Milwaukee's Best Private Elementary Schools [Updated 2025]

Having explored 12 incredible private elementary schools in Milwaukee, I can't wait to share the gems I’ve discovered. Each school has its own unique charm, offering everything from innovative teaching methods to a nurturing community that supports our little learners.

As a parent and education enthusiast, I know how crucial it is to find the right fit for our kids. I’ve done the homework—literally! With my firsthand experiences and insights, you can trust that this guide is packed with valuable information to help you make the best choice for your family. Let's dive into the vibrant world of Milwaukee’s private schools together!

Milwaukee Montessori School

Visiting Milwaukee Montessori School was an absolute delight! Nestled in a vibrant community, this school embraces the principles of Montessori education, fostering independence and creativity in its students. The warm, welcoming atmosphere made me feel like I had stepped into a joyful learning haven. What truly stood out was the dedicated staff—passionate educators who embrace each child's unique learning journey. The hands-on approach, combined with a rich variety of programs, cultivates a sense of exploration and wonder. If you're seeking a nurturing environment where children thrive, Milwaukee Montessori is a standout choice!

You might also want to check out the best hair salons in Milwaukee.

Saint Sebastian School

Highlights
Loving community spirit
Caring principal and teachers
Great food and service
Welcoming for families
Kids enjoy the experience

Saint Sebastian School stands out as a gem within Milwaukee's rich educational landscape. From the moment I stepped through those vibrant doors, I felt the loving community spirit envelop me like a warm hug. The principal and teaching staff exude a genuine care for each student which is palpable. Their dedication creates an environment where every child thrives academically and socially.

One of the highlights of my visit was the great food and service. It’s comforting to know that the children are not just fed with nutrition but are also encouraged to explore a variety of flavors. The cafeteria is a bustling hub of laughter and camaraderie, making lunchtime a delightful experience for the little ones.

The school's welcoming environment for families was also impressive. Parents are regularly invited into the fold, fostering a strong home-school connection that contributes significantly to a child's success. Kids seem to genuinely enjoy their time at Saint Sebastian, which shines through in their cheerful chatter and enthusiastic participation.

In essence, this school embraces every child with open arms, making Saint Sebastian School a brilliant choice for those seeking a nurturing educational setting in Milwaukee!

You might also want to check out the best salons in Milwaukee.

Christ King School

During my recent visit to Christ King School, I was immediately struck by the vibrant atmosphere and warm community spirit. The teachers exude enthusiasm, creating an engaging environment where curiosity thrives. With a well-rounded curriculum that balances academics, arts, and physical education, students are encouraged to explore their unique talents. Not to mention, the school’s emphasis on character development fosters a sense of responsibility and respect among its little learners. The beautiful campus and strong parental involvement further enrich the experience, making it a top contender. Overall, Christ King School is a delightful place for nurturing young minds!

You might also want to check out the best massage in Milwaukee.

Holy Redeemer Christian Academy

Holy Redeemer Christian Academy is a delightful gem in Milwaukee! From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with warmth and vibrancy. The dedicated staff genuinely nurture each child's spirit, fostering curiosity and a love for learning. The integration of Christian values with academic rigor creates an enriching environment. I loved how the small class sizes promote personalized attention, allowing students to flourish. With an engaging curriculum and a strong sense of community, Holy Redeemer truly stands out as an excellent choice. If you’re seeking a supportive and inspiring place for your child, this school is definitely worth considering!

You might also want to check out the best spas in Milwaukee.

Atonement Lutheran School

Nestled in a friendly neighborhood, Atonement Lutheran School truly captures the heart of education. The dedicated staff fosters a nurturing environment, making learning both engaging and enjoyable. I was particularly impressed by the emphasis on character development alongside academic excellence; students are encouraged to be both scholars and good citizens. Small class sizes ensure personalized attention, allowing each child to thrive. What truly stands out is the sense of community—parents and teachers work hand-in-hand, creating a supportive atmosphere. Overall, Atonement is a delightful option for families seeking a well-rounded education for their little ones!

You might also want to check out the best hair salons in Brookfield.

