The Absolute Best Pizza in Germantown

The Absolute Best Pizza in Germantown
Food tour map
The Local's Blackbook 📓

The 48-Hour Insider Itinerary to Milwaukee

Join our The Milwauker newsletter and get our 48-hour insider itinerary to the top hidden spots in Milwaukee.

  • •Custom 3-stop crawl with QR codes for easy navigation
  • •5 photo-worthy hidden gems (Instagram gold)
  • •Insider timing tips: when to go to skip crowds
  • •Top spots in your inbox every week

Each slice tells a story, and trust me, I’ve tasted my way through a dozen of Germantown’s top spots to find the absolute best. Picture this: crispy crusts, gooey cheese, and toppings that make your taste buds dance. As someone who’s savored every cheesy bite, I’ve become something of a local aficionado, and I can’t wait to share my discoveries with you.

What sets my recommendations apart? Well, I’ve gone beyond just the flavors—I’ve soaked in the ambiance, the service, and that all-important vibe that makes a pizzeria truly special. Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni or adventurous gourmet options, I’ve got the inside scoop to elevate your next pizza night!

Loading...
Loading map...

Brama's Pizzeria

Brama's Pizzeria
🗺️ N112W16700 Mequon Rd, Germantown, WI 53022
☎️ +1262-735-4602
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–9 PM
Friday: 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM
Highlights
Small portion sizes
Burnt breadsticks
Bland pizza flavors
Kind service
Disappointing value

At Brama's Pizzeria, my enthusiasm soon turned into a mixed platter of emotions. While the staff was undeniably kind, making me feel welcomed from the moment I walked in, the excitement started to wane once I dove into the food. The small portion sizes left me feeling like I’d just sampled a teaser rather than indulging in a satisfying meal.

The burnt breadsticks were a surprising letdown; I was hoping for a delightful appetizer, but these were more charred than charming. As for the pizza itself, the flavors fell disappointingly flat. Each bite, which I hoped would burst with flavor, instead reminded me of some long-lost bland affair that failed to ignite any oomph.

Though Brama's boasts an atmosphere filled with warmth and friendly service, the overall value left me feeling rather deflated. I had high hopes for the best pizza experience in Germantown, but Brama's fell short. If you’re in search of a delightful slice, you might want to explore other nooks in Germantown before settling down here. Pizza is meant to charm, and sadly, this one doesn’t quite make the cut.

Das Barrel Room

Das Barrel Room
🗺️ W201N10466 Appleton Ave, Germantown, WI 53022
☎️ +1262-252-9118
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–10 PM
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 3 PM–2 AM
Wednesday: 3 PM–2 AM
Thursday: 3 PM–2 AM
Friday: 11 AM–2:30 AM
Saturday: 11 AM–2:30 AM
Highlights
Great live music events
Comfortable, well-kept decor
Outstanding customer service
Reasonable pricing
Spacious outdoor patio

Das Barrel Room in Germantown is not just a pizza place; it's a vibrant culinary haven! From the moment I stepped inside, I was enveloped by a warm ambiance and welcomed by their outstanding customer service. The decor strikes the perfect balance between rustic charm and modern aesthetics, creating a cozy spot to enjoy a slice or two.

What truly caught my attention, however, was the incredible selection of pizzas. Each bite reveals a perfect crust—crispy on the outside with a wonderfully chewy interior. The toppings are fresh, vibrant, and generously portioned. As I savored my pizza, the live music in the background provided the perfect soundtrack to a delightful dining experience.

And let’s talk about the pricing! It’s surprisingly affordable considering the quality of the food. Plus, if the weather permits, dining on their spacious outdoor patio is an experience in itself, making it an ideal spot for both casual evenings or special gatherings.

In summary, Das Barrel Room brilliantly fuses great pizza with an inviting atmosphere—definitely a must-visit for anyone seeking the best pizza in Germantown! 🍕 Cheers to that!

Precinct Tap & Table

Precinct Tap & Table
🗺️ W161N11629 Church St, Germantown, WI 53022
☎️ +1262-415-5680
🌐 Website
Sunday: Closed
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 4 PM–9 PM
Thursday: 4 PM–9 PM
Friday: 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–9 PM
Highlights
Delicious and varied menu
Fun atmosphere
Friendly and attentive service
Exceptional food combinations
Perfect for social gatherings

Review of Precinct Tap & Table

During my quest for the best pizza in Germantown, I found myself at Precinct Tap & Table, and let me tell you, it was a delightful adventure! The fun atmosphere wraps you in a cozy embrace, perfect for both casual hangouts and lively gatherings with friends. As soon as I entered, the friendly and attentive service made me feel right at home.

Now, let’s get to the good stuff—the pizza. The menu features a variety of exquisite options that invite your taste buds to explore. I opted for the “Precinct Special,” which showcased exceptional food combinations that balanced savory and zesty flavors. The crust struck a perfect balance between crispy and chewy—a hallmark of a great pizza!

Not to mention, the vibrant ambiance added to the whole experience, making it an ideal spot for sharing slices and laughter. Precinct Tap & Table is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a cheerful gathering place. If you find yourself in Germantown, don’t miss the chance to grab a slice—you might just discover your new favorite pizza! 🍕

Old Germantown

Old Germantown
🗺️ W148N12696 Pleasant View Dr, Germantown, WI 53022, United States
☎️ +1262-345-5961
🌐 Website
Sunday: 12 PM–6 PM
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 4 PM–8:30 PM
Friday: 4 PM–8:30 PM
Saturday: 12 PM–8:30 PM

During my visit to Old Germantown, I was greeted by the warm aroma of fresh dough and zesty tomato sauce. The Crust? Perfectly crispy with just the right amount of chew—definitely a highlight! I indulged in their classic Margherita, where the balance of fresh basil, mozzarella, and tangy sauce danced on my palate. Each slice felt like a flavorful hug, and I couldn’t resist going back for seconds. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff added to the charm. If you’re on the hunt for pizza that evokes nostalgia with a modern twist, Old Germantown should be at the top of your list! 🍕

STAGS Tavern

STAGS Tavern
🗺️ W187N12793 Fond du Lac Ave, Germantown, WI 53022
☎️ +1262-677-1994
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–11 PM
Monday: 11 AM–12 AM
Tuesday: 11 AM–12 AM
Wednesday: 11 AM–12 AM
Thursday: 11 AM–12 AM
Friday: 11 AM–12 AM
Saturday: 11 AM–12 AM

STAGS Tavern in Germantown charms with its inviting ambiance and hearty menu, but the real star is its pizza! Baked to perfection, the crust has that delightful crunch while remaining soft and chewy. I savored the Stag Supreme, loaded with fresh toppings that sang in harmony. Each bite was a flavor fiesta! The rich tomato sauce was balanced beautifully, and the generous sprinkle of cheese had me dreaming of my next slice. If you’re seeking a fun atmosphere to indulge in a mouthwatering pizza, STAGS is your go-to spot! 🍕✨ Don’t miss it!

DeMarinis Pizzeria

DeMarinis Pizzeria
🗺️ N88W15229 Main St, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
☎️ +1262-253-1566
🌐 Website
Sunday: 4 PM–9 PM
Monday: 4 PM–9 PM
Tuesday: 4 PM–9 PM
Wednesday: 4 PM–9 PM
Thursday: 4 PM–9 PM
Friday: 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday: Closed

De Marinis Pizzeria is a hidden gem in Germantown that serves up slices worth savoring. The thin, crispy crust was a delightful surprise, perfectly charred and incredibly flavorful. I indulged in their signature Margherita, which featured fresh mozzarella and basil that danced harmoniously on my palate. The homemade sauce is a standout, bursting with robust tomato flavor. Add in the welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, and you’ve got a recipe for pizza perfection. Overall, De Marinis is a must-try for anyone seeking a delicious slice in Germantown—one bite and you’ll understand why locals rave about it!

Rosati's Pizza

Rosati's Pizza
🗺️ N112W15800 Mequon Rd, Germantown, WI 53022
☎️ +1262-345-4303
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM
Monday: 11 AM–9 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–9 PM
Friday: 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–9 PM

Rosati's Pizza in Germantown truly delivers a slice of heaven! The sauce has a delightful blend of spices that dances on your tongue, while the crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. Their signature deep-dish is a comforting hug of gooey cheese and toppings galore. I couldn’t resist trying their specialty pies, each bursting with flavor that keeps you coming back for more. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff make this spot a must-visit for any pizza lover. For an authentic experience and mouthwatering options, Rosati's is undeniably a top contender in the quest for the best pizza in Germantown! 🍕

Marko's Pizza

Marko's Pizza
🗺️ W156N9664 Pilgrim Rd, Germantown, WI 53022
☎️ +1262-251-1555
🌐 Website
Sunday: 4 PM–8 PM
Monday: 4 PM–8 PM
Tuesday: 4 PM–8 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–8 PM
Friday: 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday: 4 PM–9 PM

Marko's Pizza in Germantown is a delightful slice of heaven! The crispy crust cradles a generous layer of zesty marinara and molten cheese that melts in your mouth. Each bite is a savory burst of flavor, with toppings that are both fresh and supportively balanced. The cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect spot to indulge in this pizza paradise. Don't skip the garlic knots—they're the ideal companion to your pizza adventure. If you're seeking a flavor-packed experience, Marko's is a must-try that will have you coming back for more! 🍕✨

Carol Ann's Pizza LLC

Carol Ann's Pizza LLC
🗺️ 2935 Hubertus Rd, Hubertus, WI 53033
☎️ +1262-628-8237
🌐 Website
Sunday: 4 PM–7 PM
Monday: 4 PM–7 PM
Tuesday: 4 PM–7 PM
Wednesday: 4 PM–7 PM
Thursday: 4 PM–7 PM
Friday: 4 PM–8 PM
Saturday: 4 PM–8 PM

At Carol Ann's Pizza LLC, each bite is a delightful adventure! The crust strikes a perfect balance between crispy and chewy, while their sauce bursts with a zesty freshness. I tried the Margarita Pizza, topped with vibrant basil, and it transported me straight to Italy with its vibrant flavors. The generous cheese melts harmoniously, creating an unforgettable experience. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff add to its charm, making it a perfect spot for a casual pizza night. If you’re hunting for some of the best pizza in Germantown, Carol Ann's is certainly worth a visit—your taste buds will thank you!

Pepino's

Pepino's
🗺️ N84W15841 Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
☎️ +1262-251-6500
🌐 Website
Sunday: 4 PM–8 PM
Monday: 4 PM–8 PM
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 4 PM–8 PM
Thursday: 4 PM–8 PM
Friday: 4 PM–9 PM
Saturday: 4 PM–9 PM

At Pepino's, the aroma hits you before you even walk through the door, teasing your taste buds with promises of deliciousness. The thin-crust pizza, topped with fresh ingredients, is nothing short of spectacular. I particularly savored the margherita, with its vibrant basil and zesty tomato sauce that danced on my palate. The balance of melted mozzarella and a hint of garlic made each slice an irresistible treat. Truly, this cozy gem captures the essence of authentic pizzeria culture. If you're searching for the best pizza in Germantown, let Pepino's be your next stop; you won't be disappointed!

The Stillery - Richfield

The Stillery - Richfield
🗺️ W204N14025 Fond du Lac Ave, Richfield, WI 53076
☎️ +1262-674-2033
🌐 Website
Sunday: 11 AM–10 PM
Monday: 11 AM–10 PM
Tuesday: 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday: 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday: 11 AM–10 PM
Friday: 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday: 11 AM–11 PM

The Stillery - Richfield is a delightful gem in Germantown that takes pizza to a whole new level! I indulged in their signature Stillery Pie, a masterful blend of fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The crust was perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of chew. Topped with a rich tomato sauce and a generous layer of gooey cheese, it felt like a warm hug for my taste buds. The ambiance is vibrant, making it an ideal spot for a fun night out. If you’re in the mood for pizza that sparks joy, The Stillery is a must-visit!

Von Rothenburg Bier Stube

Von Rothenburg Bier Stube
🗺️ N116W15863 Main St, Germantown, WI 53022, United States
🌐 Website
Sunday: 12 PM–7 PM
Monday: 3 PM–9 PM
Tuesday: 3 PM–9 PM
Wednesday: 3 PM–9 PM
Thursday: 3 PM–9 PM
Friday: 12 PM–10 PM
Saturday: 12 PM–10 PM

From the moment I stepped into Von Rothenburg Bier Stube, I was enveloped in a warm, rustic charm that perfectly paired with their phenomenal pizza selection. Their Haus Pizza, boasting a crispy crust and a delightful medley of fresh toppings, was an absolute standout. Each bite transported me straight to Italy, with the rich tomato sauce and perfectly melted cheese dancing delightfully on my palate. The inviting atmosphere, complemented by a fine selection of beers, makes this spot not just a place to dine, but to savor. If you're hunting for a slice of heaven in Germantown, Von Rothenburg is a must-visit!

Glen KuvalisG
Writer

Glen Kuvalis

Glen Kuvalis tracks Milwaukee's civic pulse with a data-driven eye, translating budgets and policy into plain-spoken narratives that resonate beyond City Hall. His work pairs relentless accountability with a dry wit, turning dense municipal minutiae into stories that read like dispatches from the neighborhood.
The 48-Hour Insider Itinerary to Milwaukee
Food tour map
Milwaukee Secret Guide 🤫

Join our The Milwauker newsletter and get our 48-hour insider itinerary to the top hidden spots all around Milwaukee.

Food tour map
The Local's Blackbook 📓

The 48-Hour Insider Itinerary to Milwaukee

Join our The Milwauker newsletter and get our 48-hour insider itinerary to the top hidden spots in Milwaukee.

  • •Custom 3-stop crawl with QR codes for easy navigation
  • •5 photo-worthy hidden gems (Instagram gold)
  • •Insider timing tips: when to go to skip crowds
  • •Top spots in your inbox every week
Clara VossC
Milwaukee Black Book
The Local's Blackbook 📓

INSIDER ITINERARY

Join our The Milwauker newsletter and get our 48-hour insider itinerary to the top hidden spots in Milwaukee.