New Berlin's Best Bars [Updated 2025]

I’ve sifted through the neon lights, the cozy corners, and the bustling patios to bring you the ultimate lineup of 12 top bars that make New Berlin a nightlife treasure. Whether you’re a craft beer enthusiast, a cocktail connoisseur, or just looking for a chill spot to unwind, I’ve got you covered.

With years of diving deep into local scenes and sampling everything from signature cocktails to the perfect pub pretzel, my taste buds have become pretty discerning. Trust me, I’ve experienced the highs and the lows, and I’m here to share the gems that truly deserve your attention. Let’s raise a glass to the vibrant bar culture of New Berlin!

Mary's Caddyshack And Grill

Highlights
Laid-back and local vibe
Friendly bartenders
Live music on Sundays
Amazing burgers and tots
Great value for drinks

Mary's Caddyshack And Grill is a delightful haven for those seeking a relaxed atmosphere paired with outstanding fare. The moment I stepped in, the laid-back charm of this local gem wrapped around me like a warm blanket. The friendly bartenders work their magic, ensuring everyone feels right at home, and their welcoming smiles set the tone for a memorable visit.

The live music on Sundays adds a vibrant touch, turning the space into a lively gathering point for locals and visitors alike. It's the perfect way to unwind and enjoy some top-notch talent while savoring a cold drink. Speaking of drinks, the value here is unbeatable—especially for those looking to stretch their dollar while enjoying a night out.

I couldn't resist trying their amazing burgers and tots, which were nothing short of divine. Each bite was a testament to their commitment to quality. Whether you’re a burger aficionado or simply in search of a satisfying meal, you won't be disappointed.

In summary, if you find yourself in New Berlin and are on the hunt for a spot that perfectly balances fun and flavor, look no further than Mary's Caddyshack And Grill! This establishment embodies the spirit of community, and I can't wait to return.

You might also want to check out the best bar and grill in Milwaukee.

Cleveland Pub & Grill

Highlights
Friendly and prompt service
Great for group events
Low key sports bar vibes
No wait for seating
Delicious burgers and Reubens

Cleveland Pub & Grill is a hidden gem that effortlessly embodies the perfect blend of comfort and conviviality. Upon entering, I was greeted by friendly and prompt service that immediately made me feel at home. The atmosphere is akin to a classic sports bar, ideal for unwinding and enjoying a game with friends. I particularly appreciated the low wait times for seating—a rarity in popular spots—and found myself quickly immersed in the inviting surroundings.

What sets Cleveland Pub apart is its lively yet laid-back vibe, perfect for group gatherings. I couldn’t resist diving into their menu, and let me tell you, the burgers are nothing short of phenomenal. A close second was their Reuben sandwich, which delivered a delightful punch of flavor. The whole place radiates a sense of community, making it ideal to catch a game or celebrate with friends.

With its delectable food, welcoming atmosphere, and great service, Cleveland Pub & Grill has etched itself as a must-visit in New Berlin. If you're searching for a spot to enjoy some good food and even better company, this place will not disappoint!

You might also want to check out the best bank for small business in Milwaukee.

Clubhouse Bar & Grill

Highlights
Excellent food options
Friendly and attentive staff
Indoor/outdoor golf facilities
Homemade chips and chili dip
New kitchen with stellar offerings

Clubhouse Bar & Grill is a delightful gem that effortlessly combines a lively atmosphere with an exceptional culinary experience. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by the friendly and attentive staff, setting the tone for a relaxed evening. This bar isn’t just about drinks; the excellent food options steal the show. I couldn't resist trying their homemade chips and chili dip, which were a perfect kickoff to my meal — a delightful combination of crunch and zest.

But what truly elevates this place is its unique indoor/outdoor golf facilities, making it an ideal spot for both sports enthusiasts and social butterflies. Picture this: enjoying a cold drink while your friends challenge each other to a friendly game. It’s a lively atmosphere that keeps the energy high.