Tamarack Waldorf School

Stepping into Tamarack Waldorf School felt like entering a vibrant tapestry of creativity and learning. The children animatedly engage with nature and their surroundings, demonstrating a holistic approach to education that truly captivated me. The curriculum emphasizes not just academics but also artistic expression and hands-on activities. Each classroom buzzed with excitement, showcasing walls adorned with student artwork. I was particularly charmed by the nurturing environment, where teachers foster a sense of community and respect. If you seek a school that encourages imagination and critical thinking, Tamarack is a delightful gem in Milwaukee’s educational landscape!

You might also want to check out the best nail salons in Brookfield.

Blessed Savior West Campus

I recently had the delightful opportunity to explore Blessed Savior West Campus in Milwaukee, and I was thoroughly impressed! This vibrant school exudes a warm and welcoming atmosphere, where nurturing educators foster both academic growth and personal development. The curriculum is thoughtfully designed, blending traditional values with modern techniques to inspire young minds. What truly stood out was their emphasis on community, encouraging students to engage in service projects that cultivate empathy and teamwork. With engaging activities and a commitment to character development, Blessed Savior West Campus is truly a gem among Milwaukee's private elementary schools—an exceptional choice for families!

You might also want to check out the best barbershops in Milwaukee.

Early View Academy of Excellence

At Early View Academy of Excellence, I was instantly charmed by the vibrant atmosphere and dedicated staff. The school fosters a nurturing environment where creativity and inquiry flourish. With a focus on holistic development, students enjoy engaging curricula that stimulate both the mind and spirit. The small class sizes encourage personalized attention, ensuring each child's unique talents shine through. Plus, the emphasis on community involvement enriches the student experience, making learning relevant and impactful. If you’re exploring top-notch educational options in Milwaukee, Early View Academy certainly deserves a spot on your list! 🌟

You might also want to check out the best microblading in Milwaukee.

Academy of Excellence - South Campus

The Academy of Excellence - South Campus truly impressed me with its vibrant atmosphere and dedicated staff. The moment I stepped in, I could feel the energy of engaged learners and enthusiastic teachers co-creating a magical educational experience. The curriculum is thoughtfully designed, blending academic rigor with creative exploration, ensuring that every child thrives. I particularly admired their emphasis on character development, fostering not just scholars but well-rounded individuals. The cozy classrooms buzz with creativity and collaboration, making it a delightful place for young minds to flourish. Overall, this school is a gem in Milwaukee’s educational landscape—definitely worth considering!

You might also want to check out the best charter schools in Milwaukee.

Blessed Savior East Campus

From the moment I stepped into Blessed Savior East Campus, I felt the warmth of the community. The teachers are truly passionate, creating a nurturing environment that inspires each student to thrive. The curriculum is both challenging and engaging, fostering a love of learning through innovative methods. I was particularly impressed by their emphasis on character development alongside academics, helping children grow into compassionate individuals. With small class sizes and a strong sense of community, it’s a delightful place for young minds to flourish. If you’re seeking a school that balances education and values, Blessed Savior is worth considering!

You might also want to check out the best preschools in Milwaukee.

St. Margaret Mary School

St. Margaret Mary School truly stands out in Milwaukee's vibrant educational landscape! Nestled in a welcoming community, this institution blends academic excellence with a strong moral foundation. The dedicated staff fosters a nurturing environment, where each student feels valued and encouraged to explore their interests. I was particularly impressed by their emphasis on creative arts alongside traditional subjects—who knew math could be so much fun? From engaging extracurriculars to a close-knit atmosphere, it’s clear that St. Margaret Mary not only educates but also inspires young minds to shine. A delightful choice for any family seeking a holistic education!

You might also want to check out the best nail salon in Oak Creek.

Mount Calvary Lutheran School

Mount Calvary Lutheran School is a delightful gem in Milwaukee's educational landscape! With its nurturing environment and strong community values, this school fosters both academic and personal growth. The dedicated faculty create engaging learning experiences that ignite curiosity and creativity in students. I was particularly impressed by their focus on character development alongside rigorous academics. The playful spirit of the students shone through during my visit, showcasing a strong sense of belonging. If you're seeking a school that blends faith and education beautifully, look no further than Mount Calvary—where every child truly feels valued and supported!

You might also want to check out the best middle schools in Milwaukee.