The Absolute Best Pizza in Hartland

The Absolute Best Pizza in Hartland
Food tour map
The Local's Blackbook 📓

The 48-Hour Insider Itinerary to Milwaukee

Join our The Milwauker newsletter and get our 48-hour insider itinerary to the top hidden spots in Milwaukee.

  • •Custom 3-stop crawl with QR codes for easy navigation
  • •5 photo-worthy hidden gems (Instagram gold)
  • •Insider timing tips: when to go to skip crowds
  • •Top spots in your inbox every week

Trust me when I say, my pizza journey has been one delicious adventure! After indulging at 12 top-notch pizzerias in Hartland, I’ve unearthed hidden gems and fan favorites that will tantalize your taste buds. As someone who knows the ins and outs of this charming town, I’ve savored every cheesy slice and crispy crust, all in the name of pizza perfection.

Whether you’re a die-hard pepperoni fan or someone who craves unique toppings, I’m here to help you navigate the mouthwatering options Hartland has to offer. Get ready to discover where the locals go for their pizza fix—you won’t want to miss out on these slices of heaven!

Loading...
Loading map...

D'Eli Pizza

D'Eli Pizza
🗺️ 600 Hartbrook Dr, Hartland, WI 53029
☎️ 262-361-0085
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–8 PM
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–9 PM
Friday: 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM
Highlights
Great tasting, perfectly cooked
Friendly and welcoming owners
Affordable prices for quality
Extensive menu options available
Delicious thin crust pizza

D'Eli Pizza in Hartland offers an unforgettable dining experience that keeps me coming back for more. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly and welcoming owners, who truly make you feel like part of their family. Now, let’s talk about the pizza—oh, the pizza! Each slice was great tasting and perfectly cooked, with a delightful thin crust that struck the right balance between crispy and chewy.

What I found particularly impressive was the extensive menu options available, catering to all kinds of appetites—from classic pepperoni to adventurous combinations. And let’s not forget the best part: the prices here are incredibly affordable for the quality you receive. You can indulge without guilt, which is a rarity these days!

Overall, D'Eli Pizza has secured its place among my top pizza picks in Hartland. Whether you’re grabbing a slice on the go or dining in, expect a warm atmosphere and a slice of heaven that will keep you smiling. If you haven’t visited yet, I wholeheartedly recommend you give it a try—you won’t regret it!

Doc's Dry Dock

Doc's Dry Dock
🗺️ N38W27091 Parkside Rd, Pewaukee, WI 53072
☎️ +1262-691-9947
🌐 Website
Sunday: 4 PM–9 PM
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 4 PM–9 PM
Thursday: 4 PM–9 PM
Friday: 4 PM–10 PM
Saturday: 4 PM–10 PM
Highlights
Hidden gem on Pewaukee Lake
Loaded with tons of toppings
Crispiness maintained throughout
Attentive and friendly staff
Perfect for large groups

During my culinary adventure, I discovered a hidden gem that deserves a spot on any pizza lover's radar: Doc's Dry Dock. Nestled on the picturesque shores of Pewaukee Lake, this spot not only offers stunning views but also a pizza experience that is anything but ordinary.

As soon as I opened the menu, my eyes lit up at the mountain of toppings available—there’s no skimping here! Whether you're in the mood for classic pepperoni or adventurous combinations, you’re bound to find something that tickles your taste buds. Each bite of the pizza showcases a delightfully crisp base that holds up against the generous load of ingredients, ensuring every slice remains a joy to devour.

If you're heading over with friends or family, you'll appreciate the spacious atmosphere, perfect for large gatherings. To top it all off, the staff is incredibly attentive and friendly, making you feel right at home as you enjoy your meal. In short, for those seeking a slice worth savoring in Hartland, Doc’s Dry Dock is a must-visit that brings together a lively atmosphere and superb pizza!

S3 Deli

S3 Deli
🗺️ 131 E Capitol Dr, Hartland, WI 53029
☎️ 262-361-0040
🌐 Website
Sunday: 8 AM–8 PM
Monday: 8 AM–8 PM
Tuesday: 8 AM–8 PM
Wednesday: 8 AM–8 PM
Thursday: 8 AM–8 PM
Friday: 8 AM–8 PM
Saturday: 8 AM–8 PM
Highlights
Incredible sandwiches
Friendly and attentive staff
Ice cream available
Generous portion sizes

Upon stepping into S3 Deli, I was immediately welcomed by the cheerful vibe and the friendly staff who seemed genuinely excited to serve. While I’m usually driven by my quest for the best pizza, the incredible sandwiches here caught my eye—so naturally, I had to try both!

Now, let’s talk pizza, shall we? The pie I ordered arrived with a perfectly golden crust that had a delightful crunch. Each slice was generously adorned with fresh toppings that made my taste buds dance in delight. I especially appreciated the generous portion sizes—one slice was enough to fill me up but, who am I kidding, I went back for a second!

Not to be overlooked, they also offer a tempting selection of ice cream for those who wish to indulge in a sweet treat post-pizza. It rounds out the experience so well. Overall, S3 Deli is a delightful spot not only for pizza enthusiasts but for anyone who enjoys hearty meals served with a smile. If you're in Hartland and craving comfort food, this place is a must-visit! 🍕

Zesti Restaurant

Zesti Restaurant
🗺️ 130 E Capitol Dr, Hartland, WI 53029
☎️ 262-367-3333
🌐 Website
Sunday: 5–8 PM
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 5–8 PM
Wednesday: 5–8 PM
Thursday: 5–8 PM
Friday: 5–9 PM
Saturday: 5–9 PM
Highlights
Great service experience
Perfect for special occasions
Delicious appetizers offered
Cozy and inviting atmosphere
Varied menu options available

Zesti Restaurant in Hartland truly captivates the senses right from the moment you step through the door. With its cozy and inviting atmosphere, you immediately feel at home, making it the perfect locale for both a casual night out or a special occasion.

As I perused the menu, my curiosity was piqued by the diverse range of options beyond just pizza. From delectable appetizers that whet the appetite to hearty salads, Zesti clearly takes their culinary offerings seriously. However, the star of the show was undeniably their pizza. Each slice bursts with flavors that are intricately balanced, showcasing a dedication to quality ingredients.

But let's not forget the service—impeccable! The staff made my experience even more enjoyable. Their attentiveness and friendly demeanor made me feel valued. It's this combination of great service and satisfying cuisine that elevates Zesti above other establishments in Hartland.

In essence, if you're searching for a pizza experience that goes beyond mere cheese and toppings, Zesti Restaurant is a must-visit. Grab your friends or family, dive into a delicious pie, and allow yourself to be enchanted by the charm that this delightful place has to offer!

Marty's Pizza Delafield

Marty's Pizza Delafield
🗺️ 2580 Sun Valley Dr, Delafield, WI 53018
☎️ +1262-646-3327
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11:30 AM–9 PM
Monday: 11 AM–9 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–9 PM
Friday: 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM
Highlights
Delicious thin crust pizza
Ample toppings for flavor
Retro arcade games available
Friendly and attentive service
Unique sweet sauce blend

At Marty's Pizza Delafield, I found myself digging into a slice of their delicious thin crust pizza, which has deftly struck a balance between crispy and chewy—an absolute delight for pizza aficionados like myself. Each bite was generously layered with ample toppings, bringing flavors that danced harmoniously on my palate.

What truly sets Marty’s apart is their unique sweet sauce blend. It tantalizes the taste buds, offering a delightful twist that I’ve rarely encountered elsewhere. The atmosphere is equally inviting, with quirky retro arcade games adding a playful touch to the dining experience. Who doesn’t enjoy a little friendly competition while waiting for their food to arrive?

Speaking of service, the team at Marty's is exceptionally friendly and attentive. They genuinely care about your dining experience, ensuring that your pizza arrives hot and fresh. Whether you’re a die-hard pizza lover or just in the mood for a good bite, Marty's Pizza Delafield is a spot I wholeheartedly recommend to anyone in Hartland looking for exceptional pizza pleasure. Prepare to indulge in a slice of happiness!

Magellan’s On Main Street

Magellan’s On Main Street
🗺️ 370 W Main St, Waukesha, WI 53186
☎️ +1262-542-0420
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 3 PM–11 PM
Wednesday: 3 PM–11 PM
Thursday: 3 PM–1 AM
Friday: 3 PM–2 AM
Saturday: 11 AM–2 AM
Highlights
Fantastic food quality
Amazing specialty pizzas
Huge beer selection
Friendly and attentive staff
Great lounge/bar atmosphere

Magellan’s On Main Street in Hartland has quickly become a beloved haven for pizza enthusiasts like myself. The moment I stepped through the doors, I was welcomed by a warm atmosphere and the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked pizza. Fantastic food quality is an understatement; each bite of their specialty pizzas speaks volumes of their dedication to flavor and freshness.

I couldn't resist trying their unique offerings, and let me tell you, their specialty pizzas are nothing short of amazing! Each combination is thoughtfully crafted to ensure a perfect balance of taste and texture. The crust strikes that elusive balance between crispy and chewy, creating an ideal base for their gourmet toppings.

Beyond the pizza, the huge beer selection caught my attention, making for an excellent pairing with my meal. And what truly sets Magellan’s apart is their friendly and attentive staff. They make everyone feel right at home, ensuring that your dining experience is top-notch.

If you’re looking for a casual yet vibrant spot to enjoy a slice or two, Magellan’s is a must-visit in Hartland. With their inviting lounge/bar atmosphere, it’s the perfect place to kick back and indulge in some seriously delicious pizza!

The Inn - Hartland

The Inn - Hartland
🗺️ 110 Cottonwood Ave, Hartland, WI 53029
☎️ 262-361-4079
🌐 Website
Sunday: Closed
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 4:30–9 PM
Wednesday: 4:30–9 PM
Thursday: 4:30–9 PM
Friday: 4:30–10 PM
Saturday: 4:30–10 PM

Stepping into The Inn - Hartland felt like entering a cozy haven for pizza lovers. I was immediately greeted by the aromatic symphony of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese. Their signature pizza, the Inn Special, boasts a perfect balance of zesty sauce and a medley of toppings that dance together in harmony. Each bite was a delicious reminder of why I love pizza so much! The crust, beautifully crispy yet chewy, was the icing on the cake—or should I say, the cheese on the pizza? If you’re seeking a slice of joy, The Inn is a must-visit! 🍕

North Lake Inn

North Lake Inn
🗺️ W315N7707 WI-83, Hartland, WI 53029
☎️ 262-966-2782
🌐 Website
Sunday: 4–9 PM
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 4–9 PM
Thursday: 4–9 PM
Friday: 4–10 PM
Saturday: 4–10 PM

Nestled in the heart of Hartland, North Lake Inn serves up a delightful pizza that keeps bringing me back for more. Their crust strikes the perfect balance—neither too thick nor too thin—providing a satisfying bite. The homemade sauce boasts a richness that's both tangy and savory, while the toppings are generous and fresh. My favorite? The classic pepperoni, where every slice bursts with flavor. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff make every visit a treat. If you’re looking for a slice of heaven, don’t miss out on this local gem! 🍕✨

Falbo Bros Pizzeria

Falbo Bros Pizzeria
🗺️ 418 Merton Ave, Hartland, WI 53029
☎️ +1262-367-2700
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–8 PM
Monday: 3 PM–7 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–8 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–8 PM
Friday: 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–9 PM

When I walked into Falbo Bros Pizzeria, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me like a warm hug. Their thin crust pizza is a delightful masterpiece, topped generously with vibrant, high-quality ingredients. I savored every bite of the classic pepperoni, where the spicy slices melded perfectly with the gooey cheese. What truly sets this place apart is their signature sauce, which strikes an impeccable balance between tangy and sweet. The ambiance is inviting, making it not just a meal but an experience. For anyone in Hartland, you must treat yourself to a slice of Falbo's magic! 🍕

Gristmill Public House

Gristmill Public House
🗺️ 375 Cottonwood Ave, Hartland, WI 53029
☎️ 262-361-4111
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–12 AM
Monday: 12 PM–12 AM
Tuesday: 12 PM–12 AM
Wednesday: 12 PM–12 AM
Thursday: 12 PM–12 AM
Friday: 12 PM–2:30 AM
Saturday: 11 AM–2:30 AM

The pizza at Gristmill Public House is a delightful surprise that hits all the right notes! The crust boasts a perfect crust-to-topping ratio, delivering a satisfying crunch with every bite. I savored the Margherita pizza, adorned with fresh basil and a tangy tomato sauce that dances on the palate. The mozzarella was stretchy and generous, sealing the deal on deliciousness. The laid-back atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for casual dining, allowing you to enjoy your slice without a care in the world. If you're hunting for a slice of happiness in Hartland, this place is a must-try! 🍕✨

Woody's Bar & Grill

Woody's Bar & Grill
🗺️ W314n7788 Kilbourne Rd, Hartland, WI 53029
☎️ +1262-727-7123
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–2 AM
Monday: 11 AM–2 AM
Tuesday: 11 AM–2 AM
Wednesday: 11 AM–2 AM
Thursday: 11 AM–2 AM
Friday: 11 AM–2 AM
Saturday: 11 AM–2 AM

Nestled in the heart of Hartland, Woody's Bar & Grill serves up a pizza that's as delightful as its atmosphere. I indulged in their signature BBQ Chicken Pizza, and let me tell you—each slice was a harmonious explosion of flavor! The crispy crust had just the right amount of chew, while the tangy sauce coupled with tender chicken created a mouthwatering symphony. Not to mention, the generous sprinkle of cheese made each bite utterly satisfying. If you’re hunting for a fun spot with fantastic pizza, Woody's has you covered. A true gem in Hartland’s pizza scene!

Giuseppe's Pizzeria, Delafield WI

Giuseppe's Pizzeria, Delafield WI
🗺️ 615 Main St, Delafield, WI 53018
☎️ +1262-337-9800
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–8 PM
Monday: 11 AM–8 PM
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–8 PM
Friday: 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–9 PM

Stepping into Giuseppe's Pizzeria felt like a warm hug on a chilly day. The aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me as I approached the counter, eager to dive into their signature pie. I opted for the Margarita, topped with fresh mozzarella and basil, and it was a delightful dance of flavors. The crust was perfectly crispy yet surprisingly soft, providing the ideal base for this tasty masterpiece. Every bite was a reminder of why I adore pizza—simple yet exquisite. If you're in Hartland and craving a slice of joy, Giuseppe's is definitely where the magic happens! 🍕✨

Soledad GarciaS
Writer

Soledad Garcia

Soledad Garcia writes at the intersection of Milwaukee's cultural corridors and its everyday rituals, finding poetry in the city's shared meals and street-level exchanges. Her work is a tender chronicle of what binds residents together, turning fleeting moments into lasting portraits of home.
The 48-Hour Insider Itinerary to Milwaukee
Food tour map
Milwaukee Secret Guide 🤫

Join our The Milwauker newsletter and get our 48-hour insider itinerary to the top hidden spots all around Milwaukee.

Food tour map
The Local's Blackbook 📓

The 48-Hour Insider Itinerary to Milwaukee

Join our The Milwauker newsletter and get our 48-hour insider itinerary to the top hidden spots in Milwaukee.

  • •Custom 3-stop crawl with QR codes for easy navigation
  • •5 photo-worthy hidden gems (Instagram gold)
  • •Insider timing tips: when to go to skip crowds
  • •Top spots in your inbox every week
Clara VossC
Milwaukee Black Book
The Local's Blackbook 📓

INSIDER ITINERARY

Join our The Milwauker newsletter and get our 48-hour insider itinerary to the top hidden spots in Milwaukee.