes
Flavorful and fresh ingredients
Welcoming atmosphere
Perfectly cooked Italian classics

Onesto in Downtown Milwaukee is a delightful culinary gem that captures the soul of Italian cuisine. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a welcoming atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The staff here is attentive and genuinely passionate about their craft, ensuring that every guest feels special.

I couldn’t resist sampling the fish dishes, which were fantastic and impeccably well-seasoned. Each bite showcased the chef's dedication to flavorful and fresh ingredients, making my taste buds dance with joy. I also indulged in some classic Italian options, all perfectly cooked and bursting with authentic flavors.

The combination of expertly crafted dishes and a warm ambiance makes Onesto a top contender in the Downtown Milwaukee scene. Whether you’re seeking a romantic dinner or a festive gathering, this restaurant offers a delightful experience that keeps you coming back for more.

If you find yourself wandering the streets of Downtown Milwaukee, make sure to pop into Onesto. You’ll quickly discover why it stands out as one of the best Italian restaurants in the area—where every meal feels like a warm, cozy embrace. Buon appetito!

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurants in Milwaukee.

Calderone Club - Downtown Milwaukee

Highlights
Phenomenal veal parmigiano
Authentic Italian flavors
Attentive and funny service
Great pre-concert dinner
Reasonably priced Sangiovese

During my culinary adventure in Downtown Milwaukee, I decided to indulge in the vibrant atmosphere of Calderone Club. Immediately, the tantalizing aroma of authentic Italian cuisine wrapped around me like a warm embrace. I had heard tales of their phenomenal veal parmigiano, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. Each bite was a poetic symphony of tender meat layered with savory cheese and just the right amount of marinara.

What truly elevated my dining experience was the service. The staff was not only attentive, but also infused a delightful humor into the evening, making me feel like a part of their family. It’s the perfect spot for a pre-concert dinner, as it’s conveniently situated near the city's entertainment venues.

As I sipped on a reasonably priced Sangiovese, I couldn’t help but feel a special connection to the rich, authentic Italian flavors that echoed throughout the room. If you’re searching for a place where laughter and deliciousness intertwine, Calderone Club is a gem that deserves your attention. Whether you’re a true enthusiast of Italian cuisine or just looking for a hearty meal, this delightful establishment is sure to satisfy your cravings!

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in Milwaukee.

SALA - Modern Sicilian Dining

Highlights
Attentive and phenomenal service
Flavorful and crispy bruschetta
Delicious flourless chocolate cake
Great for special occasions
Unique hazelnut Italian soda

SALA - Modern Sicilian Dining is a delightful gem tucked away in Downtown Milwaukee that offers an exceptional culinary escapade. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with attentive and phenomenal service that made me feel truly welcome. The ambiance strikes a perfect balance between elegance and comfort, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience.

I began my meal with their flavorful and crispy bruschetta, a delightful starter that sparked my appetite for what was to come. Each bite was a harmonious blend of fresh ingredients, leaving me craving more. For the main course, the flavors of Sicilian cuisine showcased their commitment to authenticity without losing a modern twist.

The grand finale was a slice of their delicious flourless chocolate cake—rich, velvety, and utterly indulgent. It’s a must-try for any dessert lover. I also had the chance to sip on their unique hazelnut Italian soda, a refreshing companion to my meal that was both unexpected and delightful.

Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking to enjoy a great meal, SALA is an extraordinary destination that I wholeheartedly recommend. This restaurant is a beautiful fixation on Sicilian flavors that will leave you yearning for your next visit!

You might also want to check out the best thai restaurants in Milwaukee.

Dorsia

Highlights
Amazing Service
Delicious Pasta Flights
Cool Ambiance
Tasty Appetizers
Creative Decor

Dorsia in Downtown Milwaukee is a true gem that captured my heart—and my taste buds! From the moment I walked in, I was enveloped in a cool ambiance that set the stage for an unforgettable meal. The decor is a delightful blend of modern and classic Italian flair, making it the perfect backdrop for an evening out.

As I perused the menu, I was intrigued by their delicious pasta flights—a fantastic way to sample a variety of flavors. Each dish was expertly crafted, showcasing the rich and robust tastes of traditional Italian cuisine. I particularly enjoyed the variety of tasty appetizers, which perfectly whetted my appetite for the main event.

What truly sets Dorsia apart, however, is the amazing service. The staff was not only friendly but also incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, guiding me to the best choices. They made me feel like a valued guest from start to finish.

In this vibrant downtown setting, Dorsia manages to strike the perfect balance between elegance and warmth. It’s an experience I wholeheartedly recommend to anyone looking to indulge in the essence of Italian dining. Trust me—you won't want to miss it!