Having just revamped their kitchen, Clubhouse’s menu features stellar offerings that cater to various tastes, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Whether you're out for a casual night with friends or a fun date night, this bar promises a memorable experience. If you’re in New Berlin, do yourself a favor and swing by Clubhouse Bar & Grill — it’s more than just a bar; it’s a destination!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Milwaukee.

Nickel's

Highlights
Hometown friendly atmosphere
Friendly and attentive bartenders
Daily shake specials

Nickel's in New Berlin is a quintessential spot that doubles as your local hideaway and a bustling social hub. From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted by the hometown friendly atmosphere that wraps you like a warm blanket. The bartenders are not just skilled mixologists; they are truly attentive and make you feel like a valued guest, not just another customer.

What really sets Nickel's apart is its daily shake specials, which are a delightful surprise and add an element of fun to the usual bar menu. I found myself indulging in one of their unique creations, and let me tell you—each sip was a flavor explosion!

As I sipped my drink, I felt a sense of community envelop me. It’s the kind of place where conversations flow as freely as the drinks, and laughter becomes a shared experience. Love a good game? You can often catch lively activities that engage the crowd. Whether you’re looking to unwind after a long day or celebrate with friends, Nickel's is a splendid choice. If you find yourself in New Berlin, don’t miss the chance to experience what Nickel's has to offer!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Milwaukee.

Uncle Jimmy's Pub And Grill

Highlights
Friendly and cool staff
Amazing homemade meatball
Best cheese curds in town
Fair prices for great food
Tribute to first responders

Uncle Jimmy's Pub And Grill is a quintessential stop for anyone looking to unwind in New Berlin. The first thing that struck me was the friendly and cool staff—they make every patron feel like a local regular, regardless of whether it's your first visit or your fiftieth.

As I settled in, I couldn’t resist trying their homemade meatball, which turned out to be a mouthwatering delight. It's the stuff that brings you back just to enjoy the savory flavors all over again. But that wasn’t all; I later sampled what are often touted as the best cheese curds in town. Crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside, they certainly lived up to their reputation and paired spectacularly with my favorite brew.

What I especially appreciate about Uncle Jimmy's is the fair prices for great food—the kind of atmosphere where you can indulge without financial guilt. Plus, the decor pays homage to first responders, showing just how much the community values those who protect us.

If you find yourself in New Berlin, do yourself a favor and swing by Uncle Jimmy's; it's simply a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best cocktail bars in Milwaukee.

Natty Oaks Pub & Eatery

Highlights
Fun, casual atmosphere
Great selection of beer
Delicious smash burgers
Friendly and attentive service
Nice outdoor seating

Natty Oaks Pub & Eatery is a true gem nestled in New Berlin, bursting with a vibrant and casual atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home. As I stepped inside, I was welcomed by the cheerful vibe and the sounds of laughter, making it the ideal spot for a laid-back evening or a lively gathering with friends.

The beer selection at Natty Oaks is impressive—whether you’re a craft beer aficionado or just looking to unwind with a cold one, there’s something for everyone. I was particularly enamored with their smash burgers, which are nothing short of a delightful culinary experience. The flavors meld perfectly, making each bite a celebration.

Now, let’s talk about service. The staff here are not just friendly; they’re attentive and genuinely seem to enjoy what they do, which enhances the overall experience. If you’re in the mood for some fresh air, I'd highly recommend snagging a spot in their nice outdoor seating area, where you can soak up the sun while savoring your meal.

In short, Natty Oaks captures the quintessential bar experience, making it a top contender on my list of best bars in New Berlin!

You might also want to check out the best dive bars in Milwaukee.

The Neighbors Bar & Grille

Highlights
Friendly service
Great portion sizes
Tasty battered cod
Attentive staff
Excellent food quality

The Neighbors Bar & Grille is one of those hidden gems that captures the essence of community spirit. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with a warm smile from the attentive staff, making me feel right at home. The atmosphere is lively yet relaxed, perfect for unwinding after a long day.

As I settled in, I couldn’t help but notice the friendly service that permeated the space. The servers seemed genuinely invested in providing a delightful experience, which is a rare find. I decided to indulge in their highly recommended battered cod, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The fish was perfectly cooked, with a crispy exterior that gave way to juicy, flaky goodness inside.

Portion sizes here are incredibly generous—definitely a place to visit when you’re feeling hungry. The combination of excellent food quality and that welcoming vibe makes The Neighbors a top choice for anyone seeking an enjoyable outing in New Berlin. Whether you’re catching up with friends or savoring a meal solo, this bar promises a satisfying experience that I’d recommend to anyone looking for a great time. Cheers to that!

You might also want to check out the best bloody marys in Milwaukee.

Eagle Park Brewing & Distilling Company

Highlights
Phenomenal craft beer selection
Top-notch friendly staff
Delicious prime rib sandwich
Killer food and drink pairings
Well-organized events

Eagle Park Brewing & Distilling Company in New Berlin is truly a hidden gem that any craft beverage enthusiast must experience! From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by top-notch friendly staff who radiated warmth and passion for their creation. The atmosphere buzzed with excitement, drawing me in immediately.

The real star of the show, of course, was the phenomenal craft beer selection. Every sip was a delightful journey through unique flavors that showcased the artistry of brewing. I couldn’t resist pairing my drink with their delicious prime rib sandwich; let me tell you, the combination was simply divine! The careful attention to killer food and drink pairings makes this spot stand out among its competitors.

As if that weren’t enough, I appreciated the well-organized events they often host, encouraging community engagement while showcasing local talent. In a lively environment filled with good vibes, Eagle Park has firmly secured its place as one of my personal favorites in New Berlin. Whether you're looking for a casual hangout or a lively night out with friends, this bar has something for everyone. Don’t miss out on this delightful destination!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Downtown Milwaukee.

19th Hole Country Club

Nestled perfectly between lush greens, the 19th Hole Country Club offers a delightful blend of relaxation and excitement. Upon entering, I was greeted by friendly staff who instantly made me feel at home. The atmosphere is lively yet comfortable, making it an ideal spot for both golf enthusiasts and casual visitors. Their drink menu boasts a tasty selection of craft beers and signature cocktails—perfect for unwinding after a round. I particularly enjoyed their seasonal specials, which are as refreshing as a cool breeze on the green. If you’re looking for a fantastic evening, this bar is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best wine bars in Milwaukee.

Varsity Club

Stepping into Varsity Club felt like a homecoming: friendly faces and an atmosphere buzzing with excitement. The sporty decor sets the perfect backdrop for game nights, while the menu boasts mouthwatering wings that are hard to resist. I especially loved their signature cocktails—each sip was an adventure! The staff was attentive, making sure my glass was never empty. Whether you're catching a game or just unwinding with friends, Varsity Club strikes the perfect balance between fun and relaxation. If you're in New Berlin, this spot is a must-visit for anyone looking to enjoy a lively night out!

You might also want to check out the best liquor store in Milwaukee.

West Side Pub

Tucked away in the heart of New Berlin, West Side Pub is a delightful gem that immediately captivates with its inviting ambiance. The moment you step in, the friendly staff greets you like an old friend, amplifying the lively atmosphere. I was particularly impressed by their extensive beer selection, featuring both local crafts and beloved classics. The mouthwatering food menu is just an added bonus, especially their signature wings that pack a flavorful punch. Whether you're there to catch a game or unwind after a long day, this spot truly embodies the spirit of a community gathering place. Cheers to good times!

You might also want to check out the best singles bars in Milwaukee.

Greenfield Pub

Upon stepping into Greenfield Pub, I was instantly greeted by a cozy atmosphere and a vibrant crowd. The eclectic décor, infused with sports memorabilia, sets the perfect backdrop for catching a game. Their extensive drink menu features a delightful selection of local brews, and the bartenders craft each cocktail with flair. I highly recommend trying their signature Greenfield Mule—it’s a refreshing twist that dances on the palate! The food, from juicy burgers to crispy wings, perfectly complements the beverages. Overall, Greenfield Pub delivers a fantastic blend of fun and quality, making it a must-visit for locals and visitors alike!

You might also want to check out the best rooftop bars in Milwaukee.