You might also want to check out the best vegan restaurants in Milwaukee.

Lupi & Iris

Highlights
Delicious three-course menu
Friendly and professional staff
Open kitchen dining experience
Phenomenal food quality
Intimate and fancy atmosphere

Lupi & Iris, an enchanting spot nestled in Downtown Milwaukee, has certainly carved out a unique niche in the local dining scene. From the moment I stepped through the door, I was greeted by the warm smiles of the professional staff, ready to guide me through an incredible culinary experience.

The restaurant boasts a delicious three-course menu that takes your palate on an unforgettable journey. Each dish is a testament to the phenomenal food quality that this establishment is known for. I reveled in the vibrant flavors, and it was clear that the chefs are passionate about their craft.

What truly sets Lupi & Iris apart is its open kitchen dining experience. Watching the chefs work their magic behind the glass feels like witnessing a performance, adding an extra layer of charm to the meal. The intimate and fancy atmosphere elevates the experience, making it perfect for date nights or special celebrations.

Dining at Lupi & Iris was not just a meal; it was a delightful escape into the heart of Italy, right in Milwaukee. For those seeking a taste of authentic Italian flair, this gem should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best patio restaurants in Milwaukee.

Aperitivo

Highlights
Top-notch service
Creative and delicious specials
Inviting atmosphere
Affordable happy hour
Fresh made pizzas

Aperitivo in Downtown Milwaukee is truly a gem that left me utterly charmed. From the moment I stepped inside, I was welcomed by a warm atmosphere that perfectly balances casual dining with a touch of elegance. The staff provided top-notch service; their attentive nature made me feel like I was the only guest in the room.

What really sets Aperitivo apart are their creative and delicious specials. I couldn’t resist trying their wood-fired pizzas, which are made fresh and bursting with flavor. Each bite was a delightful revelation, proving they truly understand the essence of Italian cuisine. The menu is thoughtfully crafted, ensuring there’s something to excite every palate.

If you’re looking for a great deal, their affordable happy hour is a must-try! It's the perfect opportunity to indulge without breaking the bank. I sipped on a delightful spritz while relishing some antipasti, making the whole experience even better.

In conclusion, Aperitivo isn’t just another Italian restaurant; it’s an experience that leaves you wanting more. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this spot should definitely be on your itinerary for a taste of authentic Italian flair right in the heart of Downtown Milwaukee!

You might also want to check out the best healthy restaurants in Milwaukee.

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

Highlights
Incredible Neapolitan-style pizza
Fun pizza oven seating
Friendly and attentive service
Delicious cocktails available
Light and airy dough

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana feels like a slice of Naples right in the heart of Downtown Milwaukee. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a warm atmosphere and sometimes whimsical décor, but the real star is undoubtedly the pizza. The Neapolitan-style pizza here is a true marvel—each bite is a delightful combination of light, airy dough and characteristically rich toppings that transport you right to the sun-soaked streets of Italy.

One of my favorite aspects of San Giorgio is the fun seating around the pizza oven; it adds an interactive element to your meal. Watching the pizzaiolo work his magic adds a touch of spectacle to the dining experience. Equally commendable is the friendly and attentive service—they genuinely want you to enjoy your meal, offering excellent recommendations tailored to your taste.

I couldn't resist pairing my meal with one of their refreshing cocktails, which perfectly complemented my pizza. The balance of flavors and the vibrant atmosphere left me wanting more. If you're in search of authentic Italian fare, San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana is a must-visit. It's a delightful spot that beautifully encapsulates the spirit of Italian dining!

You might also want to check out the best takeout restaurants in Milwaukee.

Stella Van Buren

Highlights
Excellent dining experience
Attentive and friendly service
Seasonal menu with great selection
Delicious lasagna and lamb
Popular chocolate cake dessert

Review of Stella Van Buren

Stepping into Stella Van Buren felt like being welcomed into an enchanting Italian villa. The ambiance was warm and inviting, making it the perfect backdrop for a delightful evening. From the moment I sat down, the service was nothing short of exceptional; the staff’s attentiveness and genuine friendliness immediately put me at ease.

I was particularly taken with their seasonal menu, offering a great selection of dishes that showcase the freshness of the ingredients. I couldn't resist trying their lasagna, which was rich and comforting, layering flavors that danced on my palate. The lamb dish also found its way onto my table, and let me tell you, it was a triumph of tender, savory goodness.

To cap off this fabulous dining experience, I indulged in their popular chocolate cake for dessert. One bite and I was in heaven; its decadent richness was the perfect finish to an already wonderful meal.

Stella Van Buren is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience. If you are searching for a taste of Italy in Downtown Milwaukee, this gem is a must-visit! 🍷🍴

You might also want to check out the best fancy restaurants in Milwaukee.

Santino's Little Italy

Highlights
Homemade pasta and sauces
Phenomenal pizzas
Great wine selection
Relaxing dining atmosphere
Reservations recommended

During my recent culinary adventure, I found myself at Santino's Little Italy, a true gem nestled in Downtown Milwaukee. From the moment I stepped inside, I was enveloped in a warm Italian ambiance that felt both cozy and inviting. The homemade pasta and sauces were, without a doubt, the stars of the show. Each bite was a delightful reminder that simplicity can yield extraordinary flavors.

I couldn't resist trying their pizzas, and let me tell you, they were nothing short of phenomenal. The crust was perfectly crispy, while the toppings were fresh and generously applied. Pairing my meal with a selection from their great wine list only elevated the experience further—it's a true wine lover's paradise.

Despite the thrilling flavors, what set Santino's apart was its relaxing dining atmosphere. It was the ideal place to unwind after a long day. I highly recommend making reservations, as this spot can get quite busy with fellow Italian cuisine enthusiasts. In short, Santino's Little Italy isn’t just another restaurant; it's a heartfelt homage to Italian tradition, making it one of the best dining options in Downtown Milwaukee. Buon Appetito!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Milwaukee.

Brisa Do Mar

Highlights
Incredible server experience
Accommodates large parties
Generous portion sizes
Great for celebrations
Immaculate outdoor vibes

Brisa Do Mar is a true gem in the heart of Downtown Milwaukee, blending Italian warmth with a refreshing coastal vibe. From the moment I stepped through the door, I was greeted by a team of enthusiastic servers who genuinely care about your experience. Their energy is contagious—perfect for setting the mood for a delightful evening.

One of the standout features is the ample space for large parties, making it an ideal spot for those special celebrations. Whether it’s a birthday bash or a reunion with friends, Brisa Do Mar can accommodate you with flair. And don't even get me started on portion sizes! Each dish is served generously, ensuring you never leave feeling hungry.

The outdoor seating area is simply immaculate, providing a charming backdrop for your meal, and it's perfect for those warm Milwaukee evenings. I found myself enraptured not only by the ambiance but also by the exquisite flavors wafting from the kitchen—eating here is more than just a meal; it’s an experience. Brisa Do Mar has firmly secured its place as one of my top picks for Italian cuisine in the area, and I can’t wait to return for more culinary adventures.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Allis.

Sorella

Highlights
Cozy and inviting atmosphere
Outstanding burrata dish
Attentive and friendly service
Great cocktails and desserts
Unique and flavorful menu items

Review of Sorella

Nestled in the heart of Downtown Milwaukee, Sorella is a delightful find that captures the essence of Italian dining. From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted by a cozy and inviting atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The soft lighting and charming decor set the perfect backdrop for an intimate meal or a lively evening with friends.

One of the standout dishes on the menu is their outstanding burrata, which is a creamy, dreamy delight that simply melts in your mouth. Paired with fresh arugula and a drizzle of olive oil, it’s a dish I could enjoy every day! The service at Sorella was just as impressive; I felt genuinely welcomed by the attentive and friendly staff. They were eager to share drink recommendations, and I couldn’t resist indulging in one of their expertly crafted cocktails.

To round out my meal, I savored a decadent dessert that was both luscious and light—an experience that truly elevated my dining adventure. Overall, Sorella captures everything I adore about Italian cuisine, making it a must-visit stop in Downtown Milwaukee. I left with a smile and a longing to return, eager for what delights await on my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Milwaukee.

Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Authentic Southern Italian Cuisine
In-house Dressings and Sauces
Tender Chicken Marsala
Quaint and Charming Ambiance
Exceptional Service and Care

Carini's Southern Italian Restaurant is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Downtown Milwaukee. As I stepped inside, I was immediately embraced by a quaint and charming ambiance, setting the perfect stage for an unforgettable dining experience. The warm hues and cozy decor whisper stories of cherished family recipes and traditions.

Now, let’s talk about the heart of any Italian restaurant: the food. Carini’s serves up authentic Southern Italian cuisine that transports you straight to the sun-soaked coasts of Italy. I opted for the tender Chicken Marsala, and let me tell you, the dish was nothing short of heavenly! The chicken was cooked to perfection, bathed in a rich, savory sauce that danced on my palate.

What truly sets Carini’s apart is their commitment to quality—everything from the in-house dressings and sauces adds a personal touch that makes each bite feel special. The staff at Carini’s embodies exceptional service, with a genuine care for guests that made me feel like part of the family.

For anyone seeking a slice of Italy in Milwaukee, Carini's is undoubtedly one of the best choices. You’ll leave with a full belly and a heart full of warmth!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Waukesha